· Agency action
The People of the State of California v. Healthline Media, LLC
California Attorney General; Superior Court of California, County of San Francisco, No. CGC-25-626794
Primary source: Attorney General announcement, with the complaint and judgment. Checked on November 10, 2026.
California's Attorney General settled consumer privacy allegations against Healthline Media for $1.55 million and an injunction barring it from sharing personal information with article titles indicating a reader was already diagnosed.
What happened
Healthline Media, LLC operates Healthline.com, a health and wellness information website that earns revenue from ads, some of them personally targeted. According to the complaint, about 6.5 million Californians visit the site each month, and Healthline generally does not solicit health information from visitors and is not a health care provider that would otherwise have to comply with health privacy laws (Compl. paras. 1, 8-9).
The complaint alleged that trackers on the site, such as cookies and pixels, sent advertising companies information that could identify a reader, like a unique identifier stored as a cookie, together with the title of the article being read. Some titles suggested the reader had already been diagnosed with a serious illness, such as "Newly Diagnosed with HIV? Important Things to Know" (Compl. paras. 1, 21).
After testing the site in the fall of 2023, the Attorney General alleged that it kept sending personal information, including article titles, to more than a dozen advertising companies and kept setting advertising cookies after a reader opted out through the site's do-not-sell-or-share link, the Global Privacy Control and the cookie banner (Compl. paras. 2, 11-15). The complaint also alleged that some advertising contracts lacked terms the CCPA requires and that the cookie banner did not disable tracking cookies despite purporting to do so (paras. 3, 24-25, 33).
According to the complaint, Healthline began remedial measures after the Attorney General contacted it, including disabling trackers directly in response to opt-out requests (para. 28).
What the agency did
The People, through the Attorney General, filed a complaint alleging that Healthline sold and shared personal information despite opt-out requests, lacked CCPA-required contract terms with recipients, and used personal information in ways not reasonably necessary and proportionate to the purposes for which it was collected, in violation of the California Consumer Privacy Act and the Unfair Competition Law. (Compl. paras. 30, 32)
First, Healthline had misconfigured one opt-out mechanism and failed to test whether it worked.
Compl. para. 3 The complaint applied the CCPA's purpose limitation principle to article titles, alleging that a brief mention of targeted advertising in the privacy policy did not make sharing titles that suggest a diagnosis consistent with readers' reasonable expectations. (Compl. paras. 22-23)
And even if Healthline’s privacy policy discussed targeted advertising briefly, it never mentioned sharing article titles.
Compl. para. 23 The complaint alleged that the cookie banner was a deceptive practice under the Unfair Competition Law because it purported to let readers disable advertising cookies but did not. (Compl. paras. 13, 33)
Healthline also deceived website visitors by offering a cookie banner that purported to allow them to disable advertising cookies, but failed to do so.
Compl. para. 33 On July 28, 2025, the court signed and filed a stipulated final judgment and permanent injunction, entered without trial or adjudication of any fact or law and without Healthline admitting liability. (Final Judgment at 1-2, 8)
without the taking of proof and without trial or adjudication of any fact or law
Final Judgment at 1 The judgment requires Healthline to pay the Attorney General $1,550,000, to be deposited in the Consumer Privacy Fund; the Attorney General's announcement describes the payment as civil penalties. (Final Judgment paras. 24-25)
The settlement includes $1.55 million in civil penalties and strong injunctive terms
Attorney General announcement (July 1, 2025) The judgment bars Healthline from selling or sharing personal information combined with information that lets the recipient determine that a consumer is viewing a specific article whose title or URL indicates the reader has already been diagnosed with a medical condition, subject to CCPA exemptions. (Final Judgment paras. 6, 18)
HEALTHLINE shall not SELL or SHARE PERSONAL INFORMATION combined with information that allows the recipient to determine that the CONSUMER is viewing a specific DIAGNOSED MEDICAL CONDITION ARTICLE
Final Judgment para. 18 That ban does not reach general-interest health articles whose titles do not suggest the reader already has a diagnosis. (Final Judgment para. 6)
it does not include general interest health or medical articles whose titles do not suggest the reader already has a medical diagnosis
Final Judgment para. 6 The judgment requires Healthline to process opt-outs sent through opt-out preference signals, including the Global Privacy Control, to give notice that it sells and shares personal information, and, for three years, to monitor its opt-out processing, review the third parties that receive data through its tracking technologies and audit their contracts, reporting annually to the People. (Final Judgment paras. 16-17, 21-22)
HEALTHLINE shall process CONSUMER requests to opt out of SALES or SHARING, signaled via an OPT-OUT PREFERENCE SIGNAL
Final Judgment para. 17 On entry of the judgment and full payment, the People release Healthline from civil privacy and consumer protection claims relating to consumers' interactions with its websites and apps, and the court retains jurisdiction to enforce the judgment. (Final Judgment paras. 27-28)
What it did not decide
- Whether Healthline violated the CCPA or the Unfair Competition Law; the judgment was entered without trial or adjudication of any fact or law and without an admission of liability (Final Judgment at 1-2).
- Any claim by an individual consumer; the case was brought by the People through the Attorney General, and the release in the judgment is given by the People (Compl. para. 5; Final Judgment para. 27).
- Whether sharing titles of general-interest health articles raises the same issue; the judgment's specific ban excludes them (Final Judgment para. 6).
- Whether an investigator's later streaming TV ads for Crohn's disease drugs resulted from his work on Healthline.com; the complaint said that could not be determined (Compl. paras. 19-20).
