· Agency action
In the Matter of BetterHelp, Inc.
Federal Trade Commission, FTC Docket No. C-4796
Primary source: Decision and order. Checked on November 10, 2026.
The FTC barred BetterHelp from disclosing health information for advertising and required it to pay $7.8 million for partial consumer refunds, over charges it shared email addresses, IP addresses and intake answers with advertising platforms.
What happened
BetterHelp, Inc. runs an online counseling service, including versions aimed at Christian, LGBTQ and teenage users, that matches people with licensed therapists. The Commission's complaint alleged that to sign up, a visitor had to complete an intake questionnaire with detailed questions about mental health, and that the company repeatedly promised to keep this health information private. (Compl. paras. 2, 4, 10-13.)
The complaint alleged that from 2013 to December 2020 the company used and disclosed visitors' and users' email addresses, IP addresses and certain questionnaire answers for advertising, through pixels on its websites, by uploading email lists to Facebook, and by disclosing email addresses or IP addresses to Snapchat, Criteo and Pinterest. It alleged, for example, that pixel events told Facebook that more than 1.5 million visitors and users had been in therapy before, and that the company uploaded over 7 million email addresses to Facebook in 2017 and 2018. (Compl. paras. 45-47, 52-53, 55.)
The complaint alleged that the company hashed email addresses before sending them, but only to guard against a security breach, and that Facebook used the hashed addresses to match people to their accounts. It also alleged that a cookie banner added in September 2020 said the company never sells or rents information, that the privacy policy link was small and low-contrast, and that the company displayed HIPAA seals although no government agency or other third party had reviewed its practices. (Compl. paras. 34-37, 49, 65-67.)
BetterHelp neither admitted nor denied the allegations. The notice the order requires the company to send users states that it did not share messages, session data, journal entries or other communications between users and their therapists with these companies. The Commission voted 3-0 to finalize the complaint and order after reviewing 123 comments. (Decision and Order at 1, 22; FTC release, July 14, 2023.)
What the agency did
The order bans BetterHelp from disclosing Treatment Information to third parties for advertising, and from disclosing other personal information for targeting the consumer it concerns. Treatment Information includes information about a consumer's use of the service, account creation or questionnaire answers. (Decision and Order at 6 (Definition K; Provision I))
information concerning the consumer’s use of, creation of an account associated with, or response to a question or questionnaire related to, a service or product offered by Respondent
Decision and Order at 6 (Definition K.3) Before disclosing any consumer's personal information to a third party, BetterHelp must obtain affirmative express consent, defined as a freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous indication of agreement following a clear and conspicuous disclosure separate from any privacy policy or terms. Consent inferred from closing content, or obtained through an interface that subverts user choice, does not count. (Decision and Order at 2-3, 7 (Definition A; Provision II))
The Clear and Conspicuous disclosure must be separate from any “privacy policy,” “terms of service,” “terms of use,” or other similar document.
Decision and Order at 2 (Definition A) The complaint charged that disclosing an email address collected only from people seeking therapy identified them as seeking mental health treatment, so the disclosure was a disclosure of health information. (Compl. paras. 3, 48)
disclosure of a Visitor’s or User’s email address implicitly identified the Visitor or User as one seeking and/or receiving mental health treatment via the Service
Compl. para. 48 The complaint charged that hashing the email addresses did not hide identities from the recipients, because Facebook matched them to user IDs as its terms said it would. (Compl. para. 49)
the hashing was not meant to conceal the Visitors’ and Users’ identities from Facebook or the other recipient third parties
Compl. para. 49 The order bars misrepresentations about BetterHelp's data practices, including whether it is HIPAA-covered and whether its practices comply with HIPAA, and requires it to instruct third parties that received personal information without affirmative express consent to delete it. (Decision and Order at 7-8 (Provisions III, IV))
The order requires a privacy program that includes audits, reviews or testing of each mechanism through which the company discloses personal information to third parties, with independent assessments every two years for 20 years. (Decision and Order at 9-12 (Provisions VI, VII))
(including but not limited to web beacons, pixels, and Software Development Kits)
Decision and Order at 11 (Provision VI.E.8) BetterHelp had to pay $7.8 million to the Commission, which the order allows the Commission to use for consumer redress. (Decision and Order at 15 (Provisions XI, XII.D))
Respondent must pay to the Commission $7,800,000
Decision and Order at 15 (Provision XI.A) BetterHelp neither admitted nor denied the complaint's allegations, except as stated in the order, and admitted only the facts needed for jurisdiction. (Decision and Order at 1)
neither admits nor denies any of the allegations in the Complaint
Decision and Order at 1
What it did not decide
- Whether BetterHelp in fact violated the FTC Act; the order resolves the charges without findings on the merits. (Decision and Order at 1-2.)
- Any claim under the federal Wiretap Act, a state wiretap or privacy statute or a state consumer-protection statute; the complaint charged only violations of Section 5 of the FTC Act. (Compl. paras. 77-100.)
- A Health Breach Notification Rule violation; none was charged, and the order labels the $7.8 million monetary relief that the Commission may use for consumer redress, not a civil penalty. (Decision and Order at 15.)
- Whether BetterHelp is covered by HIPAA; the complaint alleged that hundreds of its therapists are not subject to HIPAA and that the company did not know which data the law protected. (Compl. para. 68.)
