Public pages use no advertising trackers. The secure portal uses an essential session cookie and the service providers described in our privacy policy.

Skip to main content

· Court ruling

Doe v. Eating Recovery Center LLC

U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, No. 3:23-cv-05561-VC, ECF No. 167

For defendantsSummary judgment granted to the provider on the CIPA, CMIA and unjust enrichment claims, and denied to the plaintiff on the CIPA claim; judgment entered October 21, 2025

Primary source: Order on summary judgment. Checked on November 10, 2026.

A federal court held Meta Pixel data from an eating disorder provider's site were contents of communications but rejected the California wiretap claim because Meta did not read or try to learn them in transit.

What happened

Eating Recovery Center treats people for eating disorders and used the Meta Pixel on its website from 2019 to 2024, with the stated goal of making its internet advertising more effective and helping people in need of its services. On the summary judgment record as the court described it, the provider installed the standard Pixel without configuring it to send more than the default event data, which for each visitor included the address of each page browsed, the time spent on it, the page the visitor came from and some actions, such as button clicks or answers. The provider used the data to build custom audiences for its ads, for example people who had visited the site within the last 180 days.

During the same period, the provider's website said communications with it were '100% confidential', that it would not collect visitors' personal information while they visited, and that it would never share or sell their personal information to a third party.

The plaintiff, a California resident diagnosed with anorexia in 2021, visited the site in June 2022, apparently to consider treatment options, and began receiving Facebook ads from the provider and other mental health services the same day. She sued in October 2023 under the California Invasion of Privacy Act (CIPA), the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (CMIA) and the Unfair Competition Law, and for unjust enrichment; the Unfair Competition Law claim was dismissed at the pleading stage for lack of economic injury, and no federal Wiretap Act claim was in the case.

Her CIPA theory was that Meta read, attempted to read or attempted to learn her communications with the provider while they were in transit, in violation of the second clause of California Penal Code § 631(a), and that the provider was liable for aiding or conspiring with Meta.

What the court held

  1. The court rejected the provider's argument that the plaintiff lacked Article III standing, contrasting a disclosure that someone was shopping for a football jersey with a disclosure that someone was likely shopping for eating disorder services. (ECF No. 167 at 4 n.3)

    The URLs at issue in this case convey information that is personal enough to confer Article III standing.

    ECF No. 167 at 4 n.3
  2. Applying the federal Wiretap Act's definition of contents, which the Ninth Circuit has held CIPA shares, the court held as a matter of law that the event data Meta obtained were contents, resting on the page addresses and the related data on time spent on each page and the browsing path, and distinguishing detailed addresses that reveal the specific document or service viewed from basic identification and address information. (ECF No. 167 at 6-8)

    The captured URLs and the information related to those URLs are sufficient to qualify as contents of a communication under the second clause of Section 631(a).

    ECF No. 167 at 7
  3. The addresses showed that the plaintiff researched anorexia, explored treatment options and locations, and at least clicked through to a self-assessment form, and the court said the data, with her path and time on each page, conveyed far more than basic identification and address information. (ECF No. 167 at 7-8)

    It conveys a significant possibility that Doe had anorexia at the time she visited the ERC website.

    ECF No. 167 at 8
  4. The court held that Meta's filtering of page addresses before logging them was not reading or learning, which requires an effort to understand the communication's meaning, and that it happened after the communication had reached the website: the parties agreed that event data is transmitted to Meta about 0.2 seconds after the visitor's action is transmitted to the website, and the encrypted data must be reassembled before it can be filtered. (ECF No. 167 at 8-9)

    the only commonsense meaning of transit, at least in the context of this statute, is the transit from the person sending the communication to its intended recipient.

    ECF No. 167 at 9
  5. The court called the plaintiff's argument that intercepting a communication as part of an attempt to learn its contents later is enough a plausible reading of the words in isolation, but held that in context a defendant must do more than intercept the communication in transit, partly because the broader reading would appear to make Penal Code § 632 superfluous for this kind of communication and partly because CIPA is a criminal statute subject to the rule of lenity, with punitive civil penalties that courts construe narrowly. (ECF No. 167 at 2, 9-11)

    The Court concludes, albeit without a great deal of confidence, that Meta's conduct did not satisfy the “in transit” requirement as a matter of law.

