· Agency action
Health Breach Notification Rule, 16 C.F.R. Part 318 (final rule)
Federal Trade Commission, 89 Fed. Reg. 47028 (May 30, 2024)
Primary source: FTC announcement. Checked on November 10, 2026.
The FTC amended its Health Breach Notification Rule to clarify that it reaches health apps and similar technologies outside HIPAA and that an unauthorized disclosure, not only a security intrusion, can be a breach.
What happened
The Health Breach Notification Rule carries out a 2009 statute. It requires vendors of personal health records and related entities that are not covered by HIPAA to notify affected individuals, the FTC and, in some cases, the media after a breach of unsecured identifiable health information. The FTC announced the amendments on April 26, 2024, published them in the Federal Register on May 30, 2024, and made them effective July 29, 2024.
The amendments define a covered health care provider to include any entity furnishing health care services or supplies. Those services or supplies are any online service, such as a website, app or connected device, that provides mechanisms to track diseases, conditions, treatment, medications, symptoms, fitness, fertility, sexual health, sleep, mental health, diet and other listed matters, or that provides other health-related services or tools. The amendments also state that a breach of security includes an unauthorized acquisition resulting from a data breach or an unauthorized disclosure, and they expand what a notice must say, including the identity of third parties that acquired the information.
Explaining the rule, the Commission said health information generated from tracking technologies on websites or apps can be PHR identifiable health information. It said persistent identifiers combined with health information qualify if they can identify or re-identify a person, and that a health app's disclosures to advertising platforms that break its privacy promises are unauthorized. It also said a purely informational health website is not a personal health record, and that a vendor must offer something relating more than tangentially to health.
The Commission approved the final rule by a 3-2 vote. Commissioners Holyoak and Ferguson dissented, arguing that the new definitions of covered health care provider, health care services or supplies and personal health record go beyond the statute.
What the agency did
The rule now states that a breach of security includes an unauthorized acquisition of unsecured PHR identifiable health information that results from an unauthorized disclosure, not only from a data breach. (16 C.F.R. § 318.2; 89 Fed. Reg. at 47054)
A breach of security includes an unauthorized acquisition of unsecured PHR identifiable health information in a personal health record that occurs as a result of a data breach or an unauthorized disclosure.
89 Fed. Reg. at 47054 (16 C.F.R. § 318.2) The Commission declined to define authorization, saying an affirmative express consent requirement would not be appropriate in all cases. It said a disclosure is authorized only when it is consistent with the company's disclosures and consumers' reasonable expectations and there is meaningful choice, and that buried disclosures do not suffice. (89 Fed. Reg. at 47041)
buried disclosures do not suffice
89 Fed. Reg. at 47041 In its examples, a medication app's disclosure of health information to third parties for advertising and advertising-related analytics, contrary to its privacy promises, is unauthorized, while clearly disclosed sharing with contractually limited service providers for functions the app needs is authorized. (89 Fed. Reg. at 47042)
These disclosures are not authorized under the Rule because they are inconsistent with consumer expectations
89 Fed. Reg. at 47042 The rule defines health care services or supplies as any online service, such as a website, app or connected device, that provides mechanisms to track listed health matters or that provides other health-related services or tools. An entity furnishing such services or supplies is therefore a covered health care provider under the rule. (16 C.F.R. § 318.2; 89 Fed. Reg. at 47055)
Health care services or supplies means any online service such as a website, mobile application, or internet-connected device that provides mechanisms to track diseases, health conditions, diagnoses or diagnostic testing, treatment, medications
89 Fed. Reg. at 47055 (16 C.F.R. § 318.2) The Commission said unique persistent identifiers combined with health information are PHR identifiable health information if they can identify or re-identify a person, and that data de-identified under HHS standards is not identifiable. (89 Fed. Reg. at 47034)
unique, persistent identifiers (such as unique device and mobile advertising identifiers), when combined with health information, constitute “PHR identifiable health information,” if these identifiers can be used to identify or re-identify an individual.
