An arbitration clause can do two different things. It can choose the forum, and it can limit what the decision maker is allowed to award. A common limit is a flat ban on punitive damages. Hadnot v. Bay, Ltd. shows what happens when such a ban meets a claim under a statute that provides punitive damages: the ban is struck, and the arbitration goes forward with the full remedy available.
The case at a glance
Hadnot v. Bay, Ltd., 344 F.3d 474 (5th Cir. 2003), No. 03-40325. Decided September 11, 2003, by the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, in an opinion by Judge Wiener.
An employment agreement that banned punitive damages
An employee signed an employment agreement whose arbitration provision barred the arbitrator from awarding exemplary or punitive damages. He later sued the company for racial discrimination under Title VII, the federal employment discrimination law, which provides for punitive damages. The district court struck the ban and ordered the case to arbitration. The employee appealed, arguing that the agreement lacked consideration and that the unlawful ban made the entire arbitration provision void.
What the court held
The Fifth Circuit affirmed. It agreed with the district court that the ban could not be enforced against the claim: "As the district court correctly noted, the Agreement's ban on punitive and exemplary damages is unenforceable in a Title VII case." It added: "Because Title VII provides for statutory punitive damages, the district court found the ban on such damages unenforceable. We agree with that determination." 344 F.3d at 478 n.14. In the same footnote, the court relied on the Supreme Court's statement in Mitsubishi v. Soler that agreeing to arbitrate a statutory claim does not give up the statute's substantive rights.
The court then explained why striking the ban did not doom the arbitration clause: "Even with its unlawful limitation on the types or permissible damage awards lifted, so that the decision maker is free to address punitive damages, the arbitration clause remains capable of achieving this goal. In fact, the lifting of that illegal restriction enhances the ability of the arbitration provision to function fully and adequately under the law." 344 F.3d at 478.
And it described the result for the employee: "As a potential arbitrator in this case is now authorized to award punitive damages, as well as compensatory damages, Hadnot's rights under Title VII are fully protected." Id. The judgment: "the district court's order voiding the prohibition of awarding punitive damages and compelling arbitration is, in all respects, AFFIRMED." Id. at 478-79.
Why it matters when website terms limit damages
The reasoning turns on a simple conflict. When a statute authorizes punitive damages, a private contract that forbids them takes away something the legislature chose to provide. The court resolved that conflict by enforcing the statute's remedy and keeping the parties' choice of forum.
Privacy law presents the same conflict. The federal Wiretap Act allows "punitive damages in appropriate cases" in addition to statutory damages, as our guide to the Act's damages provision explains. Some website terms of use combine an arbitration requirement with a clause excluding punitive or exemplary damages. A person whose health searches or page visits were intercepted, and who is held to such terms, can point to this decision for the proposition that the exclusion is the part that gives way.
The decision also explains why courts are comfortable doing this. Striking the ban does not rewrite the bargain against the company's interest in arbitration; in the court's words, removing the restriction "enhances the ability of the arbitration provision to function fully and adequately under the law." A court can enforce the forum the company wrote and still give the person bringing the claim the remedy the statute provides.
What the arguments were, and how the court answered
The ban itself. The agreement said the arbitrator could not award punitive or exemplary damages. The district court held the ban unenforceable against a claim under a statute providing for punitive damages, and the Fifth Circuit agreed.
Severability. The employee argued that the unlawful ban was integral to the agreement and made the entire arbitration provision void, hoping to escape arbitration altogether. The court rejected the argument: the clause's purpose, resolving employment disputes in arbitration, survives intact once the illegal restriction is lifted.
Formation arguments. The employee also argued that the agreement lacked consideration and that he had been offered the job before signing. The court found valid consideration under Texas law, because the agreement was signed in exchange for the company's consideration of his application and its offer of employment (344 F.3d at 476-78).
The employee did not get the court trial he wanted. What he got was an arbitration in which punitive damages were available, which is the part of the decision that matters to anyone facing a clause that limits remedies.
Subsequent history
None. No later order in the case disturbs the decision.
Read the opinion
Related case notes: Morrison v. Circuit City and Booker v. Robert Half.
Checked on November 10, 2026.
Privacy Resolve is not a law firm, and this is not legal advice.