Public pages use no advertising trackers. The secure portal uses an essential session cookie and the service providers described in our privacy policy.

Skip to main content

· Court ruling

Kurowski v. Rush System for Health

U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois, 683 F. Supp. 3d 836, No. 1:22-cv-05380

Mixed rulingMotion to dismiss the first amended complaint granted in part and denied in part

Primary source: Memorandum opinion and order. Checked on November 10, 2026.

Patients' Wiretap Act claim was dismissed because the complaint plausibly alleged only metadata, not health information, but their Illinois Eavesdropping Act claim proceeded against the health system as a principal benefiting from third-party cookies.

What happened

Two Rush patients, Marguerite Kurowski and Brenda McClendon, sued Rush University System for Health on behalf of a proposed class. They alleged that Rush secretly deployed third-party source code, such as Google Analytics, on its website and its password-protected MyChart patient portal, causing patient data and communications to be sent to Facebook, Google and Bidtellect for advertising (ECF No. 60 at 1-3).

The data allegedly sent included IP addresses, cookie identifiers, device identifiers, account numbers, URLs, other unique identifying codes and browser fingerprints, and the complaint alleged that communications inside MyChart were shared with at least Google (at 3). The complaint acknowledged that transmissions to Facebook had stopped and that Google transmissions from MyChart seemed to have stopped, while transmissions to Bidtellect appeared to be ongoing (at 14-15).

This was the court's second ruling on the pleadings. On March 3, 2023, it had dismissed the original complaint except for a claim for injunctive relief under the Illinois Uniform Deceptive Trade Practices Act, and the amended complaint pleaded eleven claims, the five from the original complaint plus six new ones, including breach of contract and the Illinois Eavesdropping Act (at 1-2; ECF No. 81 at 2). The order was issued by Judge Matthew F. Kennelly on July 24, 2023 (at 1, 27).

What the court held

  1. The parties did not appear to dispute that Rush, as the intended recipient of the communications, could invoke the party exception, so the Wiretap Act claim depended on the crime-tort exception. (ECF No. 60 at 4)

  2. The court held that 42 U.S.C. § 1320d-6 could not supply the criminal purpose because the allegations were too vague to infer that Rush disclosed individually identifiable health information rather than metadata, while recognizing that private, care-related communications would qualify. (ECF No. 60 at 4-8)

    By contrast, Kurowski's allegations are far too vague to allow an inference to be drawn that Rush was actually disclosing IIHI as it is unambiguously defined by HIPAA, rather than just metadata.

    ECF No. 60 at 7
  3. The court declined to rely on HHS's 2022 tracking guidance, holding that it was not entitled to deference and that its reading of individually identifiable health information went beyond what the statute can bear. (ECF No. 60 at 5-8)

    The interpretation of IIHI offered by HHS in its guidance goes well beyond the meaning of what the statute can bear.

    ECF No. 60 at 8
  4. The court said a plaintiff suing over the invasion of her medical privacy must reveal what she alleges was disclosed, noting that she could have asked to file the complaint under seal. (ECF No. 60 at 7)

    Kurowski cannot reasonably expect to bring a lawsuit related to the invasion of her medical privacy and completely evade revealing what it is that she alleges Rush disclosed to third parties.

    ECF No. 60 at 7
  5. Other alleged criminal or tortious purposes failed because they duplicated the alleged wiretapping or rested on claims the court had rejected, and the exception requires an act independent of the recording itself. The court dismissed the Wiretap Act count. (ECF No. 60 at 9)

  6. Illinois law does not recognize a tort claim for breach of an implied duty of confidentiality, so that count was dismissed. (ECF No. 60 at 9-11)

  7. The Illinois Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act claim failed for lack of pecuniary loss, and the claim for an injunction under the Illinois Uniform Deceptive Trade Practices Act failed because the transmissions to Facebook and Google had stopped and were not reasonably expected to recur. (ECF No. 60 at 11-16)

  8. The intrusion upon seclusion claim failed because any harm flowed from disclosure rather than intrusion, and any intrusion was by the third parties, not by Rush. (ECF No. 60 at 16-18)

    Rush cannot plausibly be considered to have intruded on, intercepted, or "bugged" private communications that it was always the intended recipient of.

    ECF No. 60 at 17-18
  9. The publication of private facts claim failed for lack of publicity, the trespass to chattels claim failed for lack of harm to the plaintiffs' devices, the good faith and fair dealing count was dismissed as a standalone claim, and the unjust enrichment count failed because it incorporated the contract allegations. (ECF No. 60 at 18-24)

  10. The breach of contract claim survived on promises in the MyChart terms and conditions, and the privacy notices they incorporate, not to share personal or health information without consent, and the court declined to enforce the terms' exculpatory clauses at the pleading stage. (ECF No. 60 at 20-23)

    Thus, Kurowski has stated a claim for breach of contract whether or not those disclosures violate other privacy laws.

