· Court ruling
American Hospital Association v. Becerra
U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas, 738 F. Supp. 3d 780, No. 4:23-cv-01110-P
Primary source: Memorandum opinion and order. Checked on November 10, 2026.
A Texas federal court vacated only the part of HHS's tracking guidance treating an IP address plus a visit to a public page about specific health conditions or providers as individually identifiable health information.
What happened
Two hospital associations and a regional health care system sued the Department of Health and Human Services in the Northern District of Texas. They challenged guidance from HHS's Office for Civil Rights on how HIPAA applies to online tracking technologies. (ECF No. 67 at 3-4.)
HHS's December 2022 bulletin gave examples that trigger HIPAA obligations, including where an online technology connects an individual's IP address with a visit to an unauthenticated public webpage addressing specific health conditions or health care providers. The court called that rule the "Proscribed Combination"; HHS described it as an example, while covered entities saw a new obligation. Days before HHS's summary judgment brief was due, HHS issued a revised bulletin, dated March 18, 2024, which the court treated as the legally operative document. (ECF No. 67 at 3-4, 7, 31.)
The revised bulletin added that the combination is not enough if the visit is not related to the individual's own health, care or payment for care; the court read this as a subjective-intent gloss that left the rule effectively unchanged. Unauthenticated public webpages are pages that do not require login credentials or user verification. (ECF No. 67 at 3, 11-12.)
The case was decided on cross-motions for summary judgment on questions of law. The opinion makes no findings about any particular website, visitor or tracking tool. (ECF No. 67 at 1, 4.)
What the court held
The court held that it had jurisdiction because the revised bulletin's treatment of the Proscribed Combination was final agency action: it consummated HHS's decision-making and imposed new legal obligations on covered entities, even though the bulletin said it lacked the force and effect of law. (ECF No. 67 at 5-19)
Thus, the Revised Bulletin is a “final agency action” subject to judicial review.
ECF No. 67 at 19 The court limited its analysis to the Proscribed Combination and said much of the rest of the revised bulletin was legally and pragmatically sound. (ECF No. 67 at 7 n.3)
The Court’s analysis concerns only the Proscribed Combination and the Revised Bulletin’s attempt to apply HIPAA obligations to this ostensibly new IIHI context.
ECF No. 67 at 7 n.3 The court held that the Proscribed Combination fails HIPAA's requirement that the information relate to the individual's health, care or payment for care, because a visitor's reason for viewing a public page is unknowable and the statute says "relates to," not "may relate to." It said it would not disagree that some, or even most, visitors view such pages for reasons related to their own care, but that is not what HIPAA requires. (ECF No. 67 at 21-23)
Thus, without knowing a particular query relates to a category of information in Section 1320d(6), metadata from a UPW search cannot constitute IIHI.
ECF No. 67 at 23 The court held that the Proscribed Combination also fails the requirement that the information identify the individual or give a reasonable basis to believe it can, because information that at most supports an inference is not enough. (ECF No. 67 at 23-25)
And whatever it means, it assuredly does not include information that, at most, supports an “inference” of identification.
ECF No. 67 at 24 The court summarized its reasoning in a formula: knowing who a visitor is and what the visitor looked up does not establish that the visitor has the condition. (ECF No. 67 at 25)
Simply put, Identity (Person A) + Query (Condition B) ≠ IIHI (Person A has Condition B).
ECF No. 67 at 25 The court said a different case would arise if a covered entity's public page asked visitors their reason for visiting. (ECF No. 67 at 25)
The Department can and should remind covered entities that the Privacy Rule would apply in those circumstances.
ECF No. 67 at 25 The court declared the Proscribed Combination unlawful and vacated it under 5 U.S.C. § 706. It denied a permanent injunction because declaratory relief and vacatur would remedy the hospitals' injury. (ECF No. 67 at 26-31)
DECLARES that the Proscribed Combination, as set forth in the HHS Bulletin of March 18, 2024, is UNLAWFUL, as it was promulgated in clear excess of HHS’s authority under HIPAA.
ECF No. 67 at 31 The court stated that its vacatur does not limit the rest of the revised bulletin. (ECF No. 67 at 31 n.8)
Such vacatur is not intended to, and should not be construed as, limiting the legal operability of other guidance in the germane HHS document.
ECF No. 67 at 31 n.8
What it did not decide
- Whether the Proscribed Combination was arbitrary and capricious or required notice and comment; the court found it unnecessary to reach those arguments (ECF No. 67 at 20, 26).
- The validity of the rest of the March 18, 2024 bulletin, which the court said its vacatur should not be read to limit (ECF No. 67 at 7 n.3, 31 n.8).
