· Court ruling
Baker v. Seattle Children's Hospital
Supreme Court of Washington, No. 104590-5
Primary source: Opinion. Checked on November 10, 2026.
The Washington Supreme Court held that the Washington Privacy Act's ban on intercepting private communications between two or more individuals does not reach a visitor's searches and clicks on a hospital's public website.
What happened
Seattle Children's Hospital, a Washington nonprofit corporation, runs a public website with a directory of health care professionals, clinic hours and descriptions of health conditions, which visitors navigate by links or a search bar. According to the complaint, which the court accepted as true in reviewing the dismissal, the site used the Meta Pixel, which tracked visitors' clicks, text searches and page views and sent them to Meta without the visitor's knowledge; in the complaint's example, a search for depression was relayed to Meta, which linked it to the visitor's Facebook or Instagram account and used it for targeted advertising (slip op. at 2-3).
The complaint also alleged that for visitors without a Meta account, or not logged in, the Pixel sent their activity with a unique identifier that let Meta link it once they logged in or created an account. It also alleged that a pop-up told visitors that accepting cookies meant agreeing to software that stores data to assist in marketing, but that the pop-up did not identify the Pixel or explain how the Pixel collects and uses data (slip op. at 3-4).
The plaintiffs, who said they searched the site for information about their children's medical conditions and clinic hours, brought a putative class action under the Washington Privacy Act and other Washington laws. The trial court dismissed with prejudice, and the Court of Appeals affirmed in an unpublished opinion that treated the searches as one-way rather than back-and-forth communications. The plaintiffs later clarified that their claims targeted only the Pixel on the public website, and the Supreme Court limited its review to that website (slip op. at 4-5 & n.5).
Seven justices joined the majority opinion and two concurred only in the result. The Chamber of Commerce of the United States, the Washington State Hospital Association and the Interactive Advertising Bureau filed amicus briefs supporting the hospital (slip op. at 5, 11; slip op. (González, J., concurring in result) at 1, 10).
What the court held
The provision at issue, RCW 9.73.030(1)(a), does not prohibit the hospital's alleged conduct, because it covers only private communications between two or more individuals and the searches and clicks drew responses from a website system the hospital owns and operates, not from an individual. (slip op. at 2, 7-10)
We conclude that the WPA does not prohibit SCH’s alleged actions.
slip op. at 2 Because the statute lists individuals separately from partnerships, corporations, associations and the state, the word individual in subsection (1)(a) does not include those other entities. (slip op. at 6-7)
No party disputed that the hospital is a corporation, and each communication was between one plaintiff and a website system the hospital owns and operates, so only one individual took part and the claim fails. (slip op. at 7)
Because only one individual was involved in each communication, the plaintiffs do not have a claim under the WPA.
slip op. at 7 That the act makes corporations liable reinforces this reading, because the legislature separately required the communication to be between two or more individuals and could have said persons instead. (slip op. at 8)
The court found federal Wiretap Act and California Invasion of Privacy Act decisions not instructive, saying both statutes differ significantly from the Washington act, and explained that it has called the act among the most restrictive mainly because it requires the consent of all parties. (slip op. at 8-9)
The same is true of California’s privacy act, which likewise differs significantly from the WPA.
slip op. at 9 The court limited its review to the public website because the plaintiffs clarified that their claims targeted only the Pixel there, although they had not expressly abandoned the allegation that it was installed on the MyChart patient portal. (slip op. at 5 n.5)
We therefore limit our review to the plaintiffs’ activities on SCH’s public website.
slip op. at 5 n.5 Concurring in the result, two justices would have held that clicks and searches can be private communications and that communications with individuals working for a corporation are protected, but agreed that these communications, directed at a server that returned stored content, were not between two or more individuals. (slip op. (González, J., concurring in result) at 1-10)
I would therefore hold that the parents’ clicking and searching could constitute a private communication.
slip op. (González, J., concurring in result) at 7
What it did not decide
- Whether searches and clicks on a public website are private communications under RCW 9.73.030(1)(a) (slip op. at 10).
