Public pages use no advertising trackers. The secure portal uses an essential session cookie and the service providers described in our privacy policy.

Skip to main content

· Court ruling

T.D. v. Piedmont Healthcare, Inc.

U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Georgia, No. 1:23-cv-05416-TWT, ECF No. 46

For defendantsMotion to dismiss granted; reconsideration and leave to amend denied on December 10, 2024

Primary source: Opinion and order. Checked on November 10, 2026.

A Georgia federal court dismissed patients' Meta Pixel claims against a health system, applying the Wiretap Act's party exception and holding there is no intrusion when patients give information to their own provider.

What happened

Patients of Piedmont Healthcare, Inc. sued in the Northern District of Georgia on behalf of a proposed class, alleging that the Meta Pixel installed on Piedmont's website and MyChart patient portal collected their personally identifiable information and protected health information without consent and disclosed it to Facebook. (ECF No. 46 at 1-2.)

The amended complaint alleged that Piedmont installed the Meta Pixel to optimize its advertising and marketing at the expense of patients' privacy, and that Piedmont acted with a purpose to violate HIPAA. It pleaded invasion of privacy, breach of fiduciary duty, negligence, breach of implied contract, breach of contract, unjust enrichment and federal Wiretap Act claims. (ECF No. 46 at 2; ECF No. 51 at 7.)

The patients argued that the disclosures included specific doctors' appointments and personal identifiers from the patient portal, and they listed unwanted targeted advertising among their harms. The court accepted the amended complaint's facts as true for the motion. (ECF No. 46 at 1 n.1, 4-5, 9.)

What the court held

  1. The court dismissed the intrusion upon seclusion claim. Siding with what it called the weight of authority in pixel tracking cases, it held that a patient who voluntarily provides information to his or her own provider has not been intruded upon, while noting a contrary decision, In re Group Health Plan Litigation (D. Minn. 2023). (ECF No. 46 at 3-7)

    There is no intrusion upon privacy when a patient voluntarily provides personally identifiable information and protected health information to his or her healthcare provider.

    ECF No. 46 at 5
  2. The court dismissed the breach of fiduciary duty claim without prejudice. It noted that providing medical care could suggest a confidential relationship, but held that the patients pleaded no facts showing they actually suffered the damages they listed, such as lost privacy, embarrassment, lost time, lost benefit of the bargain and diminished value of their information. (ECF No. 46 at 7-10)

    No facts are alleged that any of the Plaintiffs have actually suffered any of these damages.

    ECF No. 46 at 9
  3. The court also dismissed the negligence, implied and express contract and unjust enrichment claims without prejudice, for failure to plead actionable damages or unjust enrichment of Piedmont. (ECF No. 46 at 10)

    Accordingly, their negligence, breach of implied/express contract, and unjust enrichment claims should be dismissed without prejudice.

    ECF No. 46 at 10
  4. The court dismissed the Wiretap Act claim. Piedmont argued that it could not intercept a transmission it received and that a purpose of driving marketing and revenue is not criminal or tortious; the court held that the weight of persuasive authority in pixel cases supported Piedmont and cited decisions applying the party exception, five of which, as it later explained, involved health care providers using the Meta Pixel or similar tools on their own websites and portals. (ECF No. 46 at 10-12)

    As was the case in the invasion of privacy context, the weight of persuasive authority in similar pixel tracking cases supports Piedmont’s position.

    ECF No. 46 at 11
  5. Denying reconsideration on December 10, 2024, the court explained that its August order had relied on Okash v. Essentia Health and Nienaber v. Overlake Hospital Medical Center for the crime-tort exception: the exception needs a criminal or tortious act independent of the interception, a disclosure to Meta made at the same time as the interception is not one, and, as Okash put it, even if targeted advertising were an independent act, it would not meet the purpose requirement where the defendant's primary motivation was to make money. (ECF No. 51 at 6-12)

    In addition to the party exception cases, the Court cited two cases for the proposition that the crime-tort exception did not apply to Piedmont

