Two arguments appear in almost every motion to dismiss a website wiretap claim. The first is that the "tort" a plaintiff points to is just the interception under another name. The second is that the company acted to make money, not to commit a tort. In M.C. 1 v. Curriculum Associates, LLC, a federal court in Massachusetts rejected both at the pleading stage, and it did so in a case where the defendant was itself the party receiving the communications, the position in which the party defense is strongest.
The case at a glance
M.C. 1 v. Curriculum Associates, LLC, No. 25-13942-FDS, ECF No. 49 (D. Mass. Sept. 30, 2026). Decided September 30, 2026, by the United States District Court for the District of Massachusetts (Judge Saylor). The court granted the motion to dismiss in part and denied it in part; the federal wiretap count survived.
Schoolchildren and required learning software
The plaintiffs are California schoolchildren, suing through their parents, whose schools required them to use the company's i-Ready learning and assessment software. They alleged that the company collected identifying information, demographics, school and grade level, IP addresses and assessment results, and shared student data with third parties without consent from the students or anyone authorized to give it. They also alleged that the company misled parents and educators by leaving out the companies, including Google, with which it shared the information. The complaint pleaded claims under federal and state law.
What the court held
The court treated the company as a party to the communications, because the students were communicating with its software. Under the Wiretap Act, that meant the company was exempt unless the crime-tort exception applied. The plaintiffs alleged that the company disclosed the contents of those communications to third parties for the purpose of invading their privacy, and the court accepted that theory at this stage.
Independence. "The alleged wrongful conduct meets the independence requirement because the disclosure of the data is separate from the interception of the data." (Slip op. at 7.)
Which privacy tort. The court read an earlier Second Circuit decision, which held that intrusion upon seclusion cannot serve as the separate tort because it happens through the interception itself, as leaving the other privacy torts available: "If plaintiff had invoked one of '[t]he remaining three categories of invasion of privacy,' all of which 'cannot be accomplished simply by intercepting one's communications,' he might have successfully pleaded independent tortious conduct." (Slip op. at 8 n.2.)
Primary motivation. "Under the circumstances, the complaint plausibly alleges facts sufficient to fit within the crime-tort exception to the Wiretap Act. Whether defendant's alleged tortious motive was the 'primary motivation' or 'determinative factor' for the interceptions is an issue that is best resolved on a factual record, not from the bare allegations of the complaint." (Slip op. at 9.)
Money. "Finally, the Court respectfully disagrees with the reasoning of courts that have concluded that a financial motive insulates a defendant from the application of the crime-tort exception." The reason was the text of the statute: "The statute contains no such language, and many crimes and torts, such as fraud and conversion, are normally committed solely for monetary gain." (Slip op. at 9.)
The motion to dismiss the wiretap count was denied. In reaching these conclusions, the court relied in part on Doe v. Baystate Health System, the Massachusetts hospital website decision.
Why it matters for searches and page visits
The facts here involve students and school software, and the reasoning is what carries over to any website. The sequence the court described is familiar: the site receives a visitor's request for a page, a search or a form, and then code on the site sends details of that request to an advertising or analytics company. The court's point is that those are two different acts. Receiving the request is the communication; handing it to someone else is the disclosure. A claim built on the second act is not just a claim about the first one renamed.
The money argument matters even more. Websites rarely share visitor data for any reason other than advertising, measurement or revenue, so a rule that a financial motive defeats the exception would end most claims before they start. This court refused to adopt one, and it gave a reason anyone can check: the words of the statute. Fraud and conversion are committed for money too, and no one thinks the profit motive excuses them.
The footnote on privacy torts is practical as well. A claim framed only as intrusion upon seclusion risks the argument that the tort is the interception itself. A claim framed around disclosure, whether as public disclosure of private facts or under a state privacy statute, points to a separate act. That is the line the court drew, and it is the same line drawn in the hospital case it cited.
This is one district court's pleading-stage ruling, and it does not bind courts elsewhere. Its reasoning is still useful wherever the same arguments are made.
The defense positions, and how the court answered
Party status. The company contended that it was a party to the communications, and the court agreed. It then applied the statute's exception: a party's interception is still unlawful when it is for the purpose of committing a crime or tort. The alleged disclosure to third parties supplied that purpose.
Independence. The court held that the alleged disclosure is a separate act from the interception, so the tort pleaded was not the interception under another name.
Primary motivation. Whether a tortious motive was primary is a question for a factual record, not something to be decided from the complaint.
Financial motive. The court rejected the view that a financial motive takes a defendant outside the exception, relying on the statute's text and on the observation that many crimes and torts are committed for money.
The court did dismiss some of the other counts, so the ruling was not a complete loss for the company. The federal wiretap count was not among them.
Subsequent history
In October 2026 the company asked, with the plaintiffs' agreement, for more time to answer the remaining claims, citing the length of the complaint. That request did not ask the court to reconsider the ruling or to certify it for appeal, and no later order on the docket changes it. The ruling accepts the complaint's allegations as true and makes no finding that they are true.
Read the opinion
Related case notes: In re Allstate and Arity Consumer Privacy Litigation and Cheung v. Slickdeals.
Checked on November 10, 2026.
Privacy Resolve is not a law firm, and this is not legal advice.