Public pages use no advertising trackers. The secure portal uses an essential session cookie and the service providers described in our privacy policy.

Skip to main content

· Court ruling

Magliocca v. United Healthcare Services, Inc.

U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California, No. 2:25-cv-03388-WBS-SCR

For defendantsMotion to dismiss the first amended complaint granted for lack of Article III standing; action dismissed with prejudice

Primary source: Memorandum and order. Checked on November 10, 2026.

Data from one visit to a health insurer's general plan pages, with only a ZIP code entered, showed no concrete injury, a federal court held, dismissing the tracking suit with prejudice for lack of standing.

What happened

The first amended complaint alleged that United Healthcare Services, Inc., which owns and operates the website uhc.com, used tracking technology on the site from Google Ads/DoubleClick, Adobe and Adobe Audience Manager, Qualtrics, SessionCam, Shape Security, Datadog, LivePerson and Branch/App.link, 155 third-party trackers in all, including 47 cookies, 19 different canvas fingerprints and one session recorder (slip op. at 2, 5).

The plaintiff alleged that in July 2025 she clicked a Facebook advertisement to research Medicare supplement coverage, went to the site's Medicare coverage section, entered her ZIP code in Yuba County, California, clicked to view the plans available there, clicked on Plan G and on Medicare plans endorsed by AARP, and clicked a button to learn more about Plan G, and that she ultimately chose not to enroll (slip op. at 3).

She alleged that the session recorder provided screen recording, keystroke capture, mouse and scroll tracking and likely form-input capture, that canvas fingerprinting was used to identify her device, and that the trackers received page URLs and titles, event names, clickstream events, ZIP code location signals, plan-selection signals and browser and device identifiers. She alleged that she later saw advertisements for UnitedHealthcare and other health insurance on websites and social media (slip op. at 3-5).

She brought claims under the California Invasion of Privacy Act, the federal Wiretap Act, the California Computer Data Access and Fraud Act and the California Constitution. The court had dismissed her original complaint for lack of standing on March 30, 2026, with leave to amend (slip op. at 1-2, 5; order of March 30, 2026).

What the court held

  1. A statutory right to sue for an invasion of privacy does not relieve a federal court of its own duty to find a concrete injury under Article III, and the court held that the new allegations in the first amended complaint still did not show one. (slip op. at 2, 5-6)

  2. Collecting user and device identifiers, without the communication of content that results in a concrete injury, is not enough for standing. (slip op. at 6 & n.4)

  3. The court held that the plaintiff had not shown that her clicks on Medicare plan pages and her ZIP code communicated anything beyond publicly available information about the generic terms of an insurance plan she did not enroll in, and that their loose connection to health did not make them private. (slip op. at 8-10)

    plaintiff’s newfound emphasis on the vaguely health-related nature of her information does not reflexively render that information “embarrassing, invasive, or otherwise private.”

    slip op. at 9
  4. Distinguishing a decision that found sensitive medical information in personalized searches related to the provision of health care, the court listed what this complaint did not allege. (slip op. at 10)

    Here, plaintiff does not allege that the trackers captured searches for physician names, actual conditions, appointments, personal medical history, use of individual patient portals, user-inputs that are personal with respect to medical status

    slip op. at 10
  5. Despite the session recorder and canvas fingerprinting allegations, the court held that the data collected on her one visit remained non-sensitive browsing activity on a single website, which does not establish a concrete injury. (slip op. at 3-4, 10-11)

    collected following one visit to the UHC website in July 2025 remains within the kind of “non-sensitive browsing activity on a single website” that courts have repeatedly found insufficient to establish a concrete injury

    slip op. at 11
  6. The court rejected the argument that clicking on AARP-endorsed Medicare plans revealed sensitive age information, noting that she entered no birthday and that such a search might be made for a relative. (slip op. at 11-12)

    Such a generic, depersonalized search is not enough to establish a concrete invasion of privacy injury.

    slip op. at 12
  7. A single conclusory reference to a loss of money did not establish an economic injury. (slip op. at 5 n.3)

    As before, this conclusory allegation remains without factual support in the FAC and does not confer standing.

    slip op. at 5 n.3
  8. Because counsel said at the hearing that no new facts could be added, the court denied further amendment and dismissed the action with prejudice, without reaching the merits of any claim. (slip op. at 12-13)

    IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that defendant’s Motion to Dismiss Plaintiff’s First Amended Complaint (Docket No. 28) be, and the same hereby is, GRANTED, and this action is hereby DISMISSED with prejudice.

    slip op. at 13

What it did not decide

  • The merits of the California Invasion of Privacy Act, federal Wiretap Act, Computer Data Access and Fraud Act and California Constitution claims, which the court lacked jurisdiction to reach (slip op. at 12).
  • Whether a visitor whose searches for physicians, conditions or appointments, or whose patient portal use, was captured would have standing; the court contrasted such facts with this case without deciding one (slip op. at 10).
  • Whether tracking that builds a long-term, cross-site profile of sensitive information would establish injury; the court described other courts finding injury in such cases but held that the allegations here did not reach that level (slip op. at 7-8, 11).

