· Court ruling
Doe v. The Children's Hospital Corporation
U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts, No. 1:25-cv-10343-PBS, ECF No. 82
Primary source: Order. Checked on November 10, 2026.
Adopting Baystate's reasoning, a federal court in Massachusetts denied a children's hospital's motion to dismiss Wiretap Act and state-law claims over Google and Facebook tracking on its website and patient portal.
What happened
A parent, suing for herself and her minor children on behalf of proposed classes, alleged that The Children's Hospital Corporation (Boston Children's) used tracking technologies provided by Google and Facebook on its website to intercept communications between patients and the hospital and to disclose them to those companies without the patients' knowledge or consent.
As the order summarized the complaint, the intercepted communications included clicks on public pages about specific types of medical care, keyword searches on the site, searches and filtering on the 'Find a Doctor' page, and appointment requests made through that page and a separate form. The complaint also alleged that the tools captured clicks inside the hospital's online patient portal, including on the log-in page, a 'Diagnostic Tests' page, a 'Billing Summary' page and a page for renewing medications, but it did not allege that any test results were disclosed.
The complaint alleged that Google, Facebook and the hospital used the communications to serve targeted advertisements, that the disclosures violated HIPAA, the Massachusetts privacy statute (M.G.L. c. 214, § 1B) and promises the hospital made on its website, and that both Google and Facebook warned that consent should be obtained but none was. Besides the Wiretap Act count, the second amended complaint pleaded six state-law claims: the Massachusetts privacy statute, breach of fiduciary duty, negligence, breach of confidence, breach of contract and unjust enrichment.
What the court held
The court framed the threshold issue as whether the complaint stated a plausible Wiretap Act claim, noting that judges in the District of Massachusetts had reached different results on whether similar hospital tracking falls within the crime-tort exception. Goulart v. Cape Cod Healthcare, Inc., Doe v. Lawrence General Hospital and Progin v. UMass Memorial Health Care, Inc. found the exception inapplicable, while Doe v. Baystate Health System, Inc. held that it applies. (ECF No. 82 at 3-4)
No circuit has ruled on this issue so far.
ECF No. 82 at 4 After reviewing that case law, the court held that the complaint stated a plausible Wiretap Act claim for the reasons given in Baystate. (ECF No. 82 at 4)
the Court concludes that Plaintiff has stated a plausible claim under the ECPA
ECF No. 82 at 4 The court described Baystate as holding that allegations of a hospital sharing patients' searches, appointment requests and portal log-ins with Meta and Google, without their knowledge or consent, plausibly stated that the interception and disclosure were independent acts taken for the purpose of committing a tort, a violation of the Massachusetts privacy statute, with the hospital's primary or determinative motive left as a question of fact. It reached the same conclusion here. (ECF No. 82 at 4-5)
This Court reaches the same conclusion in this case.
ECF No. 82 at 5 The six state-law claims survived largely for the reasons explained in Doe v. Tenet Healthcare Corp., 731 F. Supp. 3d 142 (D. Mass. 2024), and the motion to dismiss was denied. (ECF No. 82 at 1 n.1, 5)
What it did not decide
- Which purpose actually drove the hospital (marketing, an unlawful purpose or both); under the reasoning the order adopted, that is a question of fact.
- Whether the disclosures violated HIPAA, which the plaintiff also argued; the order rested on Baystate's reasoning, which relied on the Massachusetts privacy statute.
- Whether the alleged communications were contents, or which categories count as health information; the order did not analyze those elements separately.
- The question at the circuit level: the order noted that no circuit had ruled and that an appeal in Goulart v. Cape Cod Healthcare, Inc., No. 25-1672 (1st Cir.), had been filed; that appeal was argued on April 6, 2026, and the First Circuit's opinion search showed no decision in it on November 10, 2026.
- Class certification, liability and damages.
The tracking involved
Tools
- Google Analytics (admitted in the hospital's later answer, on public pages and certain patient portal pages)
- Facebook Pixel, also called the Meta Pixel (the later answer admits it was deployed on the public website and later removed)
- DoubleClick (admitted in the hospital's later answer)
Data
- Clicks on public pages about specific types of medical care
- Keyword searches on the site
- Searches and filters on the Find a Doctor page
- Appointment requests
- Clicks in the patient portal on the log-in, Diagnostic Tests, Billing Summary and medication renewal pages
How it bears on website tracking claims
Supports: strengthens a website tracking claim on this issue. Limits: narrows or defeats a website tracking claim on this issue. Context: bears on the issue without deciding it either way.
Supports: Crime-tort exception
Whether a communication was intercepted for the purpose of a criminal or tortious act, which removes the party exception.
