Public pages use no advertising trackers. The secure portal uses an essential session cookie and the service providers described in our privacy policy.

Skip to main content
← Back to Resources
Case notes·November 10, 2026·4 min read

Booker v. Robert Half: Cutting a Punitive Damages Bar Out of an Arbitration Clause

In an opinion by then-Judge Roberts, the D.C. Circuit affirmed an order cutting a ban on punitive damages out of an arbitration clause and compelling arbitration.

PR
Privacy Resolve
Last reviewed November 19, 2026

When an arbitration clause contains a term the law will not enforce, a court has two choices. It can refuse to enforce the clause at all and let the claim go to court, or it can cut out the offending term and enforce the rest. Booker v. Robert Half International, Inc., an opinion by then-Judge John Roberts, now Chief Justice of the United States, chose the second path and explained when it is the right one. For a claimant, the result was an arbitration in which punitive damages were back on the table.

The case at a glance

Booker v. Robert Half International, Inc., 413 F.3d 77 (D.C. Cir. 2005), No. 04-7089. Decided July 1, 2005, by the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, in an opinion by then-Judge John G. Roberts, Jr.

A punitive damages bar and a severability clause

An employee signed an employment agreement that required arbitration of any dispute and stated that punitive damages could not be awarded in the arbitration. The agreement also had a severability clause, providing that a provision found invalid would not affect the rest. After leaving the company, he sued for racial discrimination under the District of Columbia Human Rights Act, which allows punitive damages. The company asked him to arbitrate, and its lawyer agreed in writing that the arbitration would not bar punitive damages. He insisted on court. The district court found the punitive damages bar unenforceable, severed it, and compelled arbitration. He appealed.

What the court held

The opinion opens by stating the problem and the result: "The arbitration clause was unenforceable as written because it precluded an award of punitive damages, which are available under the D.C. statute." The features of the agreement and the law "lead us to affirm the decision below, severing the ban on punitive damages and compelling arbitration." 413 F.3d at 79.

On appeal, the bar itself was not in dispute: "The parties do not dispute that the arbitration agreement's bar on punitive damages is unenforceable as applied to Booker's claim under the DCHRA." Id. at 83. The question was what to do about it, and the court agreed with the district court: "We agree with the district court that severing the punitive damages bar and enforcing the arbitration clause was proper here." Id. at 85.

The court explained why a remedy term is especially easy to remove: "by severing a remedial component of the arbitration clause, the district court removed a provision generally understood as not being essential to a contract's consideration, and thus more readily severable." Id.

Why it matters when website terms ban punitive damages

Website terms that require arbitration sometimes also exclude punitive or exemplary damages. This decision shows how a court can respond without taking the claim out of arbitration: the remedy limit is cut out, and the person bringing the claim arbitrates with the remedies the statute provides.

That matters for privacy claims because punitive damages are part of how some privacy statutes deter violations. The federal Wiretap Act allows punitive damages in appropriate cases; our guide to its damages provision quotes the statute. For a person whose health searches or page visits were intercepted, a clause purporting to bar that remedy is the kind of discrete term this court found easy to sever.

The opinion also offers a reason courts can give for severing rather than voiding: the more a drafter loads an agreement with unlawful terms, the less likely a court can save it by trimming, which itself discourages overreaching (413 F.3d at 84-85). A clause with one unlawful remedy term is the easy case. A clause riddled with unlawful terms may not survive at all.

The arguments in the case, and how the court answered

Consent to severance. The employee pointed to a clause requiring written consent for any change to the agreement and argued that severing the bar changed the contract without his consent. The court found no conflict: both parties had signed the severability clause, so excising an invalid term was a contingency they agreed to at the outset, not a later modification (413 F.3d at 83).

Incentives. The employee argued that if courts simply cut out illegal terms, drafters lose nothing by including them. The court answered that overreaching makes severance less likely, because a pervasively unlawful agreement cannot be repaired by trimming (413 F.3d at 84-85).

The company's own concession. Before the case reached court, the company's lawyer had agreed that the arbitration would not bar punitive damages. By the time of the appeal the point was undisputed: a bar on a remedy the statute provides could not be enforced against that statutory claim.

The employee did not get the court trial he wanted. The value of the decision for people who bring claims lies in its remedy holding: the arbitration that went forward was one where punitive damages could be awarded.

Subsequent history

None. No later order in the case disturbs the decision.

Read the opinion

Related case notes: Hadnot v. Bay and Morrison v. Circuit City, which the court cited.

Checked on November 10, 2026.

Privacy Resolve is not a law firm, and this is not legal advice.

General information only, not legal advice, and not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Laws, deadlines, defenses and outcomes vary by jurisdiction and facts.