Public pages use no advertising trackers. The secure portal uses an essential session cookie and the service providers described in our privacy policy.

Skip to main content

· Court ruling

Gay v. Garnet Health

U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, No. 7:23-cv-06950 (NSR), ECF No. 28

Mixed rulingMotion to dismiss denied in part and granted in part at the pleading stage; the Wiretap Act, fiduciary duty and GBL § 349 claims survived

Primary source: Opinion and order. Checked on November 10, 2026.

Patients' Wiretap Act claim against their hospital survived dismissal because they plausibly alleged it intended to send their identifiable health information to Facebook without consent for commercial purposes, a disclosure HIPAA makes a crime.

What happened

According to the complaint, Garnet Health is a not-for-profit New York corporation that provides health care to about 450,000 patients in Orange, Sullivan and Ulster Counties and is a HIPAA covered entity. It runs garnethealth.org and a Garnet Health MyChart patient portal reached from the site. Two current patients sued in August 2023 on behalf of a proposed class. (ECF No. 28 at 1-2.)

The complaint alleged that Garnet installed the Facebook Tracking Pixel and the Facebook Conversions API on the site. It alleged that the information patients submitted through the site was sent to Facebook along with each user's Facebook ID, and that the Conversions API sent the information to Facebook from Garnet's own server. (ECF No. 28 at 2-3.)

The patients alleged that they used the site to schedule appointments, communicate with doctors, complete patient web forms and review medical and billing records, and that this information reached Facebook. One plaintiff, who had a breast biopsy procedure at Garnet, alleged that after viewing her test results on the site she began seeing advertisements about breast cancer treatment; the other alleged targeted Facebook advertisements about her conditions and treatments. (ECF No. 28 at 3, 7-8.)

The court took the complaint's allegations as true, as it must on a motion to dismiss, and made no findings of fact. (ECF No. 28 at 1.)

What the court held

  1. The court held that the patients plausibly alleged the crime-tort exception, so their Wiretap Act claim survived even though one party's consent is ordinarily enough under the Act. (ECF No. 28 at 5-9)

    Where Defendant’s conduct became problematic is where it intended to transmit Plaintiffs’ PHI and PII without Plaintiffs’ consent for commercial purposes.

    ECF No. 28 at 5
  2. Applying the Second Circuit's test from Caro v. Weintraub, which asks whether the interception was for the purpose of a criminal or tortious act independent of the recording, and noting that the exception is construed narrowly, the court held the complaint alleged an independent act: sending identifiers and the content of patients' communications to Facebook, Google and others. (ECF No. 28 at 5-6)

    The Complaint sufficiently alleges an independent action secondary to the interception

    ECF No. 28 at 6
  3. Following Cooper v. Mount Sinai Health System, Inc. and Kane v. University of Rochester, the court held that allegations that the hospital routinely sent Facebook and Google identifiable information patients entered on the site, including treatment sought, conditions and appointment bookings, followed by targeted advertisements, were enough at the pleading stage to show an intent to commit tortious or unlawful conduct at the time of interception. (ECF No. 28 at 6-9)

    this dynamic evidences an intent on Garnet’s part to commit tortious or unlawful conduct at the time of interception as required to state an ECPA claim

    ECF No. 28 at 8
  4. The court stressed that this was a pleading-stage ruling and that discovery might show the hospital had no criminal or tortious intent. (ECF No. 28 at 9)

    It may be discovery reveals that Defendant had neither a criminal nor tortious intent, but at the motion to dismiss stage Plaintiffs have met their burden for their ECPA claim to survive.

    ECF No. 28 at 9
  5. The court held that the patients stated a claim for breach of fiduciary duty and confidentiality: they were patients, the hospital acquired information about their treatment, that information allegedly went to Facebook in a way that allowed them to be identified, and they did not consent. (ECF No. 28 at 9-12)

    Accordingly, Plaintiffs have successfully stated a breach of fiduciary duty/confidentiality claim.

    ECF No. 28 at 12
  6. The court dismissed the negligence and unjust enrichment claims without prejudice as duplicative of the fiduciary duty claim, and dismissed the implied contract claim without prejudice because the patients did not allege that they viewed the hospital's Notice of Privacy Practices when they engaged its services. It granted leave to amend by October 21, 2024. (ECF No. 28 at 9-14, 16)

    Plaintiff cannot have assented to assurances described in the NOPP if they did not view the Defendant’s policies at the time of contract formation.

