Public pages use no advertising trackers. The secure portal uses an essential session cookie and the service providers described in our privacy policy.

Skip to main content

· Court ruling

Doe v. Baystate Health System, Inc.

U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts, No. 1:25-cv-10337-JEK, ECF No. 42

For plaintiffsMotion to dismiss denied in full on the federal Wiretap Act, Massachusetts privacy statute, implied contract and fiduciary duty claims

Primary source: Memorandum and order. Checked on November 10, 2026.

A Massachusetts federal court refused to dismiss a patient's Wiretap Act claim over a hospital's Meta Pixel and Google Analytics, holding she plausibly alleged an interception for the purpose of violating the state privacy statute.

What happened

A patient of Baystate Health System for more than ten years brought a proposed class action alleging that the hospital installed the Meta Pixel and Google Analytics on its public website in January 2021 and, without patients' consent, shared the content of their communications on the site with Meta and Google. The court accepted the amended complaint's allegations as true for purposes of the motion.

The complaint alleged that the tools disclosed patients' searches for information about conditions and procedures, the identities of their physicians, their requests to schedule appointments and their support group registrations. The plaintiff alleged that her own searches about breast cancer screening and providers, her mammogram scheduling, her use of the patient portal, her status as a patient, her Facebook ID and other unique identifiers were sent, and that Meta's Off Facebook Activity Report tool showed about eighty of her communications on the site were disclosed to Meta between November 19, 2021 and April 10, 2023.

According to the complaint, until May 15, 2023, the hospital's privacy policy said identifiable information would only be used to support the patient relationship and would be disclosed only if required by law or with specific written consent. The plaintiff sued in state court in August 2023, added the federal claim in January 2025 after the Supreme Judicial Court's decision in Vita v. New England Baptist Hospital, and the hospital removed the case. The claims were the federal Wiretap Act, invasion of privacy under M.G.L. c. 214, § 1B, breach of implied contract and breach of fiduciary duty.

What the court held

  1. On the Massachusetts privacy statute, the court held that the patient's communications about cancer screening and providers, her patient status and her mammogram scheduling are medical information of a highly intimate or personal nature, and that whether marketing and business analytics are legitimate interests outweighing her privacy is a question of fact, so the claim was adequately alleged. (ECF No. 42 at 5-7)

    Based on this precedent, Doe's communications about cancer screenings and medical providers, her status as a patient, and her scheduling of a mammogram constitute medical information of a highly intimate or personal nature under Section 1B.

    ECF No. 42 at 6
  2. The hospital's status as a party to the communications was undisputed, so the federal claim depended on the crime-tort exception in 18 U.S.C. § 2511(2)(d). (ECF No. 42 at 7)

    All agree that Baystate was a party to the communications at issue in this case.

    ECF No. 42 at 7
  3. The court held that the complaint plausibly alleged the hospital intercepted the patient's communications for the purpose of violating the Massachusetts privacy statute by disclosing her health information without consent, relying on the privacy policy's promises and the plaintiff's theory that the hospital chose not to tell patients the truth so that they would submit information it then disclosed for commercial gain. (ECF No. 42 at 8-9)

    Doe plausibly alleges that Baystate intentionally intercepted her communications on its website for the purpose of committing a tortious act in violation of M.G.L. c. 214, § 1B.

    ECF No. 42 at 8
  4. Allegations that the hospital installed the tools for marketing, analytics and financial gain did not change that conclusion; under United States v. Cassiere the question is whether a criminal or tortious purpose was the primary motivation or a determinative factor, and which purpose drove the hospital is a question of fact not fit for resolution on the pleadings. (ECF No. 42 at 9)

    the existence of a lawful purpose does not mean that the interception is not also for a tortious or unlawful purpose.

    ECF No. 42 at 9 (quoting Sussman v. American Broadcasting Cos., 186 F.3d 1200, 1202 (9th Cir. 1999))
  5. Applying the parties' agreed test that the purpose must be a crime or tort independent of the interception, which the court noted the First Circuit has not adopted, the court held that the alleged privacy violation occurred through the hospital's disclosure of the communications to Meta and Google rather than through the interception itself, unlike intrusion upon seclusion. (ECF No. 42 at 8, 10-11 & n.2)

    Since Doe's factual allegations support the plausible inference that Baystate intercepted her communications for the purpose of committing a tortious act separate from the interception itself, the crime-tort exception under 18 U.S.C. § 2511(2)(d) applies.