89 Fed. Reg. at 47034 The rule does not apply to HIPAA-covered entities, or to other entities to the extent they act as business associates of HIPAA-covered entities, which must follow HHS's breach notification rule instead. (16 C.F.R. § 318.1(a); 89 Fed. Reg. at 47028, 47054)
This part does not apply to HIPAA-covered entities, or to any other entity to the extent that it engages in activities as a business associate of a HIPAA-covered entity.
89 Fed. Reg. at 47054 (16 C.F.R. § 318.1(a)) A violation is treated as a violation of an FTC rule on unfair or deceptive acts or practices and is subject to civil penalties. (16 C.F.R. § 318.7; 89 Fed. Reg. at 47057)
Any violation of this part shall be treated as a violation of a rule promulgated under section 18 of the Federal Trade Commission Act
89 Fed. Reg. at 47057 (16 C.F.R. § 318.7) To be a vendor of personal health records, an app or website must offer something relating more than tangentially to health. A purely informational health website with no way for users to track or record information is not a personal health record. (89 Fed. Reg. at 47035-36)
to be a vendor of personal health records under the Rule, an app, website, or online service must provide an offering that relates more than tangentially to health.
89 Fed. Reg. at 47035 Commissioners Holyoak and Ferguson dissented, arguing that the expanded definitions exceed the FTC's authority under the statute and leave companies unsure whether they are covered. (89 Fed. Reg. at 47061-64)
exceeds the Commission’s statutory authority, puts companies at risk of perpetual non-compliance
89 Fed. Reg. at 47061 (dissenting statement)
What it did not decide
- Whether a particular disclosure is authorized, which the Commission called a fact-specific inquiry that depends on context, recipients, purposes, the company's representations and other laws.
- Whether a particular app or website is a personal health record, which the Commission called a fact-intensive inquiry.
- Privacy duties beyond notice: the Commission said the rule addresses breach notification, not omnibus privacy protections.
- Questions under other laws: the notice does not mention the federal Wiretap Act, and the rule's text refers to state law only in a clause stating that it preempts state law as set forth in section 13421 of the 2009 statute.
The tracking involved
Tools
- Tracking technologies on websites and mobile apps, discussed in general terms
Data
- Health information generated from tracking technologies or from records of website and app interactions
- Unique persistent identifiers, such as device and mobile advertising IDs, combined with health information
- Health information inferred from other data, such as location and purchases
How it bears on website tracking claims
Supports: strengthens a website tracking claim on this issue. Limits: narrows or defeats a website tracking claim on this issue. Context: bears on the issue without deciding it either way.
Supports: Health Breach Notification Rule
The FTC rule that can treat an unauthorized disclosure of health app data as a breach that requires notice.
For a company the rule covers, sharing identifiable health information with advertising platforms in a way its privacy promises did not allow can itself be a breach (16 C.F.R. § 318.2). Such a breach requires notice to consumers, the FTC and sometimes the media (16 C.F.R. § 318.3). The Commission tied that reading to its earlier actions against GoodRx and Easy Healthcare (89 Fed. Reg. at 47030, 47041). Coverage comes first, because the rule reaches only vendors of personal health records, PHR related entities and their service providers.
Supports: Health information
What counts as individually identifiable health information when it is sent through tracking tools.
The Commission said PHR identifiable health information includes health information generated from tracking technologies on websites and apps (89 Fed. Reg. at 47031, 47042-43). It said persistent identifiers such as device or advertising IDs qualify when combined with health information and capable of identifying someone (89 Fed. Reg. at 47034). The notice speaks of tracking technologies in general and does not mention pixels by name. It interprets this rule's definition, which requires that the information be created or received by a covered health care provider, health plan, employer or health care clearinghouse.
Supports: Consent
Whether visitors agreed to the tracking through banners, privacy policies or terms.
The rule does not require opt-in consent for every disclosure (89 Fed. Reg. at 47041). But the Commission said a disclosure is authorized only when it matches the company's disclosures and consumers' reasonable expectations and comes with meaningful choice, and that buried disclosures do not suffice. It added that dark patterns undercut any claim that consumers made a meaningful choice. That standard speaks to the common defense that a privacy policy disclosed the sharing, within this rule's scope.
