· Court ruling
Vita v. Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Inc.
U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts, No. 1:25-cv-11383-JEK, ECF No. 47
Primary source: Memorandum and order. Checked on November 10, 2026.
A Massachusetts federal court let a hospital website user who was not a patient pursue her Wiretap Act claim, with the state privacy statute as the separate wrong, dismissing only her breach of confidence claim.
What happened
According to the second amended complaint, whose facts the court accepted as true, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center provides inpatient and outpatient care in and around Boston, and its website, bidmc.org, has pages on medical services, a Find a Doctor search, online bill payment and the PatientSite patient portal. Its Privacy Policy, which applies to users of the site and not just patients, said users could visit most areas without identifying themselves, that data on website activity such as the pages people visit is collected on an aggregate, anonymous basis with no personally identifiable information attached, and that the hospital would not share information it receives with outside parties except for authorized law enforcement investigations or other facially valid legal processes (ECF No. 47 at 2).
The complaint alleged that the hospital used the Meta Pixel on its website until September 2022 and Google Analytics until February 2023. As alleged, the Meta Pixel sent page URLs and the user's IP address to Meta, which can associate them with a Facebook profile, and Google Analytics sent the URL, the page title and a unique user identifier to Google. The complaint also alleged that Meta warned businesses not to use its technology on websites that include health information (ECF No. 47 at 3).
Kathleen Vita is not a patient of the hospital, but her husband is. She alleged that she regularly used the public website to research its doctors and to get information about specific medical procedures for herself and her husband, and used the patient portal to view his medical records, and that the hospital disclosed her searches for providers and treatments and her portal use to Meta and Google without her consent (ECF No. 47 at 4, 6).
She sued in Suffolk Superior Court in February 2023 under the Massachusetts Wiretap Act. After the Supreme Judicial Court held in 2024, in this case, that the hospital's conduct was not prohibited by that statute, she added a federal Wiretap Act claim and state-law claims in April 2025, and the hospital removed the case to federal court in May 2025. The operative second amended complaint was filed in November 2025 (ECF No. 47 at 4).
What the court held
Under the Massachusetts privacy statute, M.G.L. c. 214, § 1B, the court held that the plaintiff's searches for providers and specific medical procedures for herself were medical information of a highly intimate or personal nature. It treated as waived, at this stage, any argument that her case differs because she is not a patient. (ECF No. 47 at 5-8)
BIDMC has, accordingly, waived at this stage any argument that these cases are factually distinct because Vita, unlike the plaintiffs in those cases, is not a patient.
ECF No. 47 at 7 Whether marketing and advertising are legitimate interests that outweigh the intrusion on her privacy is a question of fact that cannot be resolved on a motion to dismiss, so the § 1B claim survived. (ECF No. 47 at 8)
All agreed that the hospital was a party to the communications, but the court held that the complaint plausibly alleged an interception for the purpose of violating § 1B, relying on the alleged gap between the Privacy Policy's promises and the disclosures to Meta and Google. (ECF No. 47 at 9-10)
Vita plausibly alleges that BIDMC intentionally intercepted her communications on its website for the purpose of committing a tortious act in violation of M.G.L. c. 214, § 1B.
ECF No. 47 at 9 Allegations that the hospital installed the tools for marketing and commercial gain did not change the result. Whether a lawful purpose, an unlawful purpose or both primarily or determinatively motivated the hospital is a question of fact, and the court rejected the argument that marketing was an obvious alternative explanation. (ECF No. 47 at 10-11 & n.5)
Vita’s allegations that BIDMC installed the tracking technologies from Meta and Google on its website for “marketing purposes, including targeted advertising,” and “commercial gain” do not change this conclusion.
ECF No. 47 at 10 The complaint adequately alleged a tortious purpose independent of the interception, because the alleged § 1B violation occurred through the hospital's use and disclosure of the communications to Meta and Google, not through the act of interception. (ECF No. 47 at 12-13)
Since Vita’s factual allegations support the plausible inference that BIDMC intercepted her communications for the purpose of committing a tortious act separate from the interception itself, the crime-tort exception under 18 U.S.C. § 2511(2)(d) applies.
ECF No. 47 at 13 The Wiretap Act's ordinary-course-of-business exclusion from the definition of device is an affirmative defense, and it was not clear from the complaint, which alleged that the tools were not needed to run the site, while the Privacy Policy said such information would not be shared with outside parties. (ECF No. 47 at 13-15)
But whether those technologies fall within this exclusion is an affirmative defense that must be “clear on the face of [Vita’s] pleadings.”
