Public pages use no advertising trackers. The secure portal uses an essential session cookie and the service providers described in our privacy policy.

Skip to main content
← Back to Resources
Case notes·November 10, 2026·5 min read

Cheung v. Slickdeals: A Forbidden Disclosure as the Separate Wrong, and Why Specifics Win

A federal court let a wiretap claim proceed where a deals site allegedly sent purchase details to advertisers, and showed why specific allegations decide standing.

PR
Privacy Resolve
Last reviewed November 10, 2026

Cheung v. Slickdeals, LLC teaches two things at once. The first is legal: when a website allegedly hands advertisers information that another privacy law forbids it to disclose, that disclosure can be the separate wrongful act that defeats the Wiretap Act's party defense. The second is practical: of the two people who sued, the one who described exactly what was sent kept his claims, and the one who described her browsing in general terms did not.

The case at a glance

Cheung v. Slickdeals, LLC, 2026 WL 1872831 (C.D. Cal. June 29, 2026), No. 2:26-cv-00519-CAS-MBKx, ECF No. 44. Decided June 29, 2026, by the United States District Court for the Central District of California (Judge Christina A. Snyder), which granted the motion to dismiss in part and denied it in part.

The defendant runs a deal-finding website. The plaintiffs alleged that it installed tracking tools that sent users' page views, product views, searches and checkout steps, with persistent identifiers, to advertising and analytics companies including Meta and Google, and that the web addresses those tools carried included the names of products users looked at or bought. One plaintiff, Andrew Cheung, alleged that he used deal links on the site to buy video games and that his purchases were sent to the tracking companies along with his Facebook ID. The second plaintiff, Nina Harris, alleged that her browsing was tracked. They sued under the Video Privacy Protection Act, the federal Wiretap Act, the California Invasion of Privacy Act, California's unfair competition law and for unjust enrichment.

What the court held

The party defense did not apply at this stage. "The Court finds that plaintiffs sufficiently allege that defendant intercepted plaintiff Cheung's communications for the purpose of committing a separate and independent tortious act such that the party consent defense is inapplicable at the pleading stage." (Slip op. at 23.)

The separate act was the disclosure to advertisers. "This alleged disclosure of plaintiff Cheung's video purchase information to advertisers is therefore allegedly tortious conduct that is 'independent of the interception itself.'" (Slip op. at 23.) The disclosure was alleged to violate the Video Privacy Protection Act, which forbids certain disclosures of a consumer's video purchases.

Money was not a defense on the pleadings. If the site's purpose was financial and the tort only "incidental," the court said "such a determination is better made on a more complete factual record," and added: "Moreover, allegations of financial motivation do not preclude a tortious purpose." (Slip op. at 23-24.)

The specific plaintiff had standing. "The Court finds that plaintiff Cheung adequately alleges an injury analogous to a common law invasion of privacy tort, specifically the tort of intrusion upon seclusion, because plaintiff Cheung has a reasonable expectation of privacy in his 'video-viewing history.'" (Slip op. at 15.) His video privacy, wiretap and unjust enrichment claims went forward.

The general one did not, yet. Harris's California claims were dismissed for lack of standing, with leave to amend, because her complaint referred only in general terms to browsing activity and page interactions and did not show a harm like the privacy invasions the common law recognized (slip op. at 12-16).

Why it matters for people whose health searches were shared

The contrast between the two plaintiffs is the most useful part of the decision. Both used the same website and both said they were tracked. The difference was that one could point to particular purchases tied to his identity and sent to particular companies, and the other could point only to browsing in general. For anyone whose health searches or page visits were shared, the lesson is that specifics carry a claim: which pages, which searches or form entries, which identifiers, and which companies received them. A general sense of being tracked is a starting point, not a pleading.

The legal holding matters too. The separate wrong here was a disclosure that a specific privacy statute forbids. Health information is the subject of its own federal and state laws, and when a disclosure of that information is one a law prohibits, the reasoning in this decision explains how it can serve as the separate act the Wiretap Act requires. The court did not say that any particular health law plays that role; it showed how the analysis works.

Finally, the court drew a reasonable inference from the site's business model. The site argued that it could not have known about purchases completed on other retailers' sites. The court disagreed at this stage, pointing to the allegation that the site earns a commission on sales made through its links (slip op. at 21). Courts can infer what a business knows from how it makes money.

What the site argued, and how the court answered

The party defense. The site invoked the rule that a party to a communication does not unlawfully intercept it. The court accepted that the party defense exists and held it inapplicable at the pleading stage because the interception was allegedly for a separate tortious purpose.

Independence. The site argued that the plaintiffs were simply saying the interception itself was tortious. The court located the tort in a different act: the disclosure of purchase information to advertisers.

Financial purpose. To the extent the site's purpose was financial rather than tortious, the court left that question for a fuller record and held that a financial motive does not rule out a tortious one.

Coverage and possession. The site argued that the video privacy law did not cover it because purchases were completed with other retailers, and that it never had the purchase data. The court held that the statute reaches businesses engaged in the sale or delivery of video content, not only the store where the purchase is completed, and that whether the site actually possessed and disclosed the purchases was a factual dispute for later (slip op. at 20-21).

Subsequent history

The order tested the original complaint. On July 13, 2026, the plaintiffs filed an amended complaint, which is now the operative pleading, and nothing on the docket since then is a ruling that changes this order. Because it ruled on a motion to dismiss, the court accepted the allegations as true and made no finding that the site disclosed anything.

Read the opinion

Related case notes: Garcia v. Truist, M.C. 1 v. Curriculum Associates and, on standing for privacy harms, Drazen v. Pinto.

Checked on November 10, 2026.

Privacy Resolve is not a law firm, and this is not legal advice.

General information only, not legal advice, and not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Laws, deadlines, defenses and outcomes vary by jurisdiction and facts.