    ECF No. 167 at 6
  6. Because the evidence was undisputed that Meta did not read, attempt to read or attempt to learn the contents while the communications were in transit, the court granted the provider summary judgment on the CIPA claim and denied the plaintiff's motion on that claim. (ECF No. 167 at 12)

  7. In a separate order the same day, the court granted summary judgment on the two CMIA claims because each requires information belonging to a patient, and browsing pages, including a diagnostic quiz and a self-assessment form, did not make the visitor a patient, even assuming she completed them, because the website operator was not performing any professional service at that point; her later phone call about treatment options and the provider's classification of her as a potential patient came after the data was shared, so they did not make her a patient at the relevant time. (ECF No. 168 at 1-2 & n.2)

    None of this is to say that a website operator is free to transmit a visitor's private medical information to third parties.

    ECF No. 168 at 2 n.2
  8. The court also granted summary judgment on unjust enrichment, finding no evidence that the provider's marketing efforts enriched it, let alone that the plaintiff's data did. (ECF No. 168 at 2)

    All the record reflects is that, like many businesses, ERC used Meta's services to aid its marketing efforts.

    ECF No. 168 at 2

What it did not decide

  • Any federal Wiretap Act claim, because none was pleaded.
  • Whether Penal Code § 632 reaches this conduct; the court said that section was not directly at issue, while observing that intercepting and recording the contents of a communication would seem to be covered by it.
  • Whether a 'For Me' answer sent without its question is itself contents; the court said the plaintiff's position seemed right but rested its holding on the page address data.
  • Whether other laws reach the transmission; the court said its CMIA ruling does not mean a website operator is free to transmit a visitor's private medical information to third parties.
  • Class certification.

The tracking involved

Tools

  • Meta Pixel (standard installation with default event data)

Data

  • Address of each page viewed
  • Time spent on each page
  • Address of the page the visitor came from
  • Some button clicks and answers, such as a 'For Me' answer on a self-assessment page

How it bears on website tracking claims

Supports: strengthens a website tracking claim on this issue. Limits: narrows or defeats a website tracking claim on this issue. Context: bears on the issue without deciding it either way.

  • Limits: State wiretap laws

    State interception statutes, such as California Penal Code § 631 and the Washington Privacy Act.

    The court read the second clause of California Penal Code § 631(a) to require reading, or attempting to read or learn, a communication's contents during its transit from the visitor to the website, and held that Meta's filtering after receipt did not qualify. It rejected the argument that intercepting with intent to learn the contents later is enough, relying on the overlap with Section 632 and on the rule of lenity for a criminal statute. The court said it reached this conclusion with limited confidence, acknowledged that courts, probably including itself, have been inconsistent on the transit question, and urged the California Legislature to update the statute; the ruling is one district judge's reading of one clause on a summary judgment record.

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Supports: Contents

    Whether what was sent, such as page addresses, searches and clicks, counts as the contents of a communication.

    Applying the federal Wiretap Act's definition, which the Ninth Circuit has held CIPA shares, the court held as a matter of law that the event data Meta received were contents, resting on the page addresses, time on each page and browsing path rather than on the clicks. It distinguished addresses that carry only basic identification and address information and relied on what these addresses revealed: research into anorexia, treatment options and locations. Because the court applied the federal definition, its contents reasoning is relevant to the same element of a federal Wiretap Act claim, although no federal claim was before it.

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Supports: Standing and injury

    Whether the people suing were harmed in a way that lets a federal court hear the claim.

    The court rejected the provider's standing challenge, holding that the page addresses conveyed information personal enough for Article III standing. It drew the line by example: a disclosure that someone was shopping for a football jersey might not support standing, but a disclosure that someone was likely shopping for eating disorder services does.

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Context: Health information

    What counts as individually identifiable health information when it is sent through tracking tools.

    The court treated the browsing data from a treatment provider's site as showing a significant possibility that the visitor had anorexia, based on the pages viewed, the path between them and the time spent. On standing, it treated the addresses as showing that she was likely shopping for eating disorder services. Neither point carried any claim to judgment for the plaintiff, and the CMIA ruling turned on whether she was a patient, not on the nature of the data.

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Limits: State privacy laws

    Other state privacy statutes and claims, such as medical information and health records acts and the CCPA.

    The CMIA claims failed because that statute protects a patient's medical information, and browsing pages, including quiz and self-assessment pages, before any phone call did not make the visitor a patient of the provider. The court added that this does not leave a website operator free to transmit visitors' private medical information to third parties; the CMIA simply does not cover the transmission of non-patients' medical information.

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Context: Damages

    What must be shown to recover money, including statutory damages and proof of actual loss.