    ECF No. 42 at 11
  6. The court rejected the hospital's argument, drawn from American Hospital Association v. Becerra, that merely browsing its public website cannot identify an individual or her health information, because the complaint described the specific information allegedly disclosed. (ECF No. 42 at 11-12)

    This position ignores Doe's factual allegations, which describe her specific information that Baystate allegedly disclosed.

    ECF No. 42 at 12
  7. The alleged searches, scheduling, patient status, Facebook ID and other identifiers were plausibly the contents of communications, given the statute's definition of contents and the First Circuit's reading of it in In re Pharmatrak, Inc. to include personally identifiable information such as a medical condition. (ECF No. 42 at 11-12)

    These factual allegations are sufficient to treat Doe's intercepted private health information and personal identifiers as “contents” for purposes of the ECPA.

    ECF No. 42 at 12
  8. The implied contract claim survived because the patient alleged she gave the hospital her information as part of her care on its promise not to share it without consent, and that the hospital derived a benefit from it; the court rejected arguments based on lack of assent, a preexisting HIPAA duty as no consideration, and lack of harm. (ECF No. 42 at 13-14)

  9. The fiduciary duty claim survived because Massachusetts courts recognize a hospital's duty of confidentiality to its patients, and the court rejected the argument that use of the public website fell outside that duty. (ECF No. 42 at 14-17)

    As part of “the medical profession,” however, hospitals have a “professional duty” not to disclose patients' private health information without their consent.

    ECF No. 42 at 15

What it did not decide

  • Whether the hospital also intended to violate HIPAA or the FTC Act; the court said it need not consider those theories because the state-law predicate was sufficient.
  • Whether the First Circuit requires the criminal or tortious purpose to be independent of the interception; the court applied that test because the parties agreed to it and noted the First Circuit has not adopted it.
  • Which purpose actually drove the hospital, and whether marketing and analytics are legitimate interests that outweigh patient privacy under the state statute; the court left both as questions of fact.
  • Class certification, liability and damages.

The tracking involved

Tools

  • Meta Pixel
  • Google Analytics

Data

  • Searches about medical conditions and procedures
  • Identities of physicians
  • Appointment scheduling requests
  • Support group registrations
  • Patient portal log-in requests
  • Facebook ID and other unique identifiers

How it bears on website tracking claims

Supports: strengthens a website tracking claim on this issue. Limits: narrows or defeats a website tracking claim on this issue. Context: bears on the issue without deciding it either way.

  • Supports: Crime-tort exception

    Whether a communication was intercepted for the purpose of a criminal or tortious act, which removes the party exception.

    The court held that a patient plausibly alleged the hospital intercepted her website communications for the purpose of violating the Massachusetts privacy statute, inferring that purpose from privacy promises the hospital allegedly did not keep and from its alleged disclosures for commercial gain. It held that a marketing, analytics or financial-gain motive does not rule out a tortious purpose and that which purpose was primary or determinative is a question of fact. Its limits: it is a pleading-stage ruling, and the court applied the independence test because the parties agreed to it, noting that the First Circuit has not adopted that test. Other judges in the same district have dismissed similar claims, including in the Lawrence General Hospital case, where the court discussed this ruling in September 2026.

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Context: Party exception

    Whether the website, as a party to the visit, could consent to the tracking under 18 U.S.C. § 2511(2)(d).

    The hospital's party status was undisputed, and the court said so. In this case, conceding party status did not end the claim, because the court found the crime-tort exception plausibly pleaded.

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Supports: Contents

    Whether what was sent, such as page addresses, searches and clicks, counts as the contents of a communication.

    Relying on In re Pharmatrak, Inc., which read the statutory definition to include personally identifiable information such as a medical condition, the court held that searches about breast cancer screening and providers, mammogram scheduling, patient status and a Facebook ID were plausibly contents. In doing so, it pointed to the complaint's specific allegations about the plaintiff's own information, rather than to browsing in general.

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Supports: Health information

    What counts as individually identifiable health information when it is sent through tracking tools.

    The court rejected the hospital's argument, drawn from American Hospital Association v. Becerra, that browsing a public website cannot identify a person or her health information, because the complaint described specific information disclosed, including a Facebook ID and patient status. Under the state statute it held that communications about cancer screening and providers, patient status and mammogram scheduling are medical information of a highly intimate or personal nature. It did not reach HIPAA, so it decided nothing about HIPAA's definition of individually identifiable health information.

