· Court ruling
Rand v. Eyemart Express, L.L.C.
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, No. 25-10784
Primary source: Published opinion. Checked on November 10, 2026.
The Fifth Circuit held that the alleged unauthorized disclosure of website users' health information to Meta through its Pixel is a concrete injury, and that such information need not reveal a diagnosis.
What happened
Eyemart Express operates a chain of physical stores and a website where users can browse products, buy prescription eyewear and schedule eye exams. According to the complaint, whose allegations the court accepted as true at this stage, Eyemart used the Meta Pixel on the site, the Pixel sent users' searches, clicks, product viewing information and appointment scheduling information to Meta, and Eyemart neither obtained users' consent nor told them about the tracking (slip op. at 2 & n.1).
Five Facebook users sued under the federal Wiretap Act, the Missouri Wiretap Act and the Illinois Eavesdropping Act, and for intrusion upon seclusion and breach of contract (slip op. at 3). The Search Plaintiffs alleged that their browsing and searching for prescription glasses was sent to Meta, and that when one of them scheduled an eye exam, the name and location of the store went to Meta. The Prescription Plaintiffs alleged that they entered their prescription information to buy eyewear and that it and other health information reached Meta (slip op. at 4).
The plaintiffs also alleged that Eyemart uploaded customer lists containing email addresses and purchase information so that Meta could match users to their Facebook profiles (slip op. at 12). The district court found standing but dismissed the case with prejudice, finding that the Search Plaintiffs had not adequately alleged that they shared any individually identifiable health information with Eyemart and that the Prescription Plaintiffs had not shown that such information was disclosed to Meta (slip op. at 4-5).
What the court held
The plaintiffs have Article III standing. The unauthorized disclosure of their individually identifiable health information to Meta is a concrete and particularized injury, traceable to Eyemart and redressable by the injunction and damages they seek. (slip op. at 6-10)
Plaintiffs have suffered an actionable injury in fact in the unauthorized disclosure of their IIHI to Meta.
slip op. at 7 The harm resembles intrusion upon seclusion and public disclosure of private facts. The court relied on decisions of the Second, Third, Sixth and District of Columbia Circuits, most involving the Pixel, and said health information is inherently sensitive and personal. (slip op. at 7-9)
These analogies apply with even more force to the disclosure of personal health information at issue here.
slip op. at 9 For standing, a plaintiff does not have to allege every element of the analogous common law tort; the comparison is between kinds of harm. (slip op. at 8-9)
Following the parties, the court used HIPAA's definition of individually identifiable health information, 42 U.S.C. § 1320d(6), and held that such information need not reveal a specific diagnosis or condition; relating to a condition or to the provision of care is enough. (slip op. at 11)
It need not reveal a specific diagnosis or condition; that it pertains to a condition or provision of healthcare is sufficient.
slip op. at 11 Because Eyemart is a healthcare products and services provider, activity on its site pertains to users' vision, and because, as alleged, Meta paired that activity with identifying information, it constitutes individually identifiable health information. (slip op. at 12)
By virtue of its position as a healthcare products and services provider, activity on Eyemart’s Site pertains to individuals’ vision.
slip op. at 12 The court distinguished American Hospital Ass'n v. Becerra, where the technology at issue only connected an IP address with a visit to a site. Here the plaintiffs alleged that Meta captured their searches for products and providers and paired them with their Facebook information, and that Eyemart's own privacy policy said health information is requested when scheduling an appointment. (slip op. at 13-14)
Here, Plaintiffs’ information shared with Meta goes beyond that.
slip op. at 14 Taking the allegations as true, the Search Plaintiffs' shopping and scheduling information relates to their health and the provision of healthcare services, so the district court erred in finding they shared no health information with Eyemart. (slip op. at 10-14)
At this early stage, taking Plaintiffs’ factual allegations as true, the Search Plaintiffs’ shopping and scheduling information “relates to” their health and the provision of healthcare services, within HIPAA’s definition of IIHI.
slip op. at 14 The district court also erred on the Prescription Plaintiffs. It treated a sample figure offered as an example as dispositive, drew inferences in Eyemart's favor and set aside other allegations; read as a whole, the complaint plausibly alleged that Eyemart shared the plaintiffs' health information with Meta without their consent. (slip op. at 14-17)
In other words, the district court considered a figure expressly included “[b]y way of example” to be dispositive.
slip op. at 16 The court agreed that the plaintiffs have standing, reversed the dismissal and remanded, noting that if the district court finds the elements of the claims adequately pleaded, discovery will be needed to test the allegations. (slip op. at 17-18)
What it did not decide
- Whether the plaintiffs adequately pleaded the elements of any claim, including the federal Wiretap Act, Missouri and Illinois claims; the court remanded for the district court to reconsider all of the substantive claims (slip op. at 3 n.2, 18).
