Public pages use no advertising trackers. The secure portal uses an essential session cookie and the service providers described in our privacy policy.

Skip to main content

· Court ruling

Santoro v. Tower Health

U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, No. 24-3173

Mixed rulingPrecedential appeal decision: standing found; dismissal with prejudice and denial of reconsideration affirmed

Primary source: Precedential opinion. Checked on November 10, 2026.

Patients alleging their provider secretly shared their health information with Meta have standing, the Third Circuit held, but it affirmed dismissal with prejudice on amendment grounds without reaching the merits.

What happened

According to the second amended complaint, whose facts the court accepted as true, Tower Health is a regional health care provider with seven hospitals, 27 urgent care facilities and home health services, and it encourages its patients and the public to get health information through its website. The complaint alleged that, although Tower Health pledged in notices and confidentiality agreements to keep patients' health information private, it installed the Meta Pixel on its website (slip op. at 2 & n.1).

As alleged, the Meta Pixel captured users' characteristics, such as IP addresses, device identifiers and account numbers, and the content of their communications, such as the URLs, buttons, links, pages and tabs they viewed, and sent that information at the same time to Meta, which used it for commercial purposes including selling targeted advertisements (slip op. at 2).

Patrick Santoro and Jessica Landis, both Tower Health patients, alleged that they used the website for communications that included requests for information about specific Tower Health providers and locations and information about specific health conditions, treatments and medications, and that they never authorized Tower Health to share that information with Meta (slip op. at 2-3).

Their second amended complaint asserted three claims: a federal Wiretap Act claim based on a disclosure alleged to violate HIPAA, negligence, and intrusion upon seclusion; their claims against Meta had been transferred to another district. The district court dismissed for lack of specific examples of the health information the pixel sent, with prejudice because it found amendment futile, then denied reconsideration and leave to file a third amended complaint, which would have added the URLs they visited and Facebook advertisements related to their conditions and treatments, for undue delay (slip op. at 3-6).

What the court held

  1. The court held that the plaintiffs' allegations support Article III standing for each of their claims, which all rest on the same alleged injury. (slip op. at 6 & n.3)

    We are satisfied that Plaintiffs’ allegations support Article III standing for each of their claims.

    slip op. at 6
  2. Patients who alleged that they shared information about their health conditions, treatments and medications with their provider, and that the provider shared their individually identifiable health information with Meta through the Meta Pixel without authorization, alleged a harm analogous to the common-law tort of intrusion upon seclusion. (slip op. at 7-8)

    Because patients expect the medical information they share with their healthcare providers to remain private, a provider’s surreptitious disclosure of a patient’s confidential medical information is analogous to the kind of harm caused by an intrusion upon seclusion.

    slip op. at 8
  3. The court rejected Tower Health's argument that the plaintiffs had to identify the specific information shared in order to establish a concrete injury. (slip op. at 8)

    Tower Health argues that Plaintiffs needed to identify the specific information they revealed to Tower Health (and Tower Health revealed to Meta) to establish a concrete injury. We disagree.

    slip op. at 8
  4. The patients' voluntary disclosure of their information to Tower Health did not defeat standing, because the alleged injury came from Tower Health's decision to share it with Meta without their authorization. (slip op. at 8-9)

    But Plaintiffs’ voluntary disclosure to Tower Health is beside the point.

    slip op. at 9
  5. The court rejected an analogy to the tort of public disclosure of private facts, because the plaintiffs alleged no public disclosure. (slip op. at 8 n.4)

    By contrast, Plaintiffs’ analogy to common-law public disclosure of private facts fails.

    slip op. at 8 n.4
  6. The court limited its standing holding to the allegations before it and said it did not address whether those allegations state a claim. (slip op. at 8 n.5)

    Our conclusion that Plaintiffs have standing is limited to the allegations in this case: that patients shared information about their own health conditions with their healthcare provider, which surreptitiously shared that individually-identifiable information with a third party.

    slip op. at 8 n.5
  7. The district court did not abuse its discretion in dismissing the second amended complaint with prejudice, because the plaintiffs never properly asked for leave to amend by submitting a draft amended complaint, and their conditional remarks at oral argument were not enough. (slip op. at 9)

  8. The court affirmed the denial of the motion to reopen the judgment and file a third amended complaint for undue delay. A defendant's arguments and other district courts' dismissals of similar claims did not put the plaintiffs on notice, but the district judge's clear statements at oral argument did, and the plaintiffs waited eight weeks to seek leave. (slip op. at 10-14)

    During oral argument, the District Court made its views of the SAC abundantly clear.

    slip op. at 12
  9. Because the plaintiffs did not argue on appeal that their complaint stated a claim, the court took no position on that question. (slip op. at 14)

    Thus, we take no position on whether the SAC stated a claim upon which relief could be granted.

    slip op. at 14

What it did not decide

  • Whether the second amended complaint stated a claim under the federal Wiretap Act or state tort law; the plaintiffs did not raise that question on appeal (slip op. at 8 n.5, 9, 14).
  • Whether the district court was right to require specific examples of the HIPAA-protected information the Meta Pixel sent; the plaintiffs challenged only the decision to dismiss with prejudice (slip op. at 5, 9).
  • Standing on allegations other than those before it; the court limited its holding to patients who alleged they shared information about their own health conditions with their provider (slip op. at 8 n.5).
  • The claims against Meta, which had been transferred to a different district (slip op. at 3).

The tracking involved

Tools

  • Meta Pixel

Data

  • IP addresses, device identifiers and account numbers
  • URLs, buttons, links, pages and tabs viewed
  • Requests for information about specific providers and locations
  • Information about specific health conditions, treatments and medications

How it bears on website tracking claims

Supports: strengthens a website tracking claim on this issue. Limits: narrows or defeats a website tracking claim on this issue. Context: bears on the issue without deciding it either way.