The tracking involved

Tools

  • Google Ads/DoubleClick
  • Adobe and Adobe Audience Manager
  • Qualtrics
  • SessionCam session recorder
  • Shape Security
  • Datadog
  • LivePerson
  • Branch/App.link
  • Canvas fingerprinting

Data

  • Button clicks, page visits, scrolls and session lengths
  • Keystrokes and mouse movements recorded by the session recorder
  • Page URLs and titles, event names and clickstream events
  • ZIP code entered in a plan search
  • Plan-selection signals
  • IP addresses, canvas fingerprints and browser and device identifiers

How it bears on website tracking claims

Supports: strengthens a website tracking claim on this issue. Limits: narrows or defeats a website tracking claim on this issue. Context: bears on the issue without deciding it either way.

  • Limits: Standing and injury

    Whether the people suing were harmed in a way that lets a federal court hear the claim.

    Applying the Ninth Circuit's decision in Popa v. Microsoft Corporation, the court asked whether the information collected was embarrassing, invasive or otherwise private, and held that routine interaction data from one visit to general insurance pages was not. Because standing failed, the court never reached whether the trackers violated the California Invasion of Privacy Act or the federal Wiretap Act. The ruling is from one federal district court in California and turns on its facts: one visit, generic Medicare plan pages and a ZIP code as the only input.

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Limits: Health information

    What counts as individually identifiable health information when it is sent through tracking tools.

    The court treated generic health insurance browsing as publicly available health information that does not reveal a person's health status or medical history, even with a session recorder and fingerprinting alleged. It contrasted that with personalized searches related to the provision of health care, listing searches for physician names, conditions, appointments, personal medical history, patient portal use and medical-status inputs as information missing here. The order distinguishes generic browsing of public information from personalized searches and inputs about a visitor's own care, without deciding a case with the latter facts.

    All tracker entries on this issue

Arguments it addresses

No concrete injury
On these facts the court agreed, holding that clicks, page visits and similar data from one visit to general insurance pages, with only a ZIP code entered, were non-sensitive browsing activity (slip op. at 10-11).
A page visit is not health information
The court treated generic health insurance browsing as publicly available information that did not reveal her health status, while listing searches for physicians, conditions or appointments and patient portal use as information not alleged here (slip op. at 9-10).
Identifiers such as IP addresses and device fingerprints are not private
The court held that collecting user and device identifiers, without content whose communication causes a concrete injury, does not confer standing (slip op. at 6 & n.4).
A session recorder captured everything the visitor did
The court held those allegations did not change the result, because the plaintiff did not claim her recorded inputs revealed more than plan clicks and a ZIP code (slip op. at 4, 10-11).
The statute gives a right to sue, so standing follows
The court held that a statutory right of action does not relieve a federal court of its duty to find an Article III injury (slip op. at 5-6).

For a company that received a letter

  • The dismissal rested on specific pleaded facts: one visit, general Medicare plan pages and a ZIP code as the only thing the visitor entered.
  • The court did not decide whether the trackers violated the California Invasion of Privacy Act, the federal Wiretap Act or any other law; it held only that it lacked jurisdiction because no concrete injury was alleged.
  • The order lists the kinds of information it found missing, including searches for physician names, conditions or appointments, personal medical history and patient portal use.
  • A standing dismissal in federal court applies Article III, which the court said a statutory right to sue does not satisfy on its own.

What to check on your own site

  • List the pages that load session recorders and advertising tags, and check whether any of them are pages where visitors search for doctors, describe a condition, book an appointment or sign in to a portal.
  • Check whether form entries such as ZIP codes and plan selections are sent to third-party vendors in page addresses, event names or session recordings.

Later history

Judgment was entered on August 19, 2026, and the case was closed (ECF Nos. 34, 35). CourtListener's copy of the docket, read on November 10, 2026, lists no later entry, so no notice of appeal appears there, and CourtListener lists no Ninth Circuit docket for the case.

August 28, 2026 · Court rulingSantoro v. Tower Health (3d Cir. 2026)Mixed rulingPatients alleging their provider secretly shared their health information with Meta have standing, the Third Circuit held, but it affirmed dismissal with prejudice on amendment grounds without reaching the merits.October 23, 2026 · Court rulingRand v. Eyemart Express (5th Cir. 2026)For plaintiffsThe Fifth Circuit held that the alleged unauthorized disclosure of website users' health information to Meta through its Pixel is a concrete injury, and that such information need not reveal a diagnosis.June 20, 2024 · Court rulingAmerican Hospital Association v. Becerra (N.D. Tex. 2024)For plaintiffsA Texas federal court vacated only the part of HHS's tracking guidance treating an IP address plus a visit to a public page about specific health conditions or providers as individually identifiable health information.July 24, 2023 · Court rulingKurowski v. Rush System for Health (N.D. Ill. 2023)Mixed rulingPatients' Wiretap Act claim was dismissed because the complaint plausibly alleged only metadata, not health information, but their Illinois Eavesdropping Act claim proceeded against the health system as a principal benefiting from third-party cookies.September 4, 2026 · Court rulingHanson v. Sanford Health (D. Minn. 2026)Mixed rulingA Minnesota federal court let a patient's Wiretap Act claim proceed on an alleged HIPAA disclosure, rejecting profit-motive and independence defenses, but dismissed his intrusion and state health records claims with prejudice.August 14, 2026 · Court rulingVita v. Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center (D. Mass. 2026)For plaintiffsA Massachusetts federal court let a hospital website user who was not a patient pursue her Wiretap Act claim, with the state privacy statute as the separate wrong, dismissing only her breach of confidence claim.

Published by Privacy Resolve from public records. It does not cover our own matters.

General information only, not legal advice, and not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Laws, deadlines, defenses and outcomes vary by jurisdiction and facts.