- Whether Eyemart is a HIPAA covered entity, and the plaintiffs' reliance on HIPAA in their Wiretap Act claim (slip op. at 3 n.2).
- Identifiability was not contested: Eyemart's counsel conceded at oral argument that the information Meta received was individually identifiable because it was linked to specific Facebook users, so the court did not have to resolve that question (slip op. at 11).
- The opinion does not discuss the Wiretap Act's party exception, its crime-tort exception, consent as a defense or statutory damages.
The tracking involved
Tools
- Meta Pixel
- customer list uploads to Meta
Data
- product searches and clicks
- product viewing information
- appointment scheduling details, including store name and location
- prescription information entered when ordering eyewear
- email addresses and purchase information in customer lists
How it bears on website tracking claims
Supports: strengthens a website tracking claim on this issue. Limits: narrows or defeats a website tracking claim on this issue. Context: bears on the issue without deciding it either way.
Supports: Standing and injury
Whether the people suing were harmed in a way that lets a federal court hear the claim.
A federal court of appeals held that the unauthorized disclosure of health information to Meta through a pixel is a concrete injury even though it is intangible. That answers a no-injury defense for health data in the Fifth Circuit, which covers Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi; courts elsewhere are not bound by it. The holding rests on allegations that the information related to health and was linked to identified Facebook users.
Supports: Health information
What counts as individually identifiable health information when it is sent through tracking tools.
The court read the definition broadly: browsing and searching for prescription eyewear and trying to schedule an eye exam on a health products and services provider's site related to health, with no diagnosis or symptom entered. It set Becerra apart as a case about an IP address and a page visit alone. The reading came at the pleading stage, under a definition the parties chose, and with identifiability conceded.
Context: HIPAA
How HIPAA, its criminal provision at 42 U.S.C. § 1320d-6 and HHS guidance bear on tracking.
The court used HIPAA's definition of individually identifiable health information as a yardstick because the parties did, and it noted that HIPAA itself gives no private right to sue. It did not address whether Eyemart is a covered entity or the plaintiffs' HIPAA-based Wiretap Act theory. HIPAA's criminal provision, 42 U.S.C. § 1320d-6, uses the same defined term, but the court did not apply its reading to that provision.
Arguments it addresses
- Sharing browsing data causes no concrete injury
- The court held that the unauthorized disclosure of health information to Meta is a concrete and particularized injury even though it is intangible (slip op. at 7-9).
- Browsing products is not health information
- The court held the information need not reveal a diagnosis, and that, taking the allegations as true, shopping and scheduling activity on a health products and services provider's site related to health and the provision of care (slip op. at 11-14).
- AHA v. Becerra means a page visit is not health information
- The court distinguished Becerra as involving only an IP address and a visit to a site, while the plaintiffs alleged searches, scheduling details and matching to Facebook profiles (slip op. at 13-14).
- The plaintiffs must plead every element of the analogous tort to have standing
- The court rejected that reading; standing compares the type of harm, not each element of the tort (slip op. at 8-9).
- The complaint's own screenshots show no health data
- The court held that a figure offered as an example does not override the complaint's other allegations, which must be read as a whole (slip op. at 14-17).
For a company that received a letter
- This is a published opinion of the Fifth Circuit, which covers Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi; courts in other circuits are not bound by it.
- The decision addresses standing and what counts as health information at the pleading stage; it does not decide whether any statute was violated.
- The court relied on allegations that Meta linked site activity to Facebook accounts, which Eyemart's counsel conceded at oral argument made the information individually identifiable, and on alleged uploads of customer lists with purchase information so that Meta could match users to their Facebook profiles.
- Shopping and appointment steps on a health products and services provider's site were treated as health information even without a diagnosis or symptom.
What to check on your own site
- Check whether product views, searches and add-to-cart events for prescription products send product names or descriptions to an advertising platform.
- Check what each step of an appointment booking flow sends to third parties, including store or location names.
- Check whether customer lists uploaded to advertising platforms include what customers bought or viewed.
Later history
No later history was found when this page was checked on November 10, 2026.
Sources
Related rulings
Published by Privacy Resolve from public records. It does not cover our own matters.
General information only, not legal advice, and not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Laws, deadlines, defenses and outcomes vary by jurisdiction and facts.