The tracking involved
Tools
- Pixels (web beacons) on the company's websites sending events to Facebook
- Email address lists uploaded to Facebook
- Disclosures of email addresses or IP addresses to Snapchat, Criteo and Pinterest
Data
- Email addresses, hashed before upload
- IP addresses
- Intake questionnaire answers, including prior therapy and financial status
- Account sign-up and paid enrollment events
How it bears on website tracking claims
Supports: strengthens a website tracking claim on this issue. Limits: narrows or defeats a website tracking claim on this issue. Context: bears on the issue without deciding it either way.
Context: Consumer protection
Deception and unfair practice claims, such as under the FTC Act and N.Y. General Business Law § 349.
The FTC charged under Section 5 of the FTC Act that disclosing health information to advertising platforms, contrary to BetterHelp's privacy statements and without affirmative express consent, was deceptive and unfair, and it obtained an advertising ban and $7.8 million (Compl. paras. 77-100; Decision and Order at 6, 15). It shows the FTC acting against the kind of data flow a website-tracking claim describes. The order is a negotiated settlement without findings, and it does not decide any state consumer-protection statute such as N.Y. General Business Law § 349.
Context: Health information
What counts as individually identifiable health information when it is sent through tracking tools.
The complaint treated an email address, or an IP address sent with data about enrollment or questionnaire answers, as health information because it revealed that the person was seeking therapy through the service (Compl. paras. 3, 48, 50). The order's definition of Treatment Information likewise covers account creation and questionnaire answers (Decision and Order at 6). These are the FTC's allegations and a definition binding BetterHelp, not a court's ruling on what counts as health information under HIPAA or a wiretap statute.
Context: Consent
Whether visitors agreed to the tracking through banners, privacy policies or terms.
The complaint alleged that a cookie banner and a hard-to-see privacy policy link did not tell visitors their health information would be used or disclosed for advertising (Compl. paras. 34-39). The order's definition of affirmative express consent requires a disclosure separate from any privacy policy or terms and rejects consent inferred from closing content or obtained through interfaces that subvert choice (Decision and Order at 2-3). That standard binds BetterHelp under the FTC Act; it does not define consent under the Wiretap Act or state law.
Context: HIPAA
How HIPAA, its criminal provision at 42 U.S.C. § 1320d-6 and HHS guidance bear on tracking.
The complaint alleged that BetterHelp displayed HIPAA seals and told consumers it was HIPAA certified, although no agency or other third party had reviewed its practices, and that hundreds of its therapists were not subject to HIPAA (Compl. paras. 65-69). The order bars misrepresenting HIPAA status or compliance (Decision and Order at 7). The matter does not apply HIPAA's privacy rules or 42 U.S.C. § 1320d-6.
Context: Standing and injury
Whether the people suing were harmed in a way that lets a federal court hear the claim.
The complaint alleged that disclosing this health information was likely to cause stigma, embarrassment or emotional distress, and that users paid a price premium based on the privacy promises (Compl. paras. 73-74). These are the FTC's unfairness allegations; the matter did not involve Article III standing or any individual consumer's claim.
Arguments it addresses
- The email addresses were hashed
- The complaint alleged the hashing guarded only against a security breach and that Facebook matched the hashed addresses to user IDs, as its terms said it would (Compl. para. 49).
- An email or IP address is not health information
- The complaint alleged that an email address collected only from people seeking therapy, or an IP address sent with data about enrollment or questionnaire answers, revealed that the person was seeking mental health treatment (Compl. paras. 48, 50).
- The visitor agreed to the privacy policy
- The complaint alleged the policy link was small and low-contrast and that the policy did not mention advertising use until September 2019 or advertising disclosure until September 2020, and the order requires consent through a disclosure separate from any privacy policy (Compl. paras. 34, 41-43; Decision and Order at 2).
- The cookie banner disclosed advertising cookies
- The complaint alleged that even BetterHelp's May 2021 banner, which mentioned targeting ads, did not tell visitors their health information would be used or disclosed for advertising (Compl. para. 38).
- The event names were coded, so the platform could not read them
- The complaint alleged that BetterHelp coded a prior-therapy answer as AddToWishlist but that an employee told Facebook what the event meant (Compl. para. 54).
- A consent order is not a finding of liability
- That is correct here: BetterHelp neither admitted nor denied the allegations, and the order's findings cover only the company's identity, jurisdiction and the public interest (Decision and Order at 1-2).
For a company that received a letter
- The BetterHelp order is a negotiated FTC settlement without findings, so it shows the agency's position and the remedies it obtained, not a court's ruling on any private claim.
- The complaint focused on what identifiers revealed in context: an email address or IP address sent from a therapy sign-up flow was alleged to reveal that a person sought treatment.
- The complaint addressed hashed email addresses, coded event names and a cookie banner, and alleged specific facts about each: Facebook matched the hashes, an employee explained a code, and the banners did not say that health information would be used or disclosed for advertising.
What to check on your own site
- Check whether sign-up, intake or questionnaire steps fire advertising events, and which identifiers, such as email addresses, IP addresses or cookie IDs, travel with them.
- Check whether any email or customer lists, hashed or not, are uploaded to advertising platforms, and which forms those lists come from.
- Compare the cookie banner and privacy policy with what the tags actually send, including any use of health-related answers for advertising.
Later history
On May 6, 2024, the FTC announced that about 800,000 people would begin receiving refund notices from an independent administrator. The FTC's refund page states that the first payments, sent in June 2024, totaled nearly $5.2 million, and, in an April 2025 update, that the administrator was sending a second round of payments totaling over $2.6 million to more than 534,000 people who accepted their first payment.
Related rulings
Published by Privacy Resolve from public records. It does not cover our own matters.
General information only, not legal advice, and not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Laws, deadlines, defenses and outcomes vary by jurisdiction and facts.