Public pages use no advertising trackers. The secure portal uses an essential session cookie and the service providers described in our privacy policy.

Skip to main content
← Back to Resources
Case notes·November 10, 2026·6 min read

Baker v. Index Exchange: A Website's Consent Is Not the End of a Wiretap Claim

A federal court in Chicago let a wiretap claim proceed against an ad exchange although the website consented, on an alleged breach of federal sensitive-data rules.

PR
Privacy Resolve
Last reviewed November 10, 2026

Few people have heard of an ad exchange, but details about the page they are reading can reach one in the moment before an ad appears. Baker v. Index Exchange, Inc. asked what follows when the website a person was using had agreed to that sharing. The court's answer: the website's consent is a defense the company has to raise and prove, and even uncontested consent does not end the case if the interception was made for the purpose of a separate unlawful act.

The case at a glance

Baker v. Index Exchange, Inc., No. 25 C 10517, ECF No. 75 (N.D. Ill. June 16, 2026). Decided June 16, 2026, by the United States District Court for the Northern District of Illinois (Judge Matthew F. Kennelly), which denied the defendants' motion to dismiss the first amended complaint.

Index Exchange runs what the industry calls a supply-side platform. As the court described the allegations, when a person visits a participating website, the company sends advertisers a "bid request" carrying details about the webpage and identifiers such as the person's IP address, cookie data and advertising IDs, along with inferences about the person's device, location, interests and browsing. Advertisers bid, the winning ad loads, and the whole exchange takes milliseconds. The company also allegedly matched its own user identifiers with those of other companies through "cookie syncing," including Temu, an online shopping platform the complaint describes as Chinese-owned.

The plaintiff, an Illinois resident, visited BibleGateway.com, a site that takes part in the company's ad sales. He alleged that Index Exchange intercepted his communications with the site and shared his information with other companies, Temu among them. His one claim was under the federal Wiretap Act.

What the court held

Consent is the defendant's burden. "But consent under the Wiretap Act is an affirmative defense, and a plaintiff need not anticipate or refute potential affirmative defenses in his complaint." (Slip op. at 9.)

Even uncontested consent leaves a question. The plaintiff did not dispute that the website consented. The court held that this did not decide the case: "Even when consent is uncontested, as it is here, dismissal is inappropriate without considering whether Baker has plausibly pleaded that the crime/tort exception applies." (Slip op. at 10.)

The separate wrong came from a federal regulation. The plaintiff relied on the Justice Department's rules on bulk sensitive personal data, which took effect on April 8, 2025 and restrict data transactions between United States persons and "covered persons" tied to countries of concern. The court described a claim premised on those rules as "based on the alleged wrongful act of transmitting Americans' sensitive personal data in a manner that may give foreign adversaries access to such data" and concluded that the plaintiff sufficiently alleged that the company's officers and employees in the United States, who are covered by the rules, violated them by directing bulk data transactions with Temu (slip op. at 12-13). Whether Temu is a covered person was a factual dispute for later (slip op. at 15).

The claim was stated. "To summarize, even if BibleGateway.com consented to the interception of its communications with Baker, he has sufficiently alleged that the crime/tort exception applies based on Index Exchange's alleged violation of the BSD regulations. The Court therefore concludes that Baker has stated a claim under the Electronic Communications Privacy Act, 18 U.S.C. § 2511." (Slip op. at 15.)

Illinois could hear the case. On jurisdiction, the court wrote: "But the fact that a defendant may be subject to jurisdiction in many states does not make it unfair to exercise jurisdiction in a given state when the defendant has purposefully availed itself 'of the privilege of conducting activities within [that] State.'" (Slip op. at 6.) As the plaintiff alleged, every ad the company helped display in Illinois required sending an Illinois user's data first, which tied the claim to its Illinois business.

Why it matters when ad companies learn about health page visits

People do not choose the advertising companies that receive data about the pages they read; the website does. When a visitor to a health site reads about a condition or a treatment, the site's advertising partners can learn about the page as part of deciding which ad to show. Companies in that chain usually defend themselves by pointing to the website's consent. This decision explains why that defense is not automatic: consent is an affirmative defense, and a plaintiff can still show that the interception was made for the purpose of a separate unlawful act.

The case also widens the idea of what that separate act can be. Most crime-tort arguments rest on a privacy tort or a state privacy statute. Here the wrong was defined by a federal regulation about where sensitive data may go. The court did not find that any data reached a prohibited recipient or that any rule was broken; it held only that the allegations were enough to proceed. But the reasoning shows that the law governing what happens to data after it leaves a website can matter as much as the law governing how it was collected.

Finally, the jurisdiction ruling matters to individuals. A company that profits from showing ads to people in a state can be asked to answer for its data practices in that state's courts.

What the defendants argued, and how the court answered

The website's consent. The defendants argued that the website, as a party to the communication, consented, so the one-party consent rule exempted them. The court treated consent as an affirmative defense and, because the plaintiff did not contest it, considered it. It then held that the crime-tort exception still had to be examined, and found it adequately pleaded.

A Canadian company. The defendants argued that the data rules do not apply to Index Exchange because it is a Canadian company. The court looked to the company's officers and employees in the United States, who are covered by the rules, and held that ordinary rules of vicarious liability make a company answerable for its employees' acts within the scope of their work (slip op. at 11-13).

Specificity. The defendants said the complaint named no specific transaction, date or decision. The court noted that no heightened pleading standard applied and that a company acts only through its people, so the detailed allegations about the data transfers supported the inference that employees directed them (slip op. at 12-13).

Jurisdiction. The defendants argued that it was unfair to make them defend in Illinois merely because the plaintiff happened to be there when he visited the site, since that logic would expose them to suit wherever their publishers have visitors. The court answered that being subject to suit in many states does not make it unfair to be sued in one where the company has purposefully done business (slip op. at 6).

The plaintiff did not win every point. The court found his theory that the company's United States affiliate was its alter ego insufficiently pleaded (slip op. at 13-14). The claim went forward on the other theories.

Subsequent history

This ruling addressed the first amended complaint. In August 2026 the plaintiff filed a second amended complaint pleading the same single wiretap count on the same theory, and the company's United States affiliate was given a September 2026 deadline to move to dismiss it. A second ruling on the docket is therefore possible, and none has changed this one. The ruling accepts the complaint's allegations as true and makes no finding that any data reached Temu or that any regulation was violated.

Read the opinion

Related case notes: In re Allstate and Arity Consumer Privacy Litigation and Cheung v. Slickdeals.

Checked on November 10, 2026.

Privacy Resolve is not a law firm, and this is not legal advice.

General information only, not legal advice, and not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Laws, deadlines, defenses and outcomes vary by jurisdiction and facts.