    ECF No. 60 at 21-22
  11. The Illinois Eavesdropping Act claim survived on the theory that Rush knowingly derived a benefit from the third parties' allegedly illegal use of cookies on its web properties as eavesdropping devices, although the theories that Rush employed or directed those companies failed. (ECF No. 60 at 24-26)

    Rush can plausibly be considered the principal that earned a profit ("derive[d] a benefit") from the use of cookies ("eavesdropping device") on Rush's web properties by Facebook, Google, and Bidtellect's ("by another").

    ECF No. 60 at 26

What it did not decide

  • Whether any particular health information was actually disclosed; the court held only that this complaint did not plausibly allege it (ECF No. 60 at 6-8).
  • Whether HHS's guidance applies retroactively, a question the court said it need not answer definitively (at 7).
  • Whether the third parties' cookies in fact illegally eavesdropped on private electronic communications, which the principal theory requires; the court accepted the allegations at the pleading stage (at 24-26).
  • Damages under the Eavesdropping Act and class certification, which this order did not reach.

The tracking involved

Tools

  • Third-party source code, such as Google Analytics, on the website and the MyChart portal
  • Facebook, Google and Bidtellect cookies, including fbp, ga and gid cookies

Data

  • IP addresses
  • Cookie and device identifiers
  • Account numbers
  • URLs
  • Browser fingerprints
  • Communications within the MyChart portal, as alleged for Google

How it bears on website tracking claims

Supports: strengthens a website tracking claim on this issue. Limits: narrows or defeats a website tracking claim on this issue. Context: bears on the issue without deciding it either way.

  • Limits: Party exception

    Whether the website, as a party to the visit, could consent to the tracking under 18 U.S.C. § 2511(2)(d).

    Rush's status as a party to its patients' communications was not disputed, so the federal claim needed the crime-tort exception. The court also relied on that status to reject intrusion upon seclusion, holding that Rush could not have intruded on or intercepted communications it was always meant to receive. Under the Illinois statute, which the court said has no crime or tort exception to its party exception, the plaintiffs instead pleaded Rush's liability as the third parties' principal.

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Limits: Crime-tort exception

    Whether a communication was intercepted for the purpose of a criminal or tortious act, which removes the party exception.

    This order rejected 42 U.S.C. § 1320d-6 as the predicate because the complaint described only metadata, and it rejected other predicates as duplicating the interception or resting on failed claims. The ruling turned on the detail of the allegations: the court accepted that private, care-related communications would qualify, but found none plausibly alleged. On amended allegations naming the patient's physician, specialty and location, the same judge held on December 11, 2023 that the exception was adequately invoked.

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Limits: Health information

    What counts as individually identifiable health information when it is sent through tracking tools.

    The court held that IP addresses, cookie and device identifiers, account numbers, URLs and browser fingerprints, as alleged here, did not fit HIPAA's definition of individually identifiable health information, which must relate to health, care or payment for care. It contrasted a case in which a patient entered information about heart issues and high blood pressure in a portal and then saw related ads. Under this ruling, a complaint had to identify the health information it says was disclosed.

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Limits: HIPAA

    How HIPAA, its criminal provision at 42 U.S.C. § 1320d-6 and HHS guidance bear on tracking.

    Decided in July 2023, the order declined to defer to HHS's 2022 guidance on tracking technologies, holding that guidance issued outside rulemaking or adjudication does not receive Chevron-style deference and that the guidance's reading of individually identifiable health information goes well beyond what the statute can bear. It applied the statutory definition in 42 U.S.C. § 1320d(6) instead.

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Supports: State wiretap laws

    State interception statutes, such as California Penal Code § 631 and the Washington Privacy Act.

    The court allowed an Illinois Eavesdropping Act theory that Rush was liable as a principal that knowingly derived a benefit from third parties' illegal use of an eavesdropping device, even though Rush was a party to the communications. It found that the use of cookies on Rush's web properties by Facebook, Google and Bidtellect plausibly fit that theory, while rejecting the theories that Rush employed or directed those companies. The theory depends on the third parties' own eavesdropping being illegal.

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Limits: State privacy laws

    Other state privacy statutes and claims, such as medical information and health records acts and the CCPA.

    Illinois privacy torts did not fit these facts: intrusion upon seclusion failed because the alleged harm came from disclosure and any intrusion was by third parties, publication of private facts failed because disclosure to three companies was not publicity, and Illinois does not recognize a tort for breach of an implied duty of medical confidentiality. These holdings apply Illinois law.

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Limits: Consumer protection

    Deception and unfair practice claims, such as under the FTC Act and N.Y. General Business Law § 349.

    The Illinois Consumer Fraud Act claim failed because the plaintiffs alleged no pecuniary loss, and the court declined to extend a benefit-of-the-bargain theory, which the Seventh Circuit has confined to defective or dangerous products, to the plaintiffs' argument that the free web properties were part of paid health care services. The injunction-only claim under the Deceptive Trade Practices Act failed because the alleged transmissions to Facebook and Google had stopped and were not reasonably expected to recur.

