Public pages use no advertising trackers. The secure portal uses an essential session cookie and the service providers described in our privacy policy.

Skip to main content
← Back to Resources
Case notes·November 10, 2026·4 min read

Brown v. Dillard's: A Company That Refuses Its Own Arbitration Loses the Right to Force It

The Ninth Circuit held that a company that ignored a properly started arbitration breached its own agreement and could not later force the claim out of court.

PR
Privacy Resolve
Last reviewed November 19, 2026

Companies that write arbitration clauses usually do so because they prefer arbitration to court. Sometimes, when a person actually starts the arbitration the company's own terms require, the company does not show up or does not pay its share of the fees. Brown v. Dillard's, Inc. answers what happens next: the company is in breach of its own agreement, and it cannot later use that agreement to push the claim out of court.

The case at a glance

Brown v. Dillard's, Inc., 430 F.3d 1004 (9th Cir. 2005), No. 03-56719. Decided December 6, 2005, by the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, in an opinion by Judge William A. Fletcher.

An arbitration the company would not join

A sales associate at one of the company's California stores was fired. The company's dispute program required employees to arbitrate claims, and she started an arbitration by filing a notice of intent to arbitrate with the American Arbitration Association. The Association wrote to the company asking it to pay its share of the filing fee. "Dillard's did not respond to the AAA letters, nor did it pay its share of the filing fee." 430 F.3d at 1008-09. Without the fee the arbitration could not go forward, so she sued in state court. The company removed the case to federal court and asked the court to compel arbitration. The district court refused, and the Ninth Circuit affirmed.

What the court held

The rule. "we hold that when an employer enters into an arbitration agreement with its employees, it must itself participate in properly initiated arbitration proceedings or forego its right to compel arbitration. That is, we hold that Dillard's cannot compel Brown to honor an arbitration agreement of which it is itself in material breach." 430 F.3d at 1006.

Applied. "Dillard's breached its agreement with Brown by refusing to participate in the arbitration proceedings Brown initiated. Having breached the agreement, Dillard's cannot now enforce it." Id. at 1009-10.

The proper course. "If Dillard's believed Brown's claim was meritless, its proper course of action was to make that argument in arbitration." Id. at 1010.

Waiver, too. "Dillard's concedes that it knew of its right to arbitrate, and its refusal to arbitrate after being served with Brown's notice of intent to arbitrate was an act inconsistent with that right." Id. at 1012.

Why the rule exists. "We decline to adopt a rule that would encourage companies to refuse to participate in properly initiated arbitration proceedings." Id. And the court described the employee's position plainly: "The American Arbitration Association could not compel Dillard's to pay its share of the filing fee, and in the absence of the fee it could not proceed. Brown had no choice but to come to court. Many people in Brown's position would simply have given up." Id. at 1013.

Why it matters when website terms require arbitration

Many websites' terms of use say that disputes must be arbitrated, often before a named provider whose rules require the business to pay most of the fees in a consumer case. A person whose health searches or page visits were sent to third parties may find that the company insists on that process. This decision explains the other side of the bargain: once a claimant properly starts the arbitration the company chose, the company has to take part. If it refuses, or lets the arbitration die by not paying what the rules require of it, it is the company that has broken the agreement.

The court's reasoning rests on general contract principles rather than anything special to employment. A party in material breach of a contract generally cannot enforce it against the other side. Applied to an arbitration clause, that means a company cannot treat arbitration as a shield it raises only when it is sued and drops when a claimant takes it at its word.

The decision also closes off a tempting tactic. A company that thinks a claim is weak may be inclined to ignore an arbitration demand and wait. The court's answer is that the place to say a claim lacks merit is the arbitration itself.

What the company argued, and how the court answered

Enforcing after a breach. The company argued that whatever it had done before the lawsuit, it could still enforce the arbitration agreement once sued. The court held that, under general principles of California contract law, its material breach deprived it of the right to enforce the agreement.

Merits. The company had told the employee that her complaint had no merit and that it would not arbitrate, and it argued that her notice did not state a real claim. The court's answer was that a company with that view must make the argument in arbitration, not refuse to arbitrate.

Prejudice. On waiver, the company argued that the employee was not harmed by its refusal. The court disagreed: she went to court only as a last resort, and the delay and expense the refusal caused her counted as prejudice (430 F.3d at 1012-13).

Subsequent history

No later order disturbs the decision. In 2019, California's Legislature cited it by name in the findings of a law on unpaid arbitration fees, stating an intent to affirm it and a companion Ninth Circuit decision, Sink v. Aden Enterprises, on the principle that a company's failure to pay the fees its arbitration agreement requires is a breach that lets the other party bring the claim in court (Stats. 2019, ch. 870, § 1, subds. (e)-(f)).

Read the opinion

Related case notes: Mitsubishi v. Soler and Booker v. Robert Half.

Checked on November 10, 2026.

Privacy Resolve is not a law firm, and this is not legal advice.

General information only, not legal advice, and not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Laws, deadlines, defenses and outcomes vary by jurisdiction and facts.