ECF No. 47 at 14 The allegations about her searches for providers and specific procedures were sufficient to treat her intercepted health information and personal identifiers as contents of communications. The court held that the hospital's reliance on American Hospital Association v. Becerra ignored her specific allegations about what was disclosed. (ECF No. 47 at 15-16)
These factual allegations are sufficient to treat Vita’s intercepted private health information and personal identifiers as “contents” for purposes of the ECPA.
ECF No. 47 at 16 The court declined to apply the rule of lenity to the Wiretap Act. (ECF No. 47 at 16 n.9)
BIDMC fails to identify any “grievous ambiguity” in the crime-tort exception specifically or the ECPA generally that warrants application of the rule of lenity.
ECF No. 47 at 16 n.9 The hospital's concern that the proposed class reaches people who are not patients can be addressed at class certification. (ECF No. 47 at 18)
BIDMC’s concern “regarding the appropriate contours of the putative class” can be addressed at the class certification stage
ECF No. 47 at 18 The breach of fiduciary duty, negligence, breach of implied contract and unjust enrichment claims survived. On negligence, the court said that other hospitals' use of the same tools is no defense. (ECF No. 47 at 16-27)
The fact that other hospitals may have likewise used Google Analytics and Meta Pixel is no defense to BIDMC’s alleged misconduct.
ECF No. 47 at 20-21 The breach of confidence claim was dismissed because Massachusetts law does not recognize it as a standalone claim in this context. (ECF No. 47 at 22-23)
Absent binding precedent from Massachusetts courts identifying breach of confidence as a standalone claim, the Court will not infer that such a claim exists.
ECF No. 47 at 22
What it did not decide
- Whether a website user who is not a patient stands differently from a patient; the hospital did not develop that argument, and the court treated it as waived at this stage (ECF No. 47 at 7, 18).
- Whether the hospital also intended to violate HIPAA or the Federal Trade Commission Act; the court did not need to consider those predicates (ECF No. 47 at 10 n.4).
- Whether the First Circuit requires the predicate wrong to be independent of the interception; the court applied that test because the parties agreed on it, noting that the First Circuit has not adopted it (ECF No. 47 at 9, 12 n.6).
- Which of the hospital's purposes was primary, a question of fact left for a later stage (ECF No. 47 at 11).
- The intrusion upon seclusion theory under § 1B and the express contract theory, which the court did not reach (ECF No. 47 at 6 n.2, 24 n.11).
The tracking involved
Tools
- Meta Pixel
- Google Analytics
Data
- Page URLs and page titles
- IP addresses
- A unique user identifier
- Searches for doctors and for information on specific medical procedures
- Use of the patient portal
How it bears on website tracking claims
Supports: strengthens a website tracking claim on this issue. Limits: narrows or defeats a website tracking claim on this issue. Context: bears on the issue without deciding it either way.
Context: Party exception
Whether the website, as a party to the visit, could consent to the tracking under 18 U.S.C. § 2511(2)(d).
The hospital's status as a party to the visitor's communications was undisputed. The court held that party status did not end the claim at the pleading stage, because the complaint plausibly alleged an interception for the purpose of committing a tort under the Massachusetts privacy statute.
Supports: Crime-tort exception
Whether a communication was intercepted for the purpose of a criminal or tortious act, which removes the party exception.
The court accepted M.G.L. c. 214, § 1B as the separate wrong and found a plausible inference of tortious purpose in the gap between the Privacy Policy's promises of anonymous, unshared data and the alleged disclosures to Meta and Google. It held that a marketing or financial motive does not defeat the exception, that which motive was primary is a question of fact, and that the complaint adequately alleged a disclosure independent of the interception. This is a pleading-stage ruling by one judge; the court noted that the First Circuit has not adopted the independence test, and it did not reach HIPAA or the FTC Act as predicates.
Supports: Interception
Whether a tracking tool acquired a communication as it was sent, who did it, and whether it was intentional.
The hospital argued that its use of the Meta Pixel and Google Analytics fell within the ordinary-course-of-business exclusion from the Wiretap Act's definition of device. The court treated that exclusion as an affirmative defense that must be clear on the face of the complaint and found it was not, pointing to the Privacy Policy's statement that such information would not be shared and the allegation that the tools were not needed to run the site. The ruling leaves the defense open on a factual record.
Supports: Contents
Whether what was sent, such as page addresses, searches and clicks, counts as the contents of a communication.
The court held that alleged searches for providers and specific medical procedures, together with personal identifiers, could be treated as contents of communications under the Wiretap Act's broad definition. It held that the hospital's reliance on American Hospital Association v. Becerra ignored the complaint's specific allegations about what was disclosed. The holding rests on allegations that described the plaintiff's own searches.
Supports: Health information
What counts as individually identifiable health information when it is sent through tracking tools.
