Public pages use no advertising trackers. The secure portal uses an essential session cookie and the service providers described in our privacy policy.

Skip to main content

· Court ruling

Nova v. Boston Medical Center Corporation

U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts, No. 1:25-cv-10105-GAO, ECF No. 49

For defendantsMotion to dismiss the Wiretap Act count granted; leave to amend denied as futile; state-law claims remanded

Primary source: Opinion and order. Checked on November 10, 2026.

A federal court dismissed a hospital website Wiretap Act claim, holding the allegations supported only an inference of commercial purpose and not that the data was kept in a HIPAA record set.

What happened

Elizabeth Nova filed a putative class action in the Business Litigation Session of the Massachusetts Superior Court, and Boston Medical Center Corporation removed it to federal court. She alleged that the hospital secretly allowed third parties to intercept her communications with it about protected health information through tracking technologies hidden on almost all pages of its public website, disclosing her information to third parties such as Google and Facebook without her knowledge or consent (ECF No. 49 at 1).

The amended complaint alleged tracking on the publicly available login page of the hospital's patient portal, but not on non-public pages inside the portal (ECF No. 49 at 4-5). As the hospital pointed out in its motion, the amended complaint also alleged that the hospital facilitated the interception for business reasons and for its commercial advantage, to increase revenue from existing patients and gain new patients (ECF No. 49 at 3).

Nova argued that the interception was for the purpose of violating HIPAA's criminal provision, 42 U.S.C. § 1320d-6, and several Massachusetts torts, through intentional disclosure contrary to the hospital's own published policies and users' reasonable expectations of privacy (ECF No. 49 at 3-4). After briefing, she moved to amend. Her proposed complaint alleged that the hospital sent Google the communications a person uses to find a doctor on its website, that Google tied them to the person's real-world identity, and that both used them for commercial and marketing purposes, including the hospital's targeted advertising on Google's platforms (ECF No. 49 at 5).

What the court held

  1. The motion turned on the crime-tort exception, and purpose is an essential element. Under the First Circuit's decision in United States v. Cassiere, the party invoking the exception must show that the primary motivation, or a determinative factor, for the interception was to commit a criminal, tortious or other injurious act. (ECF No. 49 at 2)

    The threshold question presented by BMC’s motion to dismiss the amended complaint is whether Nova has plausibly alleged that the ECPA’s crime-tort exception applies.

    ECF No. 49 at 2
  2. The plaintiff had to plead facts showing that the hospital acted purposefully, not merely knowingly or negligently, to commit a criminal or tortious act independent of the act of recording itself. (ECF No. 49 at 3)

  3. The amended complaint did not plausibly allege that the hospital was primarily or determinatively motivated to violate the privacy of its patients or other website users; it supported only an inference of a commercial purpose. (ECF No. 49 at 3-4)

    the facts alleged in the amended complaint merely support an inference that BMC’s purpose in deploying the tracking technologies was commercial in nature, namely for its own business and marketing interests

    ECF No. 49 at 4
  4. Relying on the report and recommendation in Doe v. Lawrence General Hospital, the court held that HIPAA's criminal provision does not reach health information in the abstract but governs information a covered entity maintains in a record set, and that allegations that tracking tools loaded in the background of the website intercepted communications as they were sent, including on the portal's public login page, did not support that inference. (ECF No. 49 at 4-5)

    Those allegations do not support an inference that the intercepted information was part of a HIPAA-regulated patient file or record set that a hospital like BMC would maintain.

    ECF No. 49 at 4
  5. Leave to amend was denied as futile. The proposed complaint still alleged targeted advertising and marketing, a commercial purpose; it still alleged that the information was intercepted as it was sent; and it said the plaintiff could not know before discovery whether tracking ran inside the portal. (ECF No. 49 at 5-7)

    These allegations of “targeted advertising” and “marketing purposes” point to a business or commercial interest, not a criminal or tortious purpose, behind the challenged interceptions.

    ECF No. 49 at 5
  6. The advertisements shown in the proposed complaint appeared to promote the hospital's own services, so on their face they fell outside HIPAA's regulatory definition of marketing. (ECF No. 49 at 6)

    Notably, the advertisements depicted are apparently designed to market and promote BMC’s own services.

    ECF No. 49 at 6
  7. With the only federal claim dismissed, the court declined to exercise jurisdiction over the state-law claims and remanded them to the Massachusetts Superior Court. (ECF No. 49 at 7)

  8. The court noted that other sessions of the same court had addressed the question, citing Doe v. Children's Hospital Corp. as reaching a different conclusion. (ECF No. 49 at 2 n.1)

    This question has been addressed by several other sessions of this District Court.

    ECF No. 49 at 2 n.1

What it did not decide

  • The Massachusetts state-law claims, which were remanded without a ruling on their merits (ECF No. 49 at 7).
  • Other elements of a Wiretap Act claim, such as interception and contents; the court decided the motion on the crime-tort exception (ECF No. 49 at 2-5).
  • How the HIPAA analysis would apply to tracking on non-public pages inside the patient portal, which the complaint did not allege (ECF No. 49 at 5-6).

The tracking involved

Tools

  • third-party tracking technologies sending data to companies such as Google and Facebook

Data

  • communications on pages of the hospital's public website
  • activity on the patient portal's public login page
  • find-a-doctor communications (proposed amended complaint)

How it bears on website tracking claims

Supports: strengthens a website tracking claim on this issue. Limits: narrows or defeats a website tracking claim on this issue. Context: bears on the issue without deciding it either way.