Context: HIPAA
How HIPAA, its criminal provision at 42 U.S.C. § 1320d-6 and HHS guidance bear on tracking.
The rule does not apply to HIPAA-covered entities or to business associates acting in that role, which follow HHS's breach notification rule instead (16 C.F.R. § 318.1(a); 89 Fed. Reg. at 47028). A HIPAA-covered hospital's or clinic's own website therefore falls outside this rule, whatever other law may apply to it.
Context: Agency penalties and orders
Civil penalties, payments and conduct terms that regulators obtained.
Violations are treated as violations of an FTC rule on unfair or deceptive practices and are subject to civil penalties; the Commission noted penalties of $1.5 million against GoodRx and $100,000 against Easy Healthcare (16 C.F.R. § 318.7; 89 Fed. Reg. at 47030). The rule's text provides for enforcement by the FTC and says nothing about private lawsuits.
Context: Health Breach Notification Rule
The FTC rule that can treat an unauthorized disclosure of health app data as a breach that requires notice.
Two Commissioners dissented, arguing that the definitions of covered health care provider, health care services or supplies and personal health record exceed the statute (89 Fed. Reg. at 47061-64). They also objected that the limit to offerings relating more than tangentially to health appears only in the Commission's explanation, not in the rule's text. Those objections bear on coverage questions for health-adjacent websites and apps. The amended text took effect and remained in the Code of Federal Regulations as of November 6, 2026.
Arguments it addresses
- The company was not hacked, so there was no breach
- The amended definition states that a breach of security includes an unauthorized acquisition resulting from an unauthorized disclosure, not only from a data breach.
- The privacy policy disclosed the sharing
- The Commission said a disclosure is authorized only when it is consistent with the company's disclosures and consumers' reasonable expectations and comes with meaningful choice, and that buried disclosures do not suffice.
- The company is a HIPAA-covered entity
- The rule does not apply to HIPAA-covered entities or to business associates acting as such, which follow HHS's breach notification rule instead.
- The site only provides health information
- The Commission said a purely informational health website or app that gives users no way to track or record information is not a personal health record.
- The identifiers the company sent are not health information
- The Commission said unique persistent identifiers combined with health information are PHR identifiable health information if they can identify or re-identify a person, while data de-identified under HHS standards is not identifiable.
- The rule exceeds the FTC's authority
- Two Commissioners made that argument in dissent, and the amended rule took effect on July 29, 2024.
For a company that received a letter
- The rule matters only to a vendor of personal health records, a PHR related entity or a third party service provider, and not to HIPAA-covered entities or to business associates acting in that role; the Commission called the question whether an app or website is a personal health record fact-intensive.
- For a covered company, the Commission treats sharing identifiable health information with advertising platforms against its privacy promises as a breach that triggers notice duties of its own.
- The rule is enforced by the FTC, which can seek civil penalties for violations.
What to check on your own site
- If your website or app lets people track health information and you are not a HIPAA-covered entity, list every outside company that receives identifiable health data from it.
- Check whether events sent to advertising or analytics platforms pair health-related actions with persistent identifiers such as advertising IDs, cookies or hashed emails.
- Check whether your disclosures about sharing appear where users make their choice, not only deep in a privacy policy.
Later history
The amendments took effect on July 29, 2024. The eCFR, current through November 6, 2026, lists no amendment to 16 C.F.R. Part 318 after July 29, 2024, and its text still contains the amended definitions. On September 15, 2026, the FTC published notice of a petition for rulemaking from a member of the public asking it to amend and repeal sections of the rule, with comments due October 15, 2026; the notice says it is not intended to start, stop or otherwise affect rulemaking proceedings (91 Fed. Reg. 58398).
Related rulings
Published by Privacy Resolve from public records. It does not cover our own matters.
General information only, not legal advice, and not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Laws, deadlines, defenses and outcomes vary by jurisdiction and facts.