    All tracker entries on this issue

Arguments it addresses

The data was only metadata
The court agreed on this complaint, holding that identifiers, URLs and similar data, as alleged, did not plausibly show disclosure of individually identifiable health information (ECF No. 60 at 6-8); amended allegations naming physicians, specialties and locations later sufficed (ECF No. 81 at 5-6).
HHS guidance does not bind courts
The court held that the guidance was not entitled to deference and went beyond what the statute can bear (ECF No. 60 at 7-8).
The website was a party to the communication
That was not disputed for the federal claim and it defeated intrusion upon seclusion, but it did not defeat the Illinois Eavesdropping Act claim pleaded on principal liability (at 4, 17-18, 24-26).
The tracking was already removed
That ended the injunction-only Deceptive Trade Practices Act claim, but the same order let the Eavesdropping Act and contract claims proceed (at 14-16, 20-26).
No pecuniary loss
That defeated the Illinois Consumer Fraud Act claim (at 11-14); the contract claim survived this order, but the court later granted Rush judgment on the pleadings on it for lack of actual damage (ECF No. 140 at 17-18).
The terms limit the provider's liability
The court declined to enforce the MyChart terms' exculpatory clauses at the pleading stage, citing unequal bargaining power, the provider-patient relationship and public policy (at 22-23).
The plaintiff has not said what was disclosed
The court agreed, holding that a medical privacy plaintiff must reveal what she alleges was disclosed and noting she could have asked to file under seal (at 7).

For a company that received a letter

  • The federal claim failed on this complaint for lack of detail about what health information was sent, and it was revived when amended allegations described the physician, specialty and location information transmitted.
  • Stopping the transmissions ended the injunction-only claim under the Deceptive Trade Practices Act, but the same order let the Eavesdropping Act and contract claims proceed.
  • Under the Illinois Eavesdropping Act, the court allowed a theory that the site operator was a principal that knowingly benefited from third parties' allegedly illegal use of cookies, even though it was a party to the communications.
  • The case ended in an injunction-only class settlement approved on December 17, 2024, under which only the two named plaintiffs released claims for money damages.

What to check on your own site

  • List every third-party tag on the main site, the provider directory and the patient portal, including smaller advertising vendors, and what each one receives.
  • Check whether any analytics or advertising tags load inside your patient portal and what data they send.

Later history

On amended allegations that Rush sent the name, location and specialty of the patient's physician, the court held on December 11, 2023 that the Wiretap Act claim was stated (ECF No. 81). On July 18, 2024, it granted judgment on the pleadings on the breach of contract claim for lack of actual damage but denied it on the Wiretap Act and Eavesdropping Act claims, rejecting the argument that a profit motive defeats the crime-tort exception (ECF No. 140). On December 17, 2024, it granted final approval of a class settlement providing injunctive relief only and dismissed the case with prejudice (ECF Nos. 159, 160).

March 19, 2024 · Court rulingKane v. University of Rochester (W.D.N.Y. 2024)Mixed rulingA Schedule an Appointment click on a physician's profile, sent to Facebook with the user's Facebook ID, was plausibly individually identifiable health information, so a Wiretap Act claim proceeded under the crime-tort exception.September 7, 2023 · Court rulingDoe v. Meta Platforms (N.D. Cal. 2023)Mixed rulingPatients' Wiretap Act and CIPA claims against Meta over its pixel on health care providers' patient portals survived dismissal, with the scope of covered content, Meta's intent and the providers' consent left to evidence.February 21, 2025 · Court rulingStein v. Edward-Elmhurst Health (N.D. Ill. 2025)Mixed rulingAn Illinois federal court held that a health care provider's alleged disclosure of patient information to Facebook in violation of HIPAA satisfies the crime-tort exception, even if done for profit; the question is on appeal.September 9, 2024 · Court rulingA.D. v. Aspen Dental Management (N.D. Ill. 2024)Mixed rulingAn Illinois federal court let a Wiretap Act claim over a dental website's tracking proceed, holding a marketing purpose could not be detached from the alleged disclosure of health information, but dismissed several state claims.June 20, 2024 · Court rulingAmerican Hospital Association v. Becerra (N.D. Tex. 2024)For plaintiffsA Texas federal court vacated only the part of HHS's tracking guidance treating an IP address plus a visit to a public page about specific health conditions or providers as individually identifiable health information.August 28, 2024 · Court rulingT.D. v. Piedmont Healthcare (N.D. Ga. 2024)For defendantsA Georgia federal court dismissed patients' Meta Pixel claims against a health system, applying the Wiretap Act's party exception and holding there is no intrusion when patients give information to their own provider.

Published by Privacy Resolve from public records. It does not cover our own matters.

General information only, not legal advice, and not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Laws, deadlines, defenses and outcomes vary by jurisdiction and facts.