For the Massachusetts privacy statute, the court held that a website user's searches for providers and specific medical procedures for herself were medical information of a highly intimate or personal nature. The plaintiff was not a patient, but the hospital did not develop an argument that this mattered, so the court treated the point as waived rather than deciding it.
Supports: State privacy laws
Other state privacy statutes and claims, such as medical information and health records acts and the CCPA.
The § 1B invasion of privacy claim survived, and the court held that whether marketing and advertising are legitimate interests that outweigh the intrusion is a question of fact. Claims for breach of fiduciary duty, negligence, breach of implied contract and unjust enrichment also survived; on fiduciary duty, the court held that a fiduciary relationship with this non-patient was plausible on the facts alleged, based in part on the Privacy Policy's promises.
Limits: State privacy laws
Other state privacy statutes and claims, such as medical information and health records acts and the CCPA.
The court dismissed the breach of confidence claim, holding that Massachusetts law does not recognize it as a standalone claim in this context and that Alberts v. Devine, which recognized a patient's remedy against a physician, does not authorize such a claim against the hospital here. The court said that, to the extent the claim rested on a hospital's duty to safeguard private health information, it duplicated the fiduciary duty claim, which proceeds.
Context: State wiretap laws
State interception statutes, such as California Penal Code § 631 and the Washington Privacy Act.
As the order recounts, the Supreme Judicial Court held in 2024, in this same case, that the hospital's conduct was not prohibited by the Massachusetts Wiretap Act, and the federal claim was added after that ruling. The federal order does not discuss the state court's reasoning, but the federal claim then survived a motion to dismiss, so the state statute's reach did not decide the federal claim.
Context: Class certification
Whether claims can go forward on behalf of a whole class of website or app users.
The proposed class covers Massachusetts residents who used the website during the class period, not only patients. The court said the hospital's concern about the class's contours, including people who are not patients, can be addressed at class certification, where a class can be redefined or divided into subclasses.
Arguments it addresses
- The website was a party to the communication
- Party status was undisputed, but the court held the crime-tort exception applied at the pleading stage because the complaint plausibly alleged an interception for the purpose of violating the Massachusetts privacy statute (ECF No. 47 at 9-13).
- The tools were used for marketing, not to commit a tort
- The court held that a marketing or financial purpose does not rule out a tortious one and that which purpose was primary is a question of fact (ECF No. 47 at 10-11).
- The only wrong alleged is the interception itself
- The court held that the alleged privacy violation occurred through the hospital's disclosure of the communications to Meta and Google, not through the interception (ECF No. 47 at 12-13).
- Browsing a public website cannot identify anyone or reveal health information
- The court held that this argument, based on American Hospital Association v. Becerra, ignored the complaint's specific allegations about her searches for providers and procedures (ECF No. 47 at 15-16).
- Tracking tools are used in the ordinary course of running a website
- The court held that the ordinary-course exclusion is an affirmative defense that was not clear from the complaint, given the Privacy Policy's promise not to share such information (ECF No. 47 at 13-15).
- The plaintiff is not a patient
- The hospital did not develop that argument, so the court treated it as waived at this stage and did not decide whether non-patients stand differently (ECF No. 47 at 7, 18).
- Other hospitals use the same tools
- On the negligence claim, the court said that other hospitals' use of Google Analytics and the Meta Pixel is no defense (ECF No. 47 at 20-21).
- This theory would expose every hospital that uses common tools
- The court said the theory does not bar hospitals from using the tools at all, only from using them without disclosing that use (ECF No. 47 at 15 n.8).
For a company that received a letter
- This is a ruling on the pleadings that treats the complaint's allegations as true; it is not a finding that the hospital is liable.
- The hospital's own Privacy Policy, which promised anonymous, aggregate data and no sharing with outside parties, was central to the rulings on purpose, the ordinary-course defense and the implied contract claim.
- The plaintiff was not a patient, but because the hospital did not develop that point, the order does not decide whether non-patient status matters.
- The federal claim went forward even though Massachusetts' highest court had held, in the same case, that the hospital's conduct was not prohibited by the state wiretap statute.
What to check on your own site
- Compare what the privacy policy says about anonymous or aggregate data and sharing with outside parties against what the site's tags actually send to Meta, Google or other vendors.
- Check whether doctor searches, procedure pages, bill payment pages and the patient portal send page addresses, page titles or user identifiers to any advertising or analytics vendor.
Later history
The hospital answered the amended complaint on October 2, 2026, and the court entered a scheduling order on October 30, 2026 (ECF Nos. 56, 60).
Related rulings
Published by Privacy Resolve from public records. It does not cover our own matters.
General information only, not legal advice, and not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Laws, deadlines, defenses and outcomes vary by jurisdiction and facts.