The order adopted Baystate's view that a hospital's interception of website communications and its disclosure of them to advertising platforms can be independent acts, taken for the purpose of committing a tort under the Massachusetts privacy statute, and that the hospital's primary or determinative motive is a fact question at the pleading stage. The order is five pages long and rests on Baystate's reasoning rather than new analysis. It acknowledged that other judges in the same district had dismissed similar claims and that no circuit had ruled, so it reflects one side of a division within the District of Massachusetts. Later in 2026, two other judges of the court cited this order and dismissed similar claims: in Lawrence General on September 21 and in Nova, a suit against Boston Medical Center, on September 30.
Context: Party exception
Whether the website, as a party to the visit, could consent to the tracking under 18 U.S.C. § 2511(2)(d).
The order recited the Wiretap Act's rule that a party to a communication, or a person with a party's prior consent, may intercept it, and decided the motion on the crime-tort exception, which removes that protection when a communication is intercepted for the purpose of committing a criminal or tortious act. It did not separately discuss whether the hospital or the vendors were parties to the communications.
Supports: State privacy laws
Other state privacy statutes and claims, such as medical information and health records acts and the CCPA.
Through Baystate, the Massachusetts privacy statute, M.G.L. c. 214, § 1B, supplied the tort for the crime-tort exception, and the statutory privacy claim itself survived alongside claims for breach of fiduciary duty, negligence, breach of confidence, breach of contract and unjust enrichment. The order relied on Doe v. Tenet Healthcare Corp. for the state claims without separate analysis.
Context: Health information
What counts as individually identifiable health information when it is sent through tracking tools.
The order described the alleged communications as clicks on pages about specific types of medical care, site and physician searches, appointment requests and clicks inside the patient portal. It did not decide whether any of these categories is health information under any statute, and it noted that, for the 'Diagnostic Tests' portal page, the complaint alleged that a click on the page was intercepted but not that any test results were disclosed.
Arguments it addresses
- The website was a party to the communication
- The order recited the party and consent exception but held that the complaint plausibly invoked the crime-tort exception, which removes that protection.
- The tracking was for marketing, not to commit a tort
- Following Baystate, the order treated whether the hospital acted for marketing, an unlawful purpose or both as a question of fact that cannot be resolved on a motion to dismiss.
- Other judges in this district have dismissed similar claims
- The order cited Goulart, Lawrence General and Progin and chose to follow Baystate, noting that no circuit had ruled on the question.
- A page visit is not health information
- The order did not decide that question; it noted that the complaint alleged a click on a 'Diagnostic Tests' portal page but no disclosure of test results, and it denied the motion without saying what weight that carried.
For a company that received a letter
- This is a pleading-stage order that accepts the complaint's allegations as true; it makes no finding that the hospital acted unlawfully or is liable.
- Judges in the District of Massachusetts have divided on the crime-tort exception for hospital website tracking, and this order sides with Baystate while citing the decisions that went the other way.
- Under the reasoning the order adopted, an advertising or analytics motive does not by itself defeat, at the pleading stage, a claim that the interception was made for the purpose of committing a tort.
- The alleged communications included clicks inside a patient portal, such as on billing and medication renewal pages, even without any alleged disclosure of test results.
What to check on your own site
- Check whether advertising or analytics tags fire on physician searches and filters, and whether the search words appear in the page address or event data sent to vendors.
- Check whether any third-party tag loads on patient portal pages, including the log-in page, billing summaries and medication renewal pages.
- Check what an appointment request form sends to vendors when a visitor opens, fills in or submits it.
Later history
The hospital answered the second amended complaint on August 7, 2026, admitting that Google Analytics and the Facebook Pixel have been deployed on pages of its public website and denying the remaining allegations of that paragraph (ECF No. 85 at 1, para. 2); it also admitted that Google Analytics was used on certain pages of its patient portal, while denying that this violated any applicable law (ECF No. 85 at 20, para. 127). A protective order was entered on September 23, 2026 (ECF Nos. 88, 89). The docket on CourtListener, read November 10, 2026, shows no dismissal or judgment.
Sources
- Order on motion to dismiss (ECF No. 82)
- Answer and affirmative defenses to the second amended complaint (ECF No. 85)
- Docket (CourtListener)
- Goulart v. Cape Cod Healthcare, Inc., No. 25-1672, First Circuit docket (CourtListener)
- Doe v. Baystate Health System, Inc., memorandum and order whose reasoning the order adopted (ECF No. 42)
Related rulings
Published by Privacy Resolve from public records. It does not cover our own matters.
General information only, not legal advice, and not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Laws, deadlines, defenses and outcomes vary by jurisdiction and facts.