  • Limits: Crime-tort exception

    Whether a communication was intercepted for the purpose of a criminal or tortious act, which removes the party exception.

    The court treated allegations that a hospital used tracking tools for marketing and targeted advertising as showing a commercial purpose, not a criminal or tortious one, and dismissed at the pleading stage under the First Circuit's primary-motivation-or-determinative-factor test from Cassiere. That reasoning runs against a claim that relies on advertising use alone to show a tortious purpose. The court acknowledged that another session of the same court reached a different conclusion.

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Context: Party exception

    Whether the website, as a party to the visit, could consent to the tracking under 18 U.S.C. § 2511(2)(d).

    The court analyzed the claim under the party provision of 18 U.S.C. § 2511(2)(d), framing the threshold question as whether the crime-tort exception applied. The opinion does not discuss any dispute over whether the hospital was a party, so the case turned on purpose.

    All tracker entries on this issue

  • Limits: HIPAA

    How HIPAA, its criminal provision at 42 U.S.C. § 1320d-6 and HHS guidance bear on tracking.

    The court read 42 U.S.C. § 1320d-6 to govern information a covered entity maintains in a record set, and held that allegations of interception as communications were sent, including on a portal's public login page, did not support that inference. It also treated a hospital's ads for its own services as outside HIPAA's definition of marketing. Under this reading, a HIPAA predicate depends on allegations tying the intercepted information to records the hospital keeps, which the complaint did not make.

    All tracker entries on this issue

Arguments it addresses

The tools were used for marketing, not to commit a crime or tort
The court agreed on these allegations, holding that targeted advertising and marketing point to a business purpose, not a criminal or tortious one (ECF No. 49 at 3-5).
HIPAA's criminal provision does not cover public website data
The court held that section 1320d-6 governs information a covered entity maintains in a record set, and that allegations of interception as communications were sent, including on the portal's public login page, did not support that inference (ECF No. 49 at 4-6).
Ads for the hospital's own services are not HIPAA marketing
The court said the ads shown in the proposed complaint appeared to promote the hospital's own services and so, on their face, fell outside HIPAA's regulatory definition of marketing (ECF No. 49 at 6).
Purpose can be decided on a motion to dismiss
The court decided it on the pleadings, while noting that another session of the same court had reached a different conclusion (ECF No. 49 at 2 n.1, 3-4).

For a company that received a letter

  • This is a district court ruling on the pleadings, and the court itself noted that another judge of the same court reached a different conclusion on the purpose question.
  • The court relied on the complaint's own description of the hospital's purpose as business, marketing and revenue.
  • The court's HIPAA analysis turned on the lack of allegations tying the intercepted information to records the hospital maintains, including the absence of allegations about tracking inside the patient portal, as opposed to its public login page.
  • The state-law claims were not decided and went back to the Massachusetts Superior Court.

What to check on your own site

  • Check whether tracking tags load on your patient portal's public login page and on pages after sign-in.
  • Check whether a find-a-doctor search sends the search terms or the doctor's name to an advertising or analytics vendor.
  • Check whether what your privacy policy says about sharing matches what your tags send.

Later history

A notice of appeal was filed on October 29, 2026 (ECF No. 52), and the First Circuit assigned the appeal a case number on October 30, 2026.

September 21, 2026 · Court rulingDoe v. Lawrence General Hospital (D. Mass. 2026)For defendantsA federal court dismissed a Wiretap Act claim over a hospital's website tracking, holding the allegations supported at most an inference of awareness that it might disclose private information, not a primary or determinative motive.March 6, 2026 · Court rulingProgin v. UMass Memorial Health Care (D. Mass. 2026)For defendantsDismissing a Wiretap Act claim against a hospital system, a federal court held allegations of tracker installation and disclosures to Facebook and Google did not show a purpose to commit the specified crimes and torts.March 19, 2026 · Court rulingDoe v. Baystate Health System (D. Mass. 2026)For plaintiffsA Massachusetts federal court refused to dismiss a patient's Wiretap Act claim over a hospital's Meta Pixel and Google Analytics, holding she plausibly alleged an interception for the purpose of violating the state privacy statute.July 1, 2026 · Court rulingDoe v. Children's Hospital Corporation (D. Mass. 2026)For plaintiffsAdopting Baystate's reasoning, a federal court in Massachusetts denied a children's hospital's motion to dismiss Wiretap Act and state-law claims over Google and Facebook tracking on its website and patient portal.August 14, 2026 · Court rulingVita v. Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center (D. Mass. 2026)For plaintiffsA Massachusetts federal court let a hospital website user who was not a patient pursue her Wiretap Act claim, with the state privacy statute as the separate wrong, dismissing only her breach of confidence claim.September 4, 2026 · Court rulingHanson v. Sanford Health (D. Minn. 2026)Mixed rulingA Minnesota federal court let a patient's Wiretap Act claim proceed on an alleged HIPAA disclosure, rejecting profit-motive and independence defenses, but dismissed his intrusion and state health records claims with prejudice.

Published by Privacy Resolve from public records. It does not cover our own matters.

General information only, not legal advice, and not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Laws, deadlines, defenses and outcomes vary by jurisdiction and facts.