    The court noted that CIPA lets a plaintiff recover a civil penalty of $5,000 per violation or three times actual damages, whichever is greater, and treated those punitive civil penalties, together with the statute's criminal character, as reasons to resolve ambiguous terms narrowly. The punitive character of the statutory remedy thus weighed against the broader reading the plaintiff urged. The court decided no question about the amount of damages or penalties.

    All tracker entries on this issue

Arguments it addresses

The vendor received the data only after it reached the website
For the reading clause of section 631(a), the court agreed on this record: transit ends at the intended recipient, and Meta's filtering came afterward.
Page addresses are record information, not contents
The court rejected this for detailed addresses that reveal the specific pages and services viewed, holding them contents as a matter of law.
Browsing data causes no concrete injury
The court held that these page addresses were personal enough to support Article III standing.
A website visitor is not a patient
The court agreed for the CMIA claims where the visitor had only browsed pages, including a quiz page, before any call, while saying operators are not thereby free to transmit visitors' private medical information.
The company gained nothing from the data
On unjust enrichment, the court found no evidence that the marketing efforts enriched the provider, let alone that this visitor's data did.

For a company that received a letter

  • The ruling construes one clause of California Penal Code § 631(a) on a summary judgment record and decided no federal Wiretap Act claim.
  • The court held that detailed page addresses can be the contents of a communication and can support standing, even though the CIPA claim failed on the in-transit requirement.
  • The court said it reached its in-transit conclusion with limited confidence and acknowledged conflicting rulings, and no ruling on the plaintiff's motion to alter or amend the judgment appears on the docket as read November 10, 2026.

What to check on your own site

  • Check whether the page addresses your pages send to advertising vendors name conditions, treatments or locations, since even a default pixel installation sends them.
  • Check what clicks and answers on quiz or self-assessment pages are sent to vendors, including answers sent without their questions.
  • Compare any confidentiality statements on your site with the tags that actually load on the pages those statements cover.

Later history

Judgment for the provider was entered on October 21, 2025 (ECF No. 171). The plaintiff moved to alter or amend the judgment under Rule 59(e) on November 18, 2025 (ECF No. 172). On December 18, 2025, the court approved the parties' stipulation that the plaintiff would file an amended motion within two weeks after the parties receive documents unsealed in In re Meta Pixel Healthcare Litigation, with briefing to follow (ECF No. 176), and the January 8, 2026 hearing was vacated (ECF No. 177). The docket on CourtListener, read November 10, 2026, shows no later entry, so no ruling on that motion was seen.

October 30, 2026 · Court rulingIn re Meta Pixel Healthcare Litigation (N.D. Cal. 2026)For plaintiffsA federal court certified classes of Facebook users suing Meta over health information allegedly obtained from provider websites and apps, holding that consent, intent and whether the data is contents are common questions.August 1, 2025 · Court rulingFrasco v. Flo Health (N.D. Cal. 2025)For plaintiffsA federal jury found Meta violated California Penal Code section 632 by eavesdropping on or recording Flo app users' menstrual and ovulation answers through its software development kit, and the court denied post-trial motions.September 7, 2023 · Court rulingDoe v. Meta Platforms (N.D. Cal. 2023)Mixed rulingPatients' Wiretap Act and CIPA claims against Meta over its pixel on health care providers' patient portals survived dismissal, with the scope of covered content, Meta's intent and the providers' consent left to evidence.November 14, 2024 · Court rulingCastillo v. Costco Wholesale (W.D. Wash. 2024)Mixed rulingRuling on the pleadings, a Seattle federal court held pharmacy customers' prescription searches sent to Meta were contents and a financial motive does not defeat the crime-tort exception, but dismissed the Washington Privacy Act claim.August 19, 2026 · Court rulingMagliocca v. United Healthcare Services (E.D. Cal. 2026)For defendantsData from one visit to a health insurer's general plan pages, with only a ZIP code entered, showed no concrete injury, a federal court held, dismissing the tracking suit with prejudice for lack of standing.October 23, 2026 · Court rulingRand v. Eyemart Express (5th Cir. 2026)For plaintiffsThe Fifth Circuit held that the alleged unauthorized disclosure of website users' health information to Meta through its Pixel is a concrete injury, and that such information need not reveal a diagnosis.

Published by Privacy Resolve from public records. It does not cover our own matters.

General information only, not legal advice, and not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Laws, deadlines, defenses and outcomes vary by jurisdiction and facts.