    ECF No. 51 at 10
  6. The court also denied leave to amend after judgment. It stated that the Wiretap Act and invasion of privacy counts had been dismissed with prejudice and that the other counts, dismissed without prejudice, could be re-filed in a new action. (ECF No. 51 at 12-15)

    both of which were dismissed with prejudice

    ECF No. 51 at 14

What it did not decide

  • Whether the information sent to Facebook was individually identifiable health information under HIPAA; neither order decides it.
  • Piedmont's arguments that Georgia law imposes no duty to refrain from sending encrypted versions of patient information to third parties, and that the patients' own provision of the information and consent caused any disclosure; the court resolved the fiduciary claim on damages instead (ECF No. 46 at 7-10).
  • Statutory damages under 18 U.S.C. § 2520, Article III standing and class certification; neither order addresses them.
  • Whether the new facts in the plaintiffs' proposed second amended complaint would state a claim; on reconsideration the court said several appeared at first glance to cure pleading deficiencies the August order raised, but it denied leave to amend under the post-judgment standards of Rules 59(e) and 60(b) (ECF No. 51 at 12-14).

The tracking involved

Tools

  • Meta Pixel

Data

  • personally identifiable information
  • protected health information entered on the website and MyChart portal
  • doctors' appointments and personal identifiers from the patient portal (as the patients argued)

How it bears on website tracking claims

Supports: strengthens a website tracking claim on this issue. Limits: narrows or defeats a website tracking claim on this issue. Context: bears on the issue without deciding it either way.

  • Limits: Party exception

    Whether the website, as a party to the visit, could consent to the tracking under 18 U.S.C. § 2511(2)(d).

    The court applied the party exception to a health system that allegedly embedded the Meta Pixel on its own website and portal, relying on decisions, five involving health care providers' websites and portals, that treated the defendant as a recipient of the communications and therefore a party to them (ECF No. 46 at 11-12; ECF No. 51 at 8-9). For a website-tracking claim against the operator, the ruling means the claim needs the crime-tort exception, which the court also found lacking.

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Limits: Interception

    Whether a tracking tool acquired a communication as it was sent, who did it, and whether it was intentional.

    Piedmont argued that it could not intercept a transmission it received on its own website (ECF No. 46 at 10). On reconsideration, the court described the decisions it relied on as holding that recipients of the communications fall under the party exception and could not intercept them within the meaning of the statute (ECF No. 51 at 8). Neither order discusses whether the Meta Pixel's transmission to Facebook is itself an interception by Facebook.

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Limits: Crime-tort exception

    Whether a communication was intercepted for the purpose of a criminal or tortious act, which removes the party exception.

    As the court later explained, it followed decisions holding that the exception needs an act independent of the interception and that a disclosure to Meta made simultaneously with the interception is not independent, and it found persuasive the view that, even if targeted advertising were an independent act, it would not meet the purpose requirement where the primary motivation was to make money (ECF No. 51 at 10-12). Other district courts in New York and Illinois, including in Gay v. Garnet Health and A.D. v. Aspen Dental Management, Inc., treated the disclosure to third parties as an act separate from the interception at the pleading stage.

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Limits: HIPAA

    How HIPAA, its criminal provision at 42 U.S.C. § 1320d-6 and HHS guidance bear on tracking.

    The amended complaint alleged that Piedmont acted with a purpose to violate HIPAA (ECF No. 51 at 7). The court did not accept that theory, relying on Okash, which rejected a HIPAA-based crime-tort argument on nearly identical facts because the alleged violation was not independent of the interception (ECF No. 51 at 10). Neither order decides whether the information was individually identifiable health information.

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Limits: State privacy laws

    Other state privacy statutes and claims, such as medical information and health records acts and the CCPA.

    Under Georgia law, the court held that a provider's alleged disclosure to Facebook of information patients voluntarily gave it was not an intrusion upon seclusion (ECF No. 46 at 4-6). This narrows privacy-tort theories that rest on a provider's onward sharing rather than on how it collected the information. The court noted a contrary decision from Minnesota (ECF No. 46 at 6).

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Limits: Damages

    What must be shown to recover money, including statutory damages and proof of actual loss.

    The fiduciary duty, negligence, contract and unjust enrichment claims failed because the patients pleaded no facts showing actual damages; the court called their theories of lost privacy, emotional harm, lost benefit of the bargain and diminished data value untenable (ECF No. 46 at 8-10). These were damages elements of state-law claims. Neither order discusses statutory damages under 18 U.S.C. § 2520.