- Whether any particular website's tracking violates HIPAA or any other law; no website's practices were before the court.
- Claims under the federal Wiretap Act, state wiretap and privacy laws, the FTC Act and the Health Breach Notification Rule; none was before the court, and the opinion does not mention the Wiretap Act.
The tracking involved
Tools
- Online tracking technologies in general; no specific product or website was at issue
Data
- IP address or other identifying information
- visits to unauthenticated public webpages addressing specific health conditions or health care providers
How it bears on website tracking claims
Supports: strengthens a website tracking claim on this issue. Limits: narrows or defeats a website tracking claim on this issue. Context: bears on the issue without deciding it either way.
Limits: Health information
What counts as individually identifiable health information when it is sent through tracking tools.
The court held that identifying information such as an IP address, combined with a visit to an unauthenticated public page about specific health conditions or providers, is not individually identifiable health information under 42 U.S.C. § 1320d(6), because it neither shows that the information relates to the visitor's own health nor reasonably identifies that health information (ECF No. 67 at 21-25). That reasoning narrows claims that rely on public page visits alone to establish HIPAA-protected information. The court's analysis concerned an identifier combined with a visit or query on a public page, and it said the result would differ if a site collected the visitor's reason for the visit (ECF No. 67 at 25).
Limits: HIPAA
How HIPAA, its criminal provision at 42 U.S.C. § 1320d-6 and HHS guidance bear on tracking.
The ruling vacated HHS's position that the Proscribed Combination is individually identifiable health information, which narrows HIPAA enforcement exposure based on that combination alone, and the court left the rest of the bulletin in place (ECF No. 67 at 7 n.3, 31 & n.8). The criminal provision used as a crime-tort predicate in several website-tracking cases, 42 U.S.C. § 1320d-6, applies to individually identifiable health information as defined in section 1320d(6), the same definition the court construed. The opinion does not mention the Wiretap Act, and it addressed agency guidance, not any website's conduct.
Arguments it addresses
- A page visit is not health information
- As to HIPAA's definition, the court agreed for an IP address or similar identifier combined with a visit to a public page about a condition or provider, holding that such metadata alone neither relates to the visitor's own health nor reasonably identifies it (ECF No. 67 at 21-25).
- The court struck down HHS's tracking guidance
- Only the Proscribed Combination was vacated; the court said its vacatur should not be read to limit the rest of the bulletin, much of which it called legally and pragmatically sound (ECF No. 67 at 7 n.3, 31 n.8).
- HIPAA does not apply to website tracking at all
- The opinion does not say that; it confined itself to the Proscribed Combination and said HHS should remind covered entities that the Privacy Rule applies if a site collects visitors' reasons for visiting (ECF No. 67 at 7 n.3, 25).
- This ruling defeats a HIPAA-based crime-tort theory
- The opinion construes the same definition of individually identifiable health information that 42 U.S.C. § 1320d-6 uses, but it does not mention the Wiretap Act and decided only whether HHS could treat the Proscribed Combination as such information (ECF No. 67 at 21-26, 31).
- The data was de-identified
- The court referred to the inherently de-identified nature of the page-visit metadata at issue, citing 45 C.F.R. § 164.514(a), but only in discussing the Proscribed Combination (ECF No. 67 at 25).
For a company that received a letter
- The ruling vacated one rule in HHS's guidance; it did not decide whether any website's tracking is lawful under HIPAA, the Wiretap Act, state law or the FTC Act.
- Its reasoning addresses an identifier combined with a visit or query on a public page; the court said a site that asks visitors their reason for visiting would present a different case.
- HHS appealed, and the Fifth Circuit dismissed the appeal on HHS's own motion without ruling on the merits.
- The court left the rest of the March 18, 2024 bulletin in place.
What to check on your own site
- Sort the pages that carry tracking code into public pages, pages with forms or booking tools, and logged-in pages, since the ruling addressed only public pages.
- Check whether any public page asks visitors why they are visiting or collects symptoms, conditions or other health details, and whether tracking code can read those answers.
Later history
The court entered final judgment the same day, declaring the Proscribed Combination unlawful and vacating it under 5 U.S.C. § 706 (ECF No. 68). HHS filed a notice of appeal on August 19, 2024 (ECF No. 69). According to the district court docket, the Fifth Circuit dismissed the appeal, No. 24-10775, on the appellants' motion under Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 42(b) as of September 4, 2024 (ECF No. 71). No later entry appears on the district court docket on CourtListener as of November 10, 2026.
Related rulings
Published by Privacy Resolve from public records. It does not cover our own matters.
General information only, not legal advice, and not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Laws, deadlines, defenses and outcomes vary by jurisdiction and facts.