  • Supports: Standing and injury

    Whether the people suing were harmed in a way that lets a federal court hear the claim.

    In a precedential opinion, the Third Circuit held that patients who allege their health care provider secretly shared their individually identifiable health information with a third party through a tracking pixel allege a concrete injury, by analogy to intrusion upon seclusion. They did not need to identify the specific information shared to establish that injury, and their voluntary disclosure to the provider did not defeat it. The holding is limited to patients who shared information about their own health conditions with their provider, and the court rejected the analogy to public disclosure of private facts because no public disclosure was alleged.

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Context: Health information

    What counts as individually identifiable health information when it is sent through tracking tools.

    The court described the health conditions, treatments and medications a patient communicates to a provider as information people expect to keep private, comparing it to the complete card numbers it had treated as highly sensitive in an earlier case. That reasoning was used only for standing. Whether the data the pixel sent included individually identifiable health information was a merits question the court did not reach.

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Context: HIPAA

    How HIPAA, its criminal provision at 42 U.S.C. § 1320d-6 and HHS guidance bear on tracking.

    The plaintiffs' Wiretap Act theory was that Tower Health disclosed their individually identifiable health information in violation of HIPAA. As the opinion describes it, the district court recognized that 42 U.S.C. § 1320d-6(a)(3) makes knowing disclosure of such information a crime, but dismissed because the complaint gave no specific examples of what the pixel sent. The Third Circuit did not review that ruling, so the opinion neither adopts nor rejects the district court's specificity requirement.

    All tracker entries on this issue

Arguments it addresses

No concrete injury
For patients who alleged their provider secretly shared their individually identifiable health information with Meta, the court held the injury concrete because it is analogous to intrusion upon seclusion (slip op. at 7-8).
The plaintiff must identify exactly what information was shared
The court rejected that requirement for standing, while the district court's dismissal for lack of such detail on the merits stayed in place because it was not challenged on appeal (slip op. at 8-9).
The patient voluntarily gave the information to the provider
The court called this beside the point for standing, because the injury came from the provider's unauthorized decision to share the information (slip op. at 9).
An appeals court affirmed the dismissal of a pixel case
The affirmance rested on how and when the plaintiffs sought to amend, and the court took no position on whether the complaint stated a claim (slip op. at 9-14).
Other courts dismissed similar claims, so the plaintiffs were on notice
The court held that other district courts' rulings and a defendant's arguments do not by themselves put a plaintiff on notice, though the district judge's clear statements at oral argument did here (slip op. at 11-12).

For a company that received a letter

  • A standing ruling decides whether a federal court can hear a case, and this opinion says expressly that it does not decide whether the allegations state a claim.
  • The affirmance concerns amending a complaint after a judge has signaled its view, not whether pixel tracking on a provider's website is lawful.
  • The standing holding covers patients who alleged they shared their own health information with their provider, not every website visitor.
  • The district court's dismissal turned on the lack of specific examples of the health information the pixel sent, a ruling the Third Circuit did not review.

What to check on your own site

  • Check whether the Meta Pixel or other advertising tags load on pages where patients look up specific providers, locations, conditions, treatments or medications.
  • Check what those tags send from such pages, including page addresses, button and link labels, and identifiers such as IP addresses and device identifiers.

Later history

The Third Circuit's mandate was entered on the district court's docket on September 30, 2026 (E.D. Pa. ECF No. 87). A Supreme Court docket search on November 10, 2026 found no petition for certiorari involving Tower Health. The time to file one had not run on that date.

October 23, 2026 · Court rulingRand v. Eyemart Express (5th Cir. 2026)For plaintiffsThe Fifth Circuit held that the alleged unauthorized disclosure of website users' health information to Meta through its Pixel is a concrete injury, and that such information need not reveal a diagnosis.August 19, 2026 · Court rulingMagliocca v. United Healthcare Services (E.D. Cal. 2026)For defendantsData from one visit to a health insurer's general plan pages, with only a ZIP code entered, showed no concrete injury, a federal court held, dismissing the tracking suit with prejudice for lack of standing.July 24, 2023 · Court rulingKurowski v. Rush System for Health (N.D. Ill. 2023)Mixed rulingPatients' Wiretap Act claim was dismissed because the complaint plausibly alleged only metadata, not health information, but their Illinois Eavesdropping Act claim proceeded against the health system as a principal benefiting from third-party cookies.August 28, 2024 · Court rulingT.D. v. Piedmont Healthcare (N.D. Ga. 2024)For defendantsA Georgia federal court dismissed patients' Meta Pixel claims against a health system, applying the Wiretap Act's party exception and holding there is no intrusion when patients give information to their own provider.September 4, 2026 · Court rulingHanson v. Sanford Health (D. Minn. 2026)Mixed rulingA Minnesota federal court let a patient's Wiretap Act claim proceed on an alleged HIPAA disclosure, rejecting profit-motive and independence defenses, but dismissed his intrusion and state health records claims with prejudice.July 30, 2024 · Court rulingCooper v. Mount Sinai Health System (S.D.N.Y. 2024)For plaintiffsA federal court let a Wiretap Act claim over a health system's Meta Pixel proceed, holding that alleged disclosure of identifiable patient health information for commercial ends plausibly invoked the crime-tort exception through HIPAA.

Published by Privacy Resolve from public records. It does not cover our own matters.

General information only, not legal advice, and not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Laws, deadlines, defenses and outcomes vary by jurisdiction and facts.