- Whether the act applies when an entity's communications are transmitted between two or more individuals, such as a message to a member of a care team (slip op. at 9 n.6; slip op. (González, J., concurring in result) at 10).
- Activity inside the MyChart patient portal (slip op. at 5 n.5).
- Claims under the Washington Consumer Protection Act and the Uniform Health Care Information Act, and for invasion of privacy, breach of implied contract, conversion and unjust enrichment, whose dismissal the plaintiffs did not challenge (slip op. at 2 n.1, 9-10 n.7).
- Whether the cookie pop-up supplied consent; the majority did not reach consent.
- Any federal Wiretap Act or California claim; the opinion construes only the Washington act.
The tracking involved
Tools
- Meta Pixel
- first- and third-party cookies
Data
- clicks
- text typed into the site search bar
- page views
- a unique identifier for visitors not logged in to Meta
How it bears on website tracking claims
Supports: strengthens a website tracking claim on this issue. Limits: narrows or defeats a website tracking claim on this issue. Context: bears on the issue without deciding it either way.
Limits: State wiretap laws
State interception statutes, such as California Penal Code § 631 and the Washington Privacy Act.
In Washington, a claim under RCW 9.73.030(1)(a) about searches and clicks on a corporation's public website fails, as pleaded here, because the communication is not between two or more individuals. The holding rests on that statute's own words, and the court said federal and California decisions are not a guide to it. It does not address communications that reach a person, activity inside a patient portal or other Washington statutes.
Context: Consent
Whether visitors agreed to the tracking through banners, privacy policies or terms.
The majority explained that it has called the Washington act among the most restrictive mainly because it requires all parties to consent, which the federal act does not, but it never reached consent because the claim failed on the two-individuals element. The concurrence said that whether a general cookie banner defeated the visitors' expectation of privacy was not resolved by the pleadings.
Arguments it addresses
- A website visit is a communication with a company, not between people
- For RCW 9.73.030(1)(a), the court agreed: searches and clicks answered by a corporation's website involve only one individual (slip op. at 7-9).
- Federal and California decisions do not decide a Washington claim
- The court said federal Wiretap Act decisions are not instructive on the Washington act and that California's act differs significantly from it (slip op. at 8-9).
- Washington's all-party consent rule does not reach a visitor's exchange with a company's website
- The court did not reach consent; it said it has called the act restrictive mainly because of its all-party consent rule, and the claim failed on the separate requirement that the communication be between two or more individuals (slip op. at 7-9).
- Searches and clicks are not private communications
- The majority did not decide that question, and the two concurring justices would have held that clicks and searches can be private communications (slip op. at 10; slip op. (González, J., concurring in result) at 7).
- The cookie banner supplied consent
- The majority did not reach consent, and the concurrence said the pleadings did not resolve whether a general cookie banner defeated the expectation of privacy (slip op. (González, J., concurring in result) at 7).
For a company that received a letter
- The ruling decides how one Washington statute applies to searches and clicks on a public website; it does not decide federal Wiretap Act, California or other state-law claims.
- The court limited its review to the public website and left open the patient portal and communications that reach a person working for the entity.
- The plaintiffs' other Washington claims, including under the Consumer Protection Act and the Uniform Health Care Information Act, were not before the Supreme Court.
- Two justices wrote that clicks and searches can convey what condition a person is researching, and that the hospital's privacy notice made an expectation of privacy reasonable on that record.
What to check on your own site
- Check whether your site search sends the words a visitor types to an advertising platform, in a page address or an event.
- Check whether advertising tags run on your patient portal's sign-in page or on pages behind the login.
- Check whether your cookie notice names the companies that receive visitor data and what they receive.
Later history
No later history was found when this page was checked on November 10, 2026.
Related rulings
Published by Privacy Resolve from public records. It does not cover our own matters.
General information only, not legal advice, and not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Laws, deadlines, defenses and outcomes vary by jurisdiction and facts.