The crime-tort exception, explained
A short video on the crime-tort exception in the federal Wiretap Act: what courts require beyond the interception, and why the facts of each visit matter.
What the video says
The federal Wiretap Act lets a party or a consenting party intercept a communication, with one exception.
Consent does not protect an interception made for the purpose of committing a criminal or tortious act under federal or state law.
Courts read this to require a wrong beyond the interception itself. One appeals court described it as a criminal or tortious use of the interception's fruits.
In health website cases, claimants often point to HIPAA's criminal provision on knowingly disclosing identifiable health information.
Some courts have held that a claimant plausibly alleged that purpose at the pleading stage. Others have found that a marketing purpose alone points to a business aim, not a tortious one. So the facts about what was sent, and why, carry the weight.
Privacy Resolve is not a law firm, and this is general information, not legal advice.