    All tracker entries on this issue

Arguments it addresses

The website was a party to the communication
The court agreed, relying on decisions, several involving health care providers using the Meta Pixel, that treated the defendant as a recipient of the communications and therefore a party (ECF No. 46 at 11-12; ECF No. 51 at 8-9).
The disclosure happens at the same moment as the interception, so it is not a separate act
The court accepted this, following decisions holding that a simultaneous disclosure to Meta does not meet the independent act requirement (ECF No. 51 at 10-12).
The purpose was marketing, not crime
The court found persuasive the reasoning that, even if targeted advertising were an independent act, it would not meet the purpose requirement where the primary motivation was to make money (ECF No. 51 at 10-11).
Patients gave the provider the information voluntarily
The court held there is no intrusion upon seclusion when a patient voluntarily provides information to his or her own provider (ECF No. 46 at 5).
No actual damages
The court held that the patients' damages theories were conclusory and not actionable for the fiduciary duty, negligence, contract and unjust enrichment claims (ECF No. 46 at 8-10).

For a company that received a letter

  • The ruling favored the health system on every claim at the pleading stage; the Wiretap Act and intrusion claims were dismissed with prejudice, and the court said the other five could be re-filed in a new action.
  • The court decided the Wiretap Act claim on the party exception and on its reading of the crime-tort exception, a question on which other district courts have ruled the other way.
  • The other state-law claims failed for lack of pleaded actual damages; the court did not rest on the absence of a duty and noted that providing medical care could suggest a confidential relationship.
  • Neither order addressed whether the information sent was individually identifiable health information or whether statutory damages were available under the Wiretap Act.

What to check on your own site

  • Check whether the Meta Pixel or similar code runs inside your patient portal or on pages where patients enter information, and what it sends.
  • Record which identifiers, such as a Facebook ID, accompany the events your site sends to advertising platforms.

Later history

The clerk entered judgment dismissing the action on September 3, 2024 (ECF No. 47). On December 10, 2024, the court denied the plaintiffs' motion for reconsideration or leave to amend (ECF No. 51), stating that the Wiretap Act and invasion of privacy counts were dismissed with prejudice and that the other counts, dismissed without prejudice, could be re-filed in a new action. No later docket entry appears on CourtListener, and no appellate decision appears on GovInfo, as of November 10, 2026.

July 29, 2026 · Court rulingDoe v. CRH Healthcare (N.D. Ga. 2026)For defendantsA Georgia federal court dismissed a Wiretap Act claim against an urgent care booking site's operator, holding its party exception applied because the negligence and fiduciary duty torts offered were not separate from the interception.July 24, 2023 · Court rulingKurowski v. Rush System for Health (N.D. Ill. 2023)Mixed rulingPatients' Wiretap Act claim was dismissed because the complaint plausibly alleged only metadata, not health information, but their Illinois Eavesdropping Act claim proceeded against the health system as a principal benefiting from third-party cookies.March 4, 2026 · Court rulingNichols v. PeaceHealth Networks on Demand (W.D. Wash. 2026)For defendantsA Washington federal court dismissed a Wiretap Act claim over Google Analytics on a care provider's appointment website, finding no pleaded facts showing a criminal or tortious purpose separate from the disclosure.March 6, 2026 · Court rulingProgin v. UMass Memorial Health Care (D. Mass. 2026)For defendantsDismissing a Wiretap Act claim against a hospital system, a federal court held allegations of tracker installation and disclosures to Facebook and Google did not show a purpose to commit the specified crimes and torts.September 16, 2024 · Court rulingGay v. Garnet Health (S.D.N.Y. 2024)Mixed rulingPatients' Wiretap Act claim against their hospital survived dismissal because they plausibly alleged it intended to send their identifiable health information to Facebook without consent for commercial purposes, a disclosure HIPAA makes a crime.September 9, 2024 · Court rulingA.D. v. Aspen Dental Management (N.D. Ill. 2024)Mixed rulingAn Illinois federal court let a Wiretap Act claim over a dental website's tracking proceed, holding a marketing purpose could not be detached from the alleged disclosure of health information, but dismissed several state claims.

Published by Privacy Resolve from public records. It does not cover our own matters.

General information only, not legal advice, and not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Laws, deadlines, defenses and outcomes vary by jurisdiction and facts.