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Supports: State privacy laws

    Other state privacy statutes and claims, such as medical information and health records acts and the CCPA.

    M.G.L. c. 214, § 1B supplied both a standalone claim and the tort for the crime-tort exception. The court held that whether marketing and business analytics are legitimate interests that outweigh a patient's privacy is a question of fact, which kept a business-justification argument from ending the claim on the pleadings.

    All tracker entries on this issue

Arguments it addresses

The website was a party to the communication
The court accepted that the hospital was a party but held that the crime-tort exception plausibly applied, which removes that protection.
The tools were installed for marketing and analytics
The court held that a lawful purpose does not mean the interception was not also for a tortious purpose, and that which motive was primary or determinative is a question of fact.
The alleged tort happens through the interception itself
The court held that the alleged state privacy violation occurred through the disclosure to Meta and Google, distinguishing intrusion upon seclusion, which some courts treat as occurring through the interception.
A visit to a public page is not health information under AHA v. Becerra
The court said that argument ignored the specific information alleged, including the patient's Facebook ID, patient status, searches and mammogram scheduling.
Marketing and analytics are legitimate business interests
Under the Massachusetts statute, the court held that weighing those interests against patient privacy is a question of fact.
The patient was not harmed
On the implied contract claim, the court said the allegation that the hospital took valuable information and derived a benefit from it without sharing that benefit contradicted the no-harm argument at this stage.

For a company that received a letter

  • The ruling accepts the complaint's allegations as true and makes no finding that the hospital acted unlawfully or is liable.
  • The court relied on the hospital's privacy-policy promises, set against the alleged disclosures, to infer a plausible improper purpose.
  • The predicate the court relied on was the Massachusetts privacy statute, and it expressly did not reach HIPAA or the FTC Act.
  • Other judges in the District of Massachusetts have dismissed similar claims, so the decision reflects one side of a division within that court.

What to check on your own site

  • Compare what your privacy policy and notice of privacy practices say about sharing identifiable information with the vendors that actually receive data from your pages.
  • Check whether condition and procedure searches, physician lookups, appointment requests and support group registrations send requests to advertising or analytics vendors.
  • Check whether those requests carry a vendor identifier, such as an advertising cookie value, alongside the page address or search terms.

Later history

At the parties' joint request, the court stayed the case on April 16, 2026 pending a mediation scheduled for June 29, 2026 (ECF Nos. 45, 46). Status reports have since been filed, the latest on October 19, 2026 (ECF No. 53). The docket on CourtListener, read November 10, 2026, shows the case still open with no judgment entered.

July 1, 2026 · Court rulingDoe v. Children's Hospital Corporation (D. Mass. 2026)For plaintiffsAdopting Baystate's reasoning, a federal court in Massachusetts denied a children's hospital's motion to dismiss Wiretap Act and state-law claims over Google and Facebook tracking on its website and patient portal.August 14, 2026 · Court rulingVita v. Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center (D. Mass. 2026)For plaintiffsA Massachusetts federal court let a hospital website user who was not a patient pursue her Wiretap Act claim, with the state privacy statute as the separate wrong, dismissing only her breach of confidence claim.March 6, 2026 · Court rulingProgin v. UMass Memorial Health Care (D. Mass. 2026)For defendantsDismissing a Wiretap Act claim against a hospital system, a federal court held allegations of tracker installation and disclosures to Facebook and Google did not show a purpose to commit the specified crimes and torts.September 21, 2026 · Court rulingDoe v. Lawrence General Hospital (D. Mass. 2026)For defendantsA federal court dismissed a Wiretap Act claim over a hospital's website tracking, holding the allegations supported at most an inference of awareness that it might disclose private information, not a primary or determinative motive.September 30, 2026 · Court rulingNova v. Boston Medical Center (D. Mass. 2026)For defendantsA federal court dismissed a hospital website Wiretap Act claim, holding the allegations supported only an inference of commercial purpose and not that the data was kept in a HIPAA record set.June 20, 2024 · Court rulingAmerican Hospital Association v. Becerra (N.D. Tex. 2024)For plaintiffsA Texas federal court vacated only the part of HHS's tracking guidance treating an IP address plus a visit to a public page about specific health conditions or providers as individually identifiable health information.

Published by Privacy Resolve from public records. It does not cover our own matters.

General information only, not legal advice, and not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Laws, deadlines, defenses and outcomes vary by jurisdiction and facts.