The tracking involved
Tools
- Third-party advertising cookies, pixels and tags
- A cookie sync pixel
- A universal identifier stored in the browser's local storage
- A cookie banner and a tool meant to detect the Global Privacy Control
Data
- Unique identifier cookies
- Titles of the articles being read, including titles suggesting a diagnosis
- Personal information sent after a reader opted out
How it bears on website tracking claims
Supports: strengthens a website tracking claim on this issue. Limits: narrows or defeats a website tracking claim on this issue. Context: bears on the issue without deciding it either way.
Context: Consent
Whether visitors agreed to the tracking through banners, privacy policies or terms.
Part of the Attorney General's case concerned whether refusals worked: it alleged that after a reader used the do-not-sell-or-share link, the Global Privacy Control and the cookie banner, advertising cookies and data transmissions continued, and that a banner purporting to disable advertising cookies was deceptive. These are allegations resolved by a stipulated judgment without findings. For a claim that a refusal did not stop tracking, the action shows how a regulator tested and described similar facts.
Context: Health information
What counts as individually identifiable health information when it is sent through tracking tools.
The complaint treated article titles suggesting an existing diagnosis as potentially revealing health-related information, even though Healthline is not a health care provider subject to health privacy laws, and the judgment bars sharing personal information with such titles. The ban is narrow: it covers titles or URLs indicating the reader has already been diagnosed and excludes general-interest health articles. It is a negotiated term, not a court's ruling on what counts as health information.
Context: State privacy laws
Other state privacy statutes and claims, such as medical information and health records acts and the CCPA.
The action invoked the CCPA's opt-out, contract and purpose limitation requirements against a publisher's advertising trackers; the complaint did not plead any wiretap statute. The case was brought by the People under the CCPA and the Unfair Competition Law, and the judgment does not address claims by individual consumers. It shows how the Attorney General applied California's consumer privacy law to advertising data flows through opt-out rights, contract terms and purpose limits rather than through interception.
Context: Consumer protection
Deception and unfair practice claims, such as under the FTC Act and N.Y. General Business Law § 349.
Alongside the CCPA, the complaint alleged Unfair Competition Law violations, including deception through a cookie banner that did not disable advertising cookies as it purported to, and it sought a civil penalty of $2,500 for each violation of that law. The stipulated judgment did not adjudicate the deception claim.
Context: Agency penalties and orders
Civil penalties, payments and conduct terms that regulators obtained.
The Attorney General described the $1.55 million as the largest CCPA settlement to date, and the complaint had sought penalties of $2,663 for each violation and $7,988 for each intentional violation of the CCPA. The judgment pairs the payment with three years of reporting on opt-out processing and third-party contracts. The amount reflects a negotiated resolution, not a court's calculation of penalties per violation.
Arguments it addresses
- Visitors can opt out through the site's banner and links
- The complaint alleged that tracking continued after readers opted out through the site's link, the Global Privacy Control and the cookie banner, and the judgment requires Healthline to honor opt-out preference signals (Compl. paras. 11-15; Final Judgment para. 17).
- The company is not a health care provider, so health privacy rules do not apply
- The complaint acknowledged that Healthline is not such a provider but still alleged that sharing article titles suggesting a diagnosis violated the CCPA's purpose limitation principle, and the judgment bars that sharing (Compl. paras. 8, 22-23; Final Judgment para. 18).
- The privacy policy discloses targeted advertising
- The complaint alleged that a brief mention of targeted advertising did not cover sharing article titles, which readers would not expect (Compl. paras. 9, 22-23).
- Ad tech partners are responsible for their own tags
- The complaint alleged that Healthline assumed but did not verify that recipients had signed an industry contractual framework, and the judgment requires annual contract reviews and verification (Compl. paras. 3, 24-27; Final Judgment para. 22).
- A settlement is not a finding of wrongdoing
- That is correct here: the judgment was entered without trial or adjudication of any fact or law and without Healthline admitting liability (Final Judgment at 1-2).
- There is no proof that sharing led to targeted ads
- The complaint itself said it was impossible to determine whether the investigator's later ads resulted from his work on Healthline.com, coincidence or activity on another website (Compl. para. 20).
For a company that received a letter
- This was a public enforcement action resolved by a stipulated judgment entered without trial or findings and without any admission of liability.
- Much of the Attorney General's case rested on testing whether opt-out tools, including the Global Privacy Control and the cookie banner, actually stopped advertising cookies and data flows.
- The judgment's ban on sharing article titles is limited to articles indicating the reader has already been diagnosed and expressly excludes general-interest health articles.
- The complaint treated contracts with advertising recipients as part of compliance, faulting reliance on an industry framework without checking which recipients had signed it.
What to check on your own site
- Turn on the Global Privacy Control in a test browser and confirm that advertising cookies and pixel requests stop on your pages.
- Use your own cookie banner's opt-out and do-not-sell-or-share link, then check in the browser's network panel whether requests to advertising vendors continue.
- Check whether page titles or URLs sent to advertising vendors reveal that a reader has a specific diagnosis.
Later history
Judge Garrett L. Wong of the San Francisco Superior Court signed the stipulated final judgment and permanent injunction, and it was filed on July 28, 2025 (Final Judgment at 1, 8).
Related rulings
Published by Privacy Resolve from public records. It does not cover our own matters.
General information only, not legal advice, and not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Laws, deadlines, defenses and outcomes vary by jurisdiction and facts.