    ECF No. 28 at 12
  7. Because the patients withdrew their claim under New York Civil Rights Law sections 50 and 51, the court dismissed it with prejudice. (ECF No. 28 at 12)

  8. The court held that the patients stated a claim under New York General Business Law section 349. The gap between the hospital's stated privacy policies and its alleged transmissions to Facebook was plausibly materially misleading, and allegations that the patients would not have retained the hospital had they known the true facts, and lost the benefit of their bargain, pleaded injury. (ECF No. 28 at 14-16)

    Given the discrepancy between the policies explicitly articulated by the Defendant and the actual conduct carried out regarding Plaintiffs PHI and PII, at this stage in the case, Plaintiffs have sufficiently alleged that the conduct was materially misleading.

    ECF No. 28 at 14

What it did not decide

  • Whether Garnet in fact intended to commit a crime or tort; the court said discovery may show it did not (ECF No. 28 at 9).
  • Whether the information sent was in fact individually identifiable health information; the court relied on the complaint's allegations and on Cooper rather than separately applying HIPAA's definition (ECF No. 28 at 6-8).
  • The merits of the New York Civil Rights Law claim, which the patients withdrew (ECF No. 28 at 12).
  • Article III standing, contents, class certification and statutory damages under 18 U.S.C. § 2520; the opinion does not discuss them.

The tracking involved

Tools

  • Facebook Tracking Pixel (Meta Pixel)
  • Facebook Conversions API (sent from the hospital's server)

Data

  • appointment scheduling and booking attempts
  • communications with doctors
  • patient web forms
  • medical and billing record views, including test results
  • treatment sought and health conditions
  • Facebook ID

How it bears on website tracking claims

Supports: strengthens a website tracking claim on this issue. Limits: narrows or defeats a website tracking claim on this issue. Context: bears on the issue without deciding it either way.

  • Context: Party exception

    Whether the website, as a party to the visit, could consent to the tracking under 18 U.S.C. § 2511(2)(d).

    The court started from the rule that one party's consent is enough under the Wiretap Act, so the claim against the hospital depended on the crime-tort exception (ECF No. 28 at 5). The opinion did not separately analyze whether the hospital was a party; it treated the case, as Cooper had, as turning on the exception (ECF No. 28 at 5-6).

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Supports: Crime-tort exception

    Whether a communication was intercepted for the purpose of a criminal or tortious act, which removes the party exception.

    Under Caro v. Weintraub, the court asked whether the hospital intercepted for the purpose of a criminal or tortious act independent of the recording, and it read the exception narrowly (ECF No. 28 at 5). It held that the alleged sending of identifiers and communication contents to Facebook, Google and others was an independent action secondary to the interception; the allegation it relied on described the data as sent simultaneously to the hospital and to Facebook, Google and others, and the opinion does not discuss that timing (ECF No. 28 at 6). For a website-tracking claim built on a HIPAA predicate, the ruling supports treating the disclosure to an advertising platform as the separate act at the pleading stage.

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Supports: HIPAA

    How HIPAA, its criminal provision at 42 U.S.C. § 1320d-6 and HHS guidance bear on tracking.

    The predicate crime was 42 U.S.C. § 1320d-6, which the court described as making it a criminal violation to disclose individually identifiable health information to another person without the patient's consent (ECF No. 28 at 5). The complaint alleged that Garnet is a HIPAA covered entity (ECF No. 28 at 2), and the opinion does not separately discuss whether HIPAA reaches the hospital or the information. The opinion does not treat the alleged commercial purpose as a reason to dismiss; it said the conduct became problematic where the hospital intended to transmit patient information without consent for commercial purposes (ECF No. 28 at 5-6).

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Supports: Health information

    What counts as individually identifiable health information when it is sent through tracking tools.

    At the pleading stage, the court accepted that information about treatment sought, specific conditions and appointment bookings, sent with a Facebook ID, could support the HIPAA-based claim (ECF No. 28 at 2, 7). It relied on the plaintiffs' accounts of advertisements that followed their use of the site, including breast cancer advertisements that one plaintiff, who had a breast biopsy procedure, began seeing after she viewed her test results on the site (ECF No. 28 at 7-8). It adopted Cooper's reasoning rather than separately applying HIPAA's definition of individually identifiable health information (ECF No. 28 at 6-8).

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Supports: Consumer protection

    Deception and unfair practice claims, such as under the FTC Act and N.Y. General Business Law § 349.

    The GBL § 349 claim survived on the theory that the hospital's stated privacy and security policy said one thing while its site allegedly sent patient information to Facebook (ECF No. 28 at 14). Injury was pleaded by allegations that the patients would not have retained the hospital had they known, and by loss of the benefit of their bargain (ECF No. 28 at 15). The ruling treats a published privacy promise that a site's alleged tracking contradicts as a plausible basis for a GBL § 349 claim at the pleading stage.

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Context: State privacy laws

    Other state privacy statutes and claims, such as medical information and health records acts and the CCPA.

    The patients withdrew their claim under New York Civil Rights Law sections 50 and 51, and the court dismissed it with prejudice without discussing its merits (ECF No. 28 at 12). Separately, the court let a common-law claim for breach of fiduciary duty and confidentiality proceed, based on the physician-patient relationship and an alleged identifying disclosure to Facebook without consent (ECF No. 28 at 9-12).

    All tracker entries on this issue

Arguments it addresses

The website was a party to the communication
The court accepted that one party's consent ordinarily suffices, but held that the alleged intent to disclose patients' health information in violation of HIPAA brought the claim within the crime-tort exception at the pleading stage (ECF No. 28 at 5-9).
The purpose was marketing, not crime
The opinion does not treat a commercial purpose as a reason to dismiss; it said the conduct became problematic where the hospital allegedly intended to transmit patient information without consent for commercial purposes (ECF No. 28 at 5-6).
The disclosure is part of the interception, not a separate act
The court held that the complaint alleged an independent action secondary to the interception: sending identifiers and the content of communications to Facebook, Google and others (ECF No. 28 at 6).
The privacy notice did not create a contract
The court agreed on these pleadings, dismissing the implied contract claim without prejudice because the patients did not allege that they viewed the Notice of Privacy Practices when they engaged the hospital (ECF No. 28 at 12-13).
No injury under GBL § 349
The court held injury was pleaded where the patients alleged they would not have retained the hospital had they known the true facts and that they lost the benefit of their bargain (ECF No. 28 at 15).

For a company that received a letter

  • This was a ruling on the pleadings: the court accepted the complaint's allegations as true and made no finding that the hospital acted unlawfully.
  • The Wiretap Act holding rested on HIPAA's criminal provision, 42 U.S.C. § 1320d-6; the complaint alleged that the hospital is a HIPAA covered entity, and the opinion did not separately analyze whether HIPAA reaches the hospital or the information.
  • The court compared the hospital's published privacy statements with its alleged tracking, and that comparison carried the GBL § 349 claim past dismissal.
  • The parties later stipulated to dismiss the case without prejudice, so no court decided the surviving Wiretap Act, fiduciary duty or GBL § 349 claims on the merits.

What to check on your own site

  • List every page and portal screen where the Meta Pixel or a server-side conversions connection runs, including appointment, form, test result and billing pages, and record which events each one sends.
  • Compare what your privacy policy and notice of privacy practices say about sharing with third parties against what your site's tags actually send.

Later history

The docket shows no amended complaint after the September 16, 2024 order, and Garnet answered the original complaint on October 28, 2024 (ECF No. 31). That order provided that, if no amended complaint was timely filed, the claims dismissed without prejudice would be deemed dismissed with prejudice (ECF No. 28 at 16). The parties later stipulated to dismiss the action voluntarily and without prejudice under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 41(a)(1)(A)(ii), each side bearing its own costs, and the court so ordered on July 25, 2025 (ECF No. 47). The stipulation gives no reason. No later docket entry appears on CourtListener as of November 10, 2026.

July 30, 2024 · Court rulingCooper v. Mount Sinai Health System (S.D.N.Y. 2024)For plaintiffsA federal court let a Wiretap Act claim over a health system's Meta Pixel proceed, holding that alleged disclosure of identifiable patient health information for commercial ends plausibly invoked the crime-tort exception through HIPAA.March 19, 2024 · Court rulingKane v. University of Rochester (W.D.N.Y. 2024)Mixed rulingA Schedule an Appointment click on a physician's profile, sent to Facebook with the user's Facebook ID, was plausibly individually identifiable health information, so a Wiretap Act claim proceeded under the crime-tort exception.June 25, 2025 · Court rulingPattison v. Teladoc Health (S.D.N.Y. 2025)For plaintiffsA New York federal court let a Wiretap Act claim against Teladoc proceed, holding alleged interception of users' health information to disclose it without authorization for marketing, an act HIPAA punishes, invokes the crime-tort exception.September 9, 2024 · Court rulingA.D. v. Aspen Dental Management (N.D. Ill. 2024)Mixed rulingAn Illinois federal court let a Wiretap Act claim over a dental website's tracking proceed, holding a marketing purpose could not be detached from the alleged disclosure of health information, but dismissed several state claims.August 28, 2024 · Court rulingT.D. v. Piedmont Healthcare (N.D. Ga. 2024)For defendantsA Georgia federal court dismissed patients' Meta Pixel claims against a health system, applying the Wiretap Act's party exception and holding there is no intrusion when patients give information to their own provider.September 30, 2026 · Court rulingNova v. Boston Medical Center (D. Mass. 2026)For defendantsA federal court dismissed a hospital website Wiretap Act claim, holding the allegations supported only an inference of commercial purpose and not that the data was kept in a HIPAA record set.

Published by Privacy Resolve from public records. It does not cover our own matters.

General information only, not legal advice, and not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Laws, deadlines, defenses and